Page 1 of 1

problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 12:38 pm
by hajduk1911
this is the game ...

Game 20561280

I lost 9 to 1 to a guy in first turn (3 fields with 3 troops each) then he made some reinforcements (poly 4) then I lost again with same result 9 to 1 ...

Now that is ok but my dice stats for last 5 battles with him say

for me
Assault +8%
Defend +28%
Total +23%

for him
Assault +3%
Defend 0%
Total +2%

It almost looks like dice stats have been reversed

I also think I didn't have that good assault (+8) but I can accept that it is my personal feeling. BUT for my defend stats I have calculated everything. It doesn't add up. Please fix these stats because if you don't do that I will lose my trust in dice being fair and stop playing this game forever ...

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 12:50 pm
by hajduk1911
Hope you understand how important this is ...
I have already dropped all my new games that I created ... If you don't fix dice stats I will stop playing CC forever

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 3:07 pm
by Jdsizzleslice
hajduk1911 wrote:this is the game ...

Game 20561280

I lost 9 to 1 to a guy in first turn (3 fields with 3 troops each) then he made some reinforcements (poly 4) then I lost again with same result 9 to 1 ...

Now that is ok but my dice stats for last 5 battles with him say

for me
Assault +8%
Defend +28%
Total +23%

for him
Assault +3%
Defend 0%
Total +2%

It almost looks like dice stats have been reversed

I also think I didn't have that good assault (+8) but I can accept that it is my personal feeling. BUT for my defend stats I have calculated everything. It doesn't add up. Please fix these stats because if you don't do that I will lose my trust in dice being fair and stop playing this game forever ...

You're looking at the last 5 dice battle rolls, when you should be looking at the last 20 or 25 (due to the fact that you lost two 9v1's, which would equal 18 total troops).


for you:
Assault +7%
Defend -17%
Total -5%

for him
Assault -2%
Defend +6%
Total +4%

These statistics for 20 rolls are more representative of what you are seeing instead of the past 5 rolls.

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 3:13 pm
by Jdsizzleslice
In my opinion, what you should be really looking at is Dice Battle Outcomes. This statistic tells you if you win or lose a roll, not what you roll. This can be more representative of how much you are winning versus losing rolls. The last 25 outcomes show you losing a lot of 3v2s, not 3v1s.

The dice statistics are not malfunctioning.

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 3:33 pm
by hajduk1911
That is exactly what I wanted to ask you ... First of all ... the numbers here are incorrect .
secondly you get the same numbers for 20 and 25 battles witch is impossible ...

Image

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 3:47 pm
by Jdsizzleslice
hajduk1911 wrote:That is exactly what I wanted to ask you ... First of all ... the numbers here are incorrect .
secondly you get the same numbers for 20 and 25 battles witch is impossible ...

To your first point, would you be willing to provide snaps when the game ends? I assume you're saying they are incorrect because in this game you have not rolled versus many regions with 2 or more troops? The sequence of events is pretty important in what you are trying to describe. We would need more information from you and from the game log in order to corroborate your claims here.

Secondly, you can if you don't break the threshold for outcomes. If you only have 18 outcomes, then the 20 will be the same for your 25. You have only had 4 turns in this game, so it's completely plausible for your recent dice outcomes versus your opponent to be under 20.

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 4:01 pm
by hajduk1911
Do you have history of dice rolls ? I can't be 100% sure as this is fog ...
Is there a way you can somehow check if everything adds up ?

Is that recent or last 25. Big difference as we played more games against each other so the numbers should be different for last 20 and 25 ...

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 4:10 pm
by Jdsizzleslice
hajduk1911 wrote:Do you have history of dice rolls ? I can't be 100% sure as this is fog ...
Is there a way you can somehow check if everything adds up ?

Is that recent or last 25. Big difference as we played more games against each other so the numbers should be different for last 20 and 25 ...

I cannot see a history of rolls besides what is in your dice statistics. Your snaps included with game log would help alleviate some of the mystery (when the game has been completed).

And the dice outcomes says recent on the page. So if you haven't played in a while they more than likely have reset for your 25 and fewer outcomes.

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 4:24 pm
by hajduk1911
I can't see his snapshots ... but from my snapshots it actually might be possible that dice are correct ...

I'm just sad that there is no history of dice ...

for example
12/25/2020 15:30 assault 3 vs 2 -- won 2 lost 0
12/25/2020 15:35 auto assault 3 vs 2 -- won 3 lost1 -- 3 vs 1 won 1 lost 1

etc

Re: problem with dice stats

PostPosted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 4:27 pm
by Jdsizzleslice
hajduk1911 wrote:I can't see his snapshots ... but from my snapshots it actually might be possible that dice are correct ...

I'm just sad that there is no history of dice ...

for example
12/25/2020 15:30 assault 3 vs 2 -- won 2 lost 0
12/25/2020 15:35 auto assault 3 vs 2 -- won 3 lost1 -- 3 vs 1 won 1 lost 1

etc

The history of the dice you roll are broken into the two statistics that you can see that are linked to your account.