Conquer Club

rishaed wrote:First off I will use this quote:

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:How unimaginative of you. I think anamaniacks summed it up pretty nicely:

anamaniacks wrote:Or, you thought that through, and decided that faking a target on Nendreel would make for a great way to clear yourself early in the game (as compared to giving a random name which doesn't add any meaning), when you really targeted Falko. dangit you played with me as the GF in Holiday mafia giving easier tells Then again, this is entirely WIFOM so I'm not going to vote just yet, but it is something to consider.And BOOM, you were right! That being said I would wager that those on Sheep are equally the same.

Applies just as readily to sheep.

-Tails

In this game as an SK you don't get many opportunities to clear yourself and gain some brownie points . So for every possible SK the best option would be to say (like I did, that I targeted someone who MK'd/NK'd to put me in the clear). There are three options here:
1. Both IB and Gregwolf are telling the truth. (Result = both town)
2. Either IB or Gregwolf is lying. (Result= town/SK)
3. Both IB and Gregwolf lied about their actions. (Result =Town/SK).
With IB bringing a shoddy case onto NG IMO i will thus take the higher odds that one of them saw the opportunity and took it. (66%)
so vote Iron Butterfly This and the fact that he has targeted someone multiple people have targeted (WIFOM ik) makes him slightly suspicious to me. That and the fact that this is a slightly more decent case than the one he has on NG.

Iron Butterfly wrote: Sarcasm is a term used for the spoken word not the written. Sarcasm is determined by the inflection of ones voice. Sarcasm is very rarely if ever ambiguous while speaking where as with the written word it is how it is interpreted.

jonty125 wrote:I agree with anamaniacks over no brownie points earned for targeting sheep, a player that was modkilled. But his voting of rishaed because [paraphrase]he can't tell if rishaed is scum or town[/paraphrase] is weak, and WIFOM - it seems a bit like individualistic play to me (more concenered about himself than town, which would indicate he is SK).

jonty125 wrote:

Iron Butterfly wrote: Sarcasm is a term used for the spoken word not the written. Sarcasm is determined by the inflection of ones voice. Sarcasm is very rarely if ever ambiguous while speaking where as with the written word it is how it is interpreted.

Fine, if we want to be pedantic, he was been ironic.

vote IB, you seem to have reacted very aggressively to my case, and seem to be arguing over the finer points rather than the substance. I agree with anamaniacks over no brownie points earned for targeting sheep, a player that was modkilled. But his voting of rishaed because [paraphrase]he can't tell if rishaed is scum or town[/paraphrase] is weak, and WIFOM - it seems a bit like individualistic play to me (more concenered about himself than town, which would indicate he is SK).

anamainiacks wrote:I find the issue over the sarcasm pretty laughable actually, haha. Don't see it holding much water either, and don't see anything suspicious about NG1's post, really. If I had to choose between the two (NG1 and IB), I'd say IB is more suspicious. So yes, IB, if you care to remove your vote on NG1 that'd be great (:

I'm looking at the posts, and have to focus on this one:

rishaed wrote:First off I will use this quote:

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:How unimaginative of you. I think anamaniacks summed it up pretty nicely:

anamaniacks wrote:Or, you thought that through, and decided that faking a target on Nendreel would make for a great way to clear yourself early in the game (as compared to giving a random name which doesn't add any meaning), when you really targeted Falko. dangit you played with me as the GF in Holiday mafia giving easier tells Then again, this is entirely WIFOM so I'm not going to vote just yet, but it is something to consider.And BOOM, you were right! That being said I would wager that those on Sheep are equally the same.

Applies just as readily to sheep.

-Tails

In this game as an SK you don't get many opportunities to clear yourself and gain some brownie points . So for every possible SK the best option would be to say (like I did, that I targeted someone who MK'd/NK'd to put me in the clear). There are three options here:
1. Both IB and Gregwolf are telling the truth. (Result = both town)
2. Either IB or Gregwolf is lying. (Result= town/SK)
3. Both IB and Gregwolf lied about their actions. (Result =Town/SK).
With IB bringing a shoddy case onto NG IMO i will thus take the higher odds that one of them saw the opportunity and took it. (66%)
so vote Iron Butterfly This and the fact that he has targeted someone multiple people have targeted (WIFOM ik) makes him slightly suspicious to me. That and the fact that this is a slightly more decent case than the one he has on NG.

1. To be honest, I don't see why Tails and rishaed think people that claimed to target sheep did so in an attempt to earn brownie points. sheep was a modkill, and there would be no risk involved in giving such a claim. Though I will admit that it is still a convenient one (albeit no more convenient than claiming to target any other player).No it does generate brownie points.... It says that I targeted a Town Person (at night no less) who is proven town, and was killed by either the SK who died, or the Mod. In this case its the mod. FoS anamainiacks This is essentially what I did with Nendreel only without the risk of catching any flack from it.
.

Iron Butterfly wrote:vote rishead

Personally i think the sk is laying low while we blab away as there is no reason for them to make waves. However I do not wish to die simply because I presented a case someone disagrees with.

gregwolf121 wrote:i targeted tails last night

aage wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:i targeted tails last night

Interesting.

aage wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:i targeted tails last night

Interesting.

As I said, animainiacks 4-ever.

anamainiacks wrote:

aage wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:i targeted tails last night

Interesting.

As I said, animainiacks 4-ever.

I targeted aage. Glad I could return the favor .

Not sure if greg is being an honest townie or an SK trying to gain trust though. Again, argument is admittedly WIFOM. At this point in the game, I guess it's pretty clear that there's no role other than just an SK, unfortunately. No other way of getting proper information.

tailgunner wrote:I targeted gregwolf again as my action does nothing.

gregwolf121 wrote:i don't think there are any inactives, for today the only one who hasn't posted is IB, but on the whole everybody seems to be active