Bad Speler wrote:I've tried adding a blur to the river mouths using photoshop. Please keep in mind, from now on this will be a bit of a nuisance updating, as I have to import it into photoshop each time and blur it again each time.
I don't follow... are you not working from a photoshop file to begin with?
Anyway, my thoughts... overall I like it. Straightforward, should play well. Little big regions in the center, small bonuses around the outside.
I like the playfulness of many of your elements: the bridges, the mountains, the color choice, and the type face. Some elements don't play along, however, especially the symbols in what would be France. When you have some serious elements it makes the less serious elements look like they aren't that way intentionally.
My biggest concern is with the borders. The territory borders are very fine, while the borders between regions are very heavy. It gives the impression that they are unpassables, which of course they aren't. I would prefer to see all of the borders the same weight, or at least more similar than they are at present. The color difference alone would be enough to define the bonus regions.
And are there a couple of stray lines going through the image? One cuts right through Iberia.
OK, I gave you enough headaches for one post - I look forward to seeing this progress!