Page 8 of 10

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 1:54 pm
by benga
Keefie wrote:If rules are for the start of the league then it's a bit disappointing to hear you support the idea of only the top 10 being invited to the next RL :( Surely that should have been announced at the start of the competition.


this will not start from RL4, no worries there ;)

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 7:36 pm
by hopalong
Game 13119503

MB has 1 MIA

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 8:14 pm
by Chariot of Fire
Qwert wrote:>>based on results in RL top 10 teams have a secured place while the last 4 dropped and cannot compete in next RL while 4 brand new clans enter, that way all clans would be fighting hard even at later stages.<<
this its best option. first then will get invitations, and if someone from this 10 decline, then you add new clan .

chariot of fire
What you have said doesn't make any sense (or at least I cannot work out what you mean in your first paragraph). As for your second statement - well that's simply not true. The majority of football leagues work on Points followed by Goal Difference (thanks Keefie for posting that info).

It may be a moot point anyway if benga's not really interested in the rules regarding a points tie, but it is worth noting the following:

Team A finish with 45 points and a record of 185 wins and 7 losses
Team B finish with 45 points and a record of 105 wins and 87 losses

Under the current rules Team B could be the winner. I just don't think that's fair, not when it is a league and a whole season's results should be taken into consideration.

btw benga, I know I said it before, but your off-site table of Matches/Results/Standings was excellent and I'm sure would be a welcome continuation in the next edition of this tourney.

I must say that benga are right here> rules are build before start of league, and everybody agree when they join.
Its can not change rules now in last round, because will be ruined Tournament integrity .
In next RL, better study rules and make suggestions, how to improve some rules, if you think are not good.


Qwert, you misunderstand. No-one is trying to change the rules of the existing tournament. Benga asked for suggestions how the next Random League could be improved and that is what I was replying to.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Fri Aug 23, 2013 5:30 pm
by t4mcr53s2
if duration too long why not start matches two weeks apart? rough on the war makers and freemiums , but will have last of 17 start 4 months after opening match.... great tournament btw

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 9:08 am
by artur1
Buhu, big surprice to see the same players whine as usually. If you have a problem with the rules bring it up before the start or after it is finish. One thing for sure, had TOFU been in the driverseat you would not have had this conversation. Thanks for the work of hosting.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 9:49 am
by Chariot of Fire
benga wrote:If I could have some feedback on the lenght of the league and any other insights, possible improvements, etc., that would be nice.

Have some things in mind, but need to hear from any of you too.

thx


benga asked this question, so I gave feedback as to possible improvements.

So why is artur1 posting this nonsense?

Buhu, big surprice to see the same players whine as usually. If you have a problem with the rules bring it up before the start or after it is finish. One thing for sure, had TOFU been in the driverseat you would not have had this conversation.


No-one is whining, no-one has a problem with the rules as they are and no-one is trying to change anything. This suggestion is being brought up before the start of the next tournament. Maybe you just didn't bother reading the thread properly.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:21 am
by artur1
Chariot of Fire wrote:
benga wrote:If I could have some feedback on the lenght of the league and any other insights, possible improvements, etc., that would be nice.

Have some things in mind, but need to hear from any of you too.

thx


benga asked this question, so I gave feedback as to possible improvements.

So why is artur1 posting this nonsense?

Buhu, big surprice to see the same players whine as usually. If you have a problem with the rules bring it up before the start or after it is finish. One thing for sure, had TOFU been in the driverseat you would not have had this conversation.


No-one is whining, no-one has a problem with the rules as they are and no-one is trying to change anything. This suggestion is being brought up before the start of the next tournament. Maybe you just didn't bother reading the thread properly.

Fair enough chariot I do apologize to you and the whole TOFO clan. I know many of you you and you are a great bunch of guys. I should not have make this personal. It might have been a bit excessive. I had a few bad rounds maybe you got to take some shit for it. However why even bring this matter up at this point at all?

Anyways, I really dont want to attack some one on the personal level as I did, sorry for that.
/Art

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:26 am
by artur1
artur1 wrote:
Chariot of Fire wrote:
benga wrote:If I could have some feedback on the lenght of the league and any other insights, possible improvements, etc., that would be nice.

Have some things in mind, but need to hear from any of you too.

thx


benga asked this question, so I gave feedback as to possible improvements.

So why is artur1 posting this nonsense?

Buhu, big surprice to see the same players whine as usually. If you have a problem with the rules bring it up before the start or after it is finish. One thing for sure, had TOFU been in the driverseat you would not have had this conversation.


No-one is whining, no-one has a problem with the rules as they are and no-one is trying to change anything. This suggestion is being brought up before the start of the next tournament. Maybe you just didn't bother reading the thread properly.

Fair enough chariot I do apologize to you and the whole TOFO clan. I know many of you you and you are a great bunch of guys. I should not have make this personal. It might have been a bit excessive. I had a few bad rounds maybe you got to take some shit for it. However why even bring this matter up at this point at all?

Anyways, I really dont want to attack some one on the personal level as I did, sorry for that.
/Art

And good luck in you remaning game and the cup, might see you there.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:32 am
by Chariot of Fire
Cheers mate, appreciate the reply.

And the reason it was brought up is because the TO was asking for any improvements that he thought could be made, so it was simply a suggestion for RL2.

Don't know why I should care though really, we won't be in it.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:42 am
by artur1
Chariot of Fire wrote:Cheers mate, appreciate the reply.

And the reason it was brought up is because the TO was asking for any improvements that he thought could be made, so it was simply a suggestion for RL2.

Don't know why I should care though really, we won't be in it.

cheers, yeah you probably didn't deserve that.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 11:47 am
by benga
Just wanted some observations, thx all of you that did so.



FALL-WAR 6-6 2013-08-20

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 11:55 am
by Qwert
Chariot of Fire wrote:
benga wrote:If I could have some feedback on the lenght of the league and any other insights, possible improvements, etc., that would be nice.

Have some things in mind, but need to hear from any of you too.

thx


benga asked this question, so I gave feedback as to possible improvements.

So why is artur1 posting this nonsense?

Buhu, big surprice to see the same players whine as usually. If you have a problem with the rules bring it up before the start or after it is finish. One thing for sure, had TOFU been in the driverseat you would not have had this conversation.


No-one is whining, no-one has a problem with the rules as they are and no-one is trying to change anything. This suggestion is being brought up before the start of the next tournament. Maybe you just didn't bother reading the thread properly.

dont notice that, that why all this confusion.
Maybe its better to open new topic, in clan main forum, for discussion about improvement.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:34 pm
by chapcrap
Just reporting that I sent this message with over 21 hours left in my turn...

-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Classic Cities: Istanbul for 2013 [RL] Random League III
Date: Sat Aug 24, 2013 10:33 pm
From: chapcrap
To: dunewarr, BADPAT, didosdildo

chapcrap wrote:12 hour fog rule - Game 13132558

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Thu Aug 29, 2013 1:18 am
by benga
RET-MD 5-7 2013-08-26

G1-HH 8-4 2013-08-28

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 4:01 am
by benga
TFFS-LOW 8-4 2013-08-30

Can't seem to find any games, not sure what is happening, all the links are broken.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 8:25 am
by Armandolas
benga wrote:TFFS-LOW 8-4 2013-08-30

Can't seem to find any games, not sure what is happening, all the links are broken.


An update to game finder, was made recently

Now when u find a game, then the url comes allready filled so i can easily past it like this

http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 8:34 am
by benga
Armandolas wrote:
benga wrote:TFFS-LOW 8-4 2013-08-30

Can't seem to find any games, not sure what is happening, all the links are broken.


An update to game finder, was made recently

Now when u find a game, then the url comes allready filled so i can easily past it like this

http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find


this doesn't explain why I can't see page 2 on game list of RL

something is terribly wrong with game finder

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 10:08 am
by Leehar
benga wrote:
Armandolas wrote:
benga wrote:TFFS-LOW 8-4 2013-08-30

Can't seem to find any games, not sure what is happening, all the links are broken.


An update to game finder, was made recently

Now when u find a game, then the url comes allready filled so i can easily past it like this

http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find


this doesn't explain why I can't see page 2 on game list of RL

something is terribly wrong with game finder


Ah ok, http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find doesn't let you go to next page? (no matching games found?)

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 10:59 am
by benga
Leehar wrote:
benga wrote:
Armandolas wrote:
benga wrote:TFFS-LOW 8-4 2013-08-30

Can't seem to find any games, not sure what is happening, all the links are broken.


An update to game finder, was made recently

Now when u find a game, then the url comes allready filled so i can easily past it like this

http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find


this doesn't explain why I can't see page 2 on game list of RL

something is terribly wrong with game finder


Ah ok, http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?g ... &mode=find doesn't let you go to next page? (no matching games found?)


EXACTLY

ah how am I suppose to know uid number in advance
only when I can get it is when games are made or?

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 11:17 am
by Armandolas
what i failed to explain: Update»»BUG»»no fix yet

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Sun Sep 01, 2013 11:05 pm
by benga
FOED-ID 9-3 2013-09-01

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Tue Sep 10, 2013 6:36 am
by benga
SOH-MB 8-4 2013-09-08

DYN-WAR 6-6 2013-09-05

G1-TNC 9-3 2013-09-10

SOH-OSA 8-4 2013-09-04

FOED-MB 10-2 2013-09-10

TNC-ID 5-7 2013-09-10

Game 13067418 This win and LOW has won the league!!

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Tue Sep 10, 2013 6:49 am
by Crazyirishman
Thanks Benga for doing such a great job keeping everything updated and running this so smoothly. This was a great competition and it was fun playing all the clans involved. I know that we can't wait for the next one.

Re: Random League III - round 17

PostPosted: Tue Sep 10, 2013 7:26 am
by Chariot of Fire
Agreed mate. And hats off to LoW for topping the table. I believe they sat there and held it throughout the tourney, with a few nipping at their heels, but never relinquished it. A sure sign of good things to come with such consistency, so well done you guys =D>