Conquer Club

Another thing to consider, though:

Let's imagine that Greece is a lyncher, and hecter is a lynchee. It is pretty much established that we have a vig, so why not vig hecter tonight, instead of lynching him? Plus, that gives us an extra lynch to find someone else scummy.

So, unvote.

Vote Count

hecter: 2 (GreecePwns, pankakemix)

Not Voting: 8
With 10 players it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline is this time Sunday.[/quote]

GreecePwns wrote:
If that's true then, I am a Cop.

you better not be lying



Vote hector

derfderf, stop skimming! Have you even looked at the rest of the posts? He might be paranoid/crazy cop, or a lyncher, or any number of things. You didn't even address those. Now, please read some of those other posts before you make your vote. Every townie dead makes the mafia closer to winning. And if he is a lyncher, than he will win when I'm dead.

everywhere116 wrote:Vote Count

hecter: 2 (GreecePwns, pankakemix)

Not Voting: 8
With 10 players it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline is this time Sunday.

[/quote]

That's obviously how you spell cake.

Was that your answer, hecter? just a yes/no will do quite nicely.

(this is me doing my best impression of wicked... )

I'm sorry. What was my answer to what? If you are reffering to the pm question, I don't know how a yes/no will answer it, and I don't want to answer it without everywheres permission.

You can say how many words and what the last word was. Nothing else

hecter wrote:I'm sorry. What was my answer to what? If you are reffering to the pm question, I don't know how a yes/no will answer it, and I don't want to answer it without everywheres permission.

sorry, I occasionally read too much into people's posts sometimes... but everywhere has given the go-ahead, so if you please...

Well, the last word is dead. There you go. Dead. Nothing special now is it?

hecter wrote:Well, the last word is dead. There you go. Dead. Nothing special now is it?

ty... It's not a 100% confirmation, but it definitely makes you less suspicious in my eyes, and leads us to the likely conclusion that while greece may be a cop, he's not a straight-up cop.

Or he lies like a dog and claimed cop so that a real cop would come forward to refute him...

I'm more inclined to the former. Roleclaiming cop on day one when you're not the cop is risky as all hell.

At the moment, the person who now looks the scummiest, operating on the principle that noob mafia tend to only skim the posts and look for their name cropping up, is derfderf.

how does that help?
mafia ends in win when all non-mafia dead
townie ends in win when all mafia are dead
same with cop and doc

Incandenza wrote:At the moment, the person who now looks the scummiest, operating on the principle that noob mafia tend to only skim the posts and look for their name cropping up, is derfderf.

Your principle seems to be working.

Incandenza wrote:Oh, man, the plot thickens...

Scenario 1: greece is a legit cop, hecter is scum, we lynch hecter and do the happy dance

Scenario 2: greece is an insane cop, hecter is town, we lynch him and do the sad dance, then lynch greece 'cause we're pissed, then we lose the game probably

Scenario 3: greece is a legit cop, hecter is a miller, we lynch hecter and do the sad dance, etc. etc.

hmmmm...

unvote greece

Scenario 4: Greece is lying scum, we lynch hecter, town, and then we lynch Greece. scum.

Scenario 5+6: Greece is paraniod, and hecter is town or mafia.

derfderf34 wrote:how does that help?
mafia ends in win when all non-mafia dead
townie ends in win when all mafia are dead
same with cop and doc

It's because Mafia wins when they outnumber the town, not when they are all dead.

Fircoal wrote:

Incandenza wrote:Oh, man, the plot thickens...

Scenario 1: greece is a legit cop, hecter is scum, we lynch hecter and do the happy dance

Scenario 2: greece is an insane cop, hecter is town, we lynch him and do the sad dance, then lynch greece 'cause we're pissed, then we lose the game probably

Scenario 3: greece is a legit cop, hecter is a miller, we lynch hecter and do the sad dance, etc. etc.

hmmmm...

unvote greece

Scenario 4: Greece is lying scum, we lynch hecter, town, and then we lynch Greece. scum.

Scenario 5+6: Greece is paraniod, and hecter is town or mafia.

In a pinch, we could always lynch greece and find out for certain... but I'd just as soon not to that unless we have to...

hecter wrote:

derfderf34 wrote:how does that help?
mafia ends in win when all non-mafia dead
townie ends in win when all mafia are dead
same with cop and doc

It's because Mafia wins when they outnumber the town, not when they are all dead.

Precisely... and the win condition isn't always 'You win when the mafia are dead"... there are other factors that can come into play where the town only wins when everyone remaining is pro-town... (which means we may be able to rule out a serial killer)

You know, it's pretty obvious derfderf is skimming. And, whether or not he's scum, his behavior isn't helping the town.

So, FOS derfderf. This will turn into a vote unless I find a good reason for it not to.

I think we should hold off on lynching either hecter or GreecePwns until Greece's sanity can be figured out. Plus, there is always the chance that Greece is a lyncher or a grudgeholder.

No, I think we shouldn't lynch him until he does something really scummy. For now, lets see what others have to say.

Wait, guys, I've got an idea. Colaalone died for no apparent reason, right? We know Colaalone is a politician. Furthermore, this game started with night, so Colaalone had a chance to purchase someone's vote.

So, here's my conjecture: Colaalone was day killed because he accidentally purchased a scum vote overnight. Thus, whomever he purchased the vote from should not have a vote today. (Does the vote revert, since Colaalone was day killed?)

So, my plan to catch scum : everyone vote for the person immediately below them in the list. Whoever doesn't vote (or whose vote doesn't show up in the vote count) is scum.

Unvote
Vote: hecter

vote: Pancakemix

Glad I'm not below anyone.

It might be nulled because of his death, but worth a shot

Unvote

vote Aimless[b]

Makes sense to me.
Vote IGS

Incandenza, if you do this, vote fircoal, because we need all to vote.

pancakemix wrote:Incandenza, if you do this, vote fircoal, because we need all to vote.

no vote some one else, I want to be the only one without a vote.

Ok then. I want 2 votes.