Page 5 of 29
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 3:33 pm
by captainwalrus
Rainbow Eater wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
It is not like we have any real information to go on.
A no lynch is still not good. It gives the mafia an extra opportunity to kill.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 3:54 pm
by Rainbow Eater
captainwalrus wrote:Rainbow Eater wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
It is not like we have any real information to go on.
A no lynch is still not good. It gives the mafia an extra opportunity to kill.
and a forced lynch with no information gives them an extra 2 kills if we lynch wrong
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 4:01 pm
by captainwalrus
Rainbow Eater wrote:captainwalrus wrote:Rainbow Eater wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
It is not like we have any real information to go on.
A no lynch is still not good. It gives the mafia an extra opportunity to kill.
and a forced lynch with no information gives them an extra 2 kills if we lynch wrong
But if we do get information, and if we choose wisely, we can get a scum down.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 4:21 pm
by colton24
vodean wrote:i may have to change my vote as a sort of BW to Colton because he was slightly scummy, and leads in votes... for now, FOS colton
Complete bullshit vodean. All I have done was vote somebody. How the hell is that suspicous? How is someone automatically scum cause they have 3 votes?
unvote
vote vodean
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 4:22 pm
by Rainbow Eater
captainwalrus wrote:But if we do get information, and if we choose wisely, we can get a scum down.
I agree with these if's. I do not think they are likely, but I do agree with them.
safariguy5 wrote:Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
I do not agree with this.
1. threatening to vote a player unless a vote is changes is scummy. If that is the way a person feels then that is a way a person feels. you need to vote them and say why, not just threaten them to follow suite.
2. If you are a new player and do not know what to do and do not have anything to go on, why is no lynch bad? This seems like a set up and fishing for a reason to lynch. Of course this works really well on new players, which is way more scummier than voting no lynch.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 8:37 pm
by Metsfanmax
safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
You may disagree with his logic, but that doesn't make him mafia, it just makes him wrong...
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 8:55 pm
by safariguy5
Metsfanmax wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
You may disagree with his logic, but that doesn't make him mafia, it just makes him wrong...
If we do not lynch, this gives mafia a free night kill.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 9:01 pm
by Metsfanmax
safariguy5 wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Wolverine Mutant wrote:I'm slightly confused too.. If I have to vote, I guess I'll just go No Vote because I don't know what else to do.
Um, you do realize that that is a signature scum move right? If you indeed voted no lynch, I will be forced to vote you.
You may disagree with his logic, but that doesn't make him mafia, it just makes him wrong...
If we do not lynch, this gives mafia a free night kill.
The mafia will most likely get a night kill regardless of what we do. There's a strong probability that lynching someone on the first day could lead to a mis-lynch which just hurts the town even more. But my point is that it doesn't matter whether you or I agree with him - I'm just saying that one can believe what he's saying and not necessarily be mafia.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 9:18 am
by vodean
look. id rather have a lynch than no lynch. there are two people i think are scummy. one happens to have more votes. these are the ONLY two people i would vote for, so its not really scummy. colton, your doing a BW to get out of your own lynching. now THATS scummy.
as for saying i was mace windu: A) as i said, i am still a bit confused about the layout. I thought mace windu was a good guy.
B)Mace Windu is not a role, as he comes from the wrong era.
C) to correct that mistake: I AM DARTH BANE!!! DIE!
could we have a vote count?
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 9:53 am
by ga7
So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates. I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Vote Rainbow Eater for scummy logic
(btw I don't really think Vodean is scum but it tied my argument nicely
)
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:14 pm
by Rainbow Eater
ga7 wrote:So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates. I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Vote Rainbow Eater for scummy logic
(btw I don't really think Vodean is scum but it tied my argument nicely
)
scum buddy? lol. I have a vote and it is placed. You seem like a person who wants rookies lynched for rookie reasons..... and you talk about scum.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:57 pm
by vodean
ga7 wrote:So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates. I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Vote Rainbow Eater for scummy logic
(btw I don't really think Vodean is scum but it tied my argument nicely
)
go ahead and lynch RE. i think that he did make some good points though. FOS both of you.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:58 pm
by vodean
vodean wrote:ga7 wrote:So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates. I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Vote Rainbow Eater for scummy logic
(btw I don't really think Vodean is scum but it tied my argument nicely
)
go ahead and lynch RE. i think that he did make some good points though. FOS both of you.
oh, and thats because ga made an argument against RE, who had done nothing wrong, and because the argument was logical.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:59 pm
by spiesr
ga7 wrote:So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates. I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Oh, ga7, I forgot you were in this game, as much as I agree with your logic, I am not sure that I can allow your existence to continue. Simply put, if you are scum you way to much of a threat to the town to be left alive. The only hoping for ending your potential reign of terror is to off you as quickly as possible. If left alive as scum you will finagle yourself into a position where you could only be lynched on a successful investigation, and you might even escape that level of evidence alive. If you are scum and live, we are all doomed. FOS ga7.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 1:27 pm
by colton24
vodean wrote:look. id rather have a lynch than no lynch. there are two people i think are scummy. one happens to have more votes. these are the ONLY two people i would vote for, so its not really scummy. colton, your doing a BW to get out of your own lynching. now THATS scummy.
as for saying i was mace windu: A) as i said, i am still a bit confused about the layout. I thought mace windu was a good guy.
B)Mace Windu is not a role, as he comes from the wrong era.
C) to correct that mistake: I AM DARTH BANE!!! DIE!
could we have a vote count?
There is no BW I'm the only one voting for you I think. YOU came up with some bullshit that I was being scummy when all I had done was vote someone. Total bullshit scum
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 2:11 pm
by captainwalrus
vote colton- He really over reacts, the post just above this even seems to be over reacting
- A colton wagon is usually good for finding scum
- If we lynch colton first in every game, eventually he will be scum
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 2:18 pm
by Metsfanmax
captainwalrus wrote:vote colton- If we lynch colton first in every game, eventually he will be scum
Lol.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 3:47 pm
by colton24
captainwalrus wrote:vote colton- He really over reacts, the post just above this even seems to be over reacting
- A colton wagon is usually good for finding scum
- If we lynch colton first in every game, eventually he will be scum
That wasn't overeacting, that was pointing out that he lied.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 3:52 pm
by captainwalrus
colton24 wrote:captainwalrus wrote:vote colton- He really over reacts, the post just above this even seems to be over reacting
- A colton wagon is usually good for finding scum
- If we lynch colton first in every game, eventually he will be scum
That wasn't overeacting, that was pointing out that he lied.
But instead of just saying, no you are wrong, you said Bullshit a lot.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 3:54 pm
by colton24
vodean wrote:look. id rather have a lynch than no lynch. there are two people i think are scummy. one happens to have more votes. these are the ONLY two people i would vote for, so its not really scummy. colton, your doing a BW to get out of your own lynching. now THATS scummy.
as for saying i was mace windu: A) as i said, i am still a bit confused about the layout. I thought mace windu was a good guy.
B)Mace Windu is not a role, as he comes from the wrong era.
C) to correct that mistake: I AM DARTH BANE!!! DIE!
could we have a vote count?
And what makes you say I will be lynched? Want to BW me eh?
captainwalrus wrote:colton24 wrote:captainwalrus wrote:vote colton- He really over reacts, the post just above this even seems to be over reacting
- A colton wagon is usually good for finding scum
- If we lynch colton first in every game, eventually he will be scum
That wasn't overeacting, that was pointing out that he lied.
But instead of just saying, no you are wrong, you said Bullshit a lot.
So what? Bullshit gets the same point across
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 4:39 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
first off there was no reason for wolverine to vote no lynch. if he is confused and doesn't know who to vote for at the time then he just shouldn't vote or cast a vote for shits and giggles at someone. secondly it is scummy to tell someone to change their vote just because you don't agree with what they put there. finally it was just plain stupid to give up a role name without any pressure like Vodean did when he just now claimed darth bane. if anyone wants to counter that speak up.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 4:51 pm
by spiesr
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:finally it was just plain stupid to give up a role name without any pressure like Vodean did when he just now claimed darth bane. if anyone wants to counter that speak up.
I am going to go with the assumption that vodean's claim of Darth Bane wasn't a serious one. I am not even sure if that character is in the correct era.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 6:21 pm
by Fuzzylogic99
ga7 wrote:So far we got a lot of irrational day 1 BS, an unpressured claim, the whole setup open and no lynch advocates.
I'd vote Fuzzylogic just for the WTF factor but I'll go for
Rainbow Eater who doesn't seem to want his scumbuddy Vodean to be lynched. No lynches are only good for the mafia people. Town only has the lynches info to go from because the NKs do not show who wanted the victim dead. With no lynch, mafia might lose the chance to kill an extra townie but they also don't even have to vote for the wrong guy, making it harder to actually find them.
Vote Rainbow Eater for scummy logic
(btw I don't really think Vodean is scum but it tied my argument nicely )
how funny you talk about people scummy logic but ignore your own.While I agree that RE logic
about the vote is a bit scummy ,I dont see it enought to vote for him.It might be just bc he
is a newby and this is a newby mistake than again he might be scum.I think he deserves a FOS for now.
now at the end you make the post you admit that you pretty much made up
parts but you think its okay since some of the other parts are true.I dont know but this seems really really scummy
FOS- RE-for scummy logic
FOS- Vondean for a few scummy posts
HFOS -GA7 for a really scummy post
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 6:28 pm
by Fuzzylogic99
I should say his comment might be bc he is new or they might be because scum.Than again he could be both am entertaining every possibility.
Re: star wars mafia game thread, day 1
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 7:30 pm
by gregwolf121
vote count
colton (3) UTAlan, captainwalrus, metsfanmax
Rainbow eater (2) strike wolf, ga7
strike wolf (1) LSU tiger josh
Vodean (3)spiesr, safariguy5, colton24
Army of God (2) Vodean, Rainbow eater
no lynch (1) wolverine mutant
with 20 alive it takes 11 to lynch