Page 5 of 10
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:57 am
by Nickbaldwin
Are we sure that we need to lynch Adam to save the other two (whether they may be town, scum, fictional, whatever), or could it be a decision that Dr. Gordon has to make on his own? I'm not completely swung by either possibility so another opinion could help.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 7:12 am
by Kernal_Kronic
Nickbaldwin wrote:Are we sure that we need to lynch Adam to save the other two (whether they may be town, scum, fictional, whatever), or could it be a decision that Dr. Gordon has to make on his own? I'm not completely swung by either possibility so another opinion could help.
Nope, Dr Gordon's wife & kid might not even be 2 other players, it could be just be part of the story.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:40 am
by got tonkaed
Updated correct vote count.
Day 1 vote counts
Mandalorian2298 1 (ga7)
Ga7 2 (mandarlorian2298,nagerous)
Animorpherv1 5(ace1217,sierra_leon,spinwizard,LSU,Kernal_kronic)
Pmchugh 1(Nickbaldwin)
Strider24 1 (spurgistan)
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:42 am
by got tonkaed
Additionally...pending confirmation Floresdemal will be replacing kalishnikov.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 11:13 am
by spinwizard
wow the pace of mafias decreced
not really got anything to add other than whats been said
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 11:15 am
by ga7
vote nagerous
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 3:03 pm
by ga7
On actual content... I'm starting to think both of these guys are actually survivors, that or mutual lynchers. Which wouldn't be a bad lynch but probably won't confirm or save anyone. Besides what kind of shitty role would be "innocent hostage" seriously... GT is kindof a sadist hence why this theme but still...
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:00 pm
by nagerous
I'm going to borrow the movie off my housemate so I can be informed as to who all the characters etc. are, rather than just pretending
.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:27 pm
by got tonkaed
Just to clarify. My objective for today is just to survive. I was told Dr. Gordon and I could talk but he doesn't seem to want to talk with me.
When I saw Ani posting as such it concerned me as I saw two titles in my PM beside my name Adam, I realized then that is was possible that my survival was dependant on a lyncher not lynching me day 1.
I dont' know if ani is that lyncher or if he is like me and has a goal. It has been my experience that a lyncher has a solo goal to win that is not in the town's favor.
Adam
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:29 pm
by pmchugh
ga7 wrote:On actual content... I'm starting to think both of these guys are actually survivors, that or mutual lynchers. Which wouldn't be a bad lynch but probably won't confirm or save anyone. Besides what kind of shitty role would be "innocent hostage" seriously... GT is kindof a sadist hence why this theme but still...
True their is probably more than meets the eye but for now I can't see a reason to suspect adam if he is a survivor then not much harm done in letting him live for now at least.
posted before farside's comment ^^^^^
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 11:46 pm
by got tonkaed
Well tomorrow I can actually talk in the game and I win with the town not alone as a "survivor" role.
Now if someone can explain to me why Dr. Gordon is not sending me a PM or trying to communicate other then something scummy I am all ears.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 11:48 pm
by got tonkaed
got tonkaed wrote:Updated correct vote count.
Day 1 vote counts
Nagerous 1 (Ga7)
Ga7 2 (mandarlorian2298,nagerous)
Animorpherv1 7(ace1217,sierra_leon,spinwizard,LSU,Kernal_kronic,murdock,secret vote)
Pmchugh 1(Nickbaldwin)
Strider24 1 (spurgistan)
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 6:07 am
by Nickbaldwin
got tonkaed wrote:got tonkaed wrote:Updated correct vote count.
Day 1 vote counts
Nagerous 1 (Ga7)
Ga7 2 (mandarlorian2298,nagerous)
Animorpherv1 7(ace1217,sierra_leon,spinwizard,LSU,Kernal_kronic,murdock,secret vote)
Pmchugh 1(Nickbaldwin)
Strider24 1 (spurgistan)
Just thought I'd highlight that for everyone.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:19 am
by ga7
Meh, I'm not convinced by this Ani wagon but will reread later to see if there' anything else.
(Flores told me she'd only be able to catch back this evening btw)
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:21 am
by spinwizard
i'm still with the ani vote but feel free to suggest someone better, im all ears.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 5:57 pm
by mandalorian2298
Ani, since you are at -2 and deadline is Sunday, I think that you should claim as soon as possible.
ga7 wrote:mandalorian2298 wrote:Vote ga7 because he is the most Fircoal-like player in this game.
OMGUS Vote Mandy for offending me beyond reason
Great! Now I angered Ga7 and the evil Tonka allows Flores to join.
*sigh*
I'm sooo going to get prodded.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:09 pm
by guylian
got tonkaed wrote:Just to clarify. My objective for today is just to survive. I was told Dr. Gordon and I could talk but he doesn't seem to want to talk with me.
When I saw Ani posting as such it concerned me as I saw two titles in my PM beside my name Adam, I realized then that is was possible that my survival was dependant on a lyncher not lynching me day 1.
I dont' know if ani is that lyncher or if he is like me and has a goal. It has been my experience that a lyncher has a solo goal to win that is not in the town's favor.
Adam
I am surprised that Dr. Gordon(current suspect Ani) does not want to talk to Adam, It feels to me like he has something to hide.
He is for damn sure not trying to help him by not talking with him.
so because it appears that adam is the one trying to help the town i am going to go ahead and
vote Ani
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:23 pm
by guylian
unvote
I have noticed that / has not posted once except to confirm
vote /
I am thinking that Ani it not Dr. Gordon and maybe you are
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:33 pm
by /
I can post just fine, plenty of people haven't posted yet actually, My logic for not posting was simply because I thought there was a possibility of Dr. Gordon having some sort of day-kill powers, I didn't post so I could give Adam a better chance of not being killed. (even though it theoretically would give myself a higher chance of being day-killed)
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:44 pm
by guylian
/ wrote:I can post just fine, plenty of people haven't posted yet actually, My logic for not posting was simply because I thought there was a possibility of Dr. Gordon having some sort of day-kill powers, I didn't post so I could give Adam a better chance of not being killed. (even though it theoretically would give myself a higher chance of being day-killed)
unvote fair enough
as soon as i voted for ani a few posts back i reread the thread again and saw this, which is why i voted you /
Kernal_Kronic wrote:I was thinking that...Maybe each one has a specific night role (doc & watcher) depending who survives,
but if ani is Dr Gordon, then he shouldn't be able to speak either 
i think we should have a list of who hasn't posted yet as if Kronic's post is true then it will be one of those who is Dr. Gordon and not Ani,
I
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 1:11 am
by got tonkaed
I think with the mod talking about PR's someone already broke the rules. I figured Dr. Gordon should be like me, IE talking through the mod, as both of us are being held by jigsaw. However I saw ani spoke which surprised me. Seeing the mod's title leads me to believe he is breaking the PR set up by the mod for reason's only he can explain.
Adam
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 4:33 am
by spinwizard
well gt said someone violated their PR a few pages back...
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 6:08 am
by mandalorian2298
got tonkaed wrote:I think with the mod talking about PR's someone already broke the rules. I figured Dr. Gordon should be like me, IE talking through the mod, as both of us are being held by jigsaw. However I saw ani spoke which surprised me. Seeing the mod's title leads me to believe he is breaking the PR set up by the mod for reason's only he can explain.
Adam
got tonkaed wrote:6. If you have a post restriction you must follow it to the letter. If you violate it once you get a warning. If you violate it twice you are dead, no questions asked.
Ani posted three times, so if he is not dead, that probably means that he has no PR.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules including your PR
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 6:35 am
by got tonkaed
In the interest of full disclosure to the game, i broke rule 6 on day one.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 8:22 am
by Kernal_Kronic
guylian wrote:/ wrote:I can post just fine, plenty of people haven't posted yet actually, My logic for not posting was simply because I thought there was a possibility of Dr. Gordon having some sort of day-kill powers, I didn't post so I could give Adam a better chance of not being killed. (even though it theoretically would give myself a higher chance of being day-killed)
unvote fair enough
as soon as i voted for ani a few posts back i reread the thread again and saw this, which is why i voted you /
Kernal_Kronic wrote:I was thinking that...Maybe each one has a specific night role (doc & watcher) depending who survives,
but if ani is Dr Gordon, then he shouldn't be able to speak either
i think we should have a list of who hasn't posted yet as if Kronic's post is true then it will be one of those who is Dr. Gordon and not Ani,
I
Looking back natewolfman, Stephen Wayne/Murdock Sampson, kalishnikov/Floresdemal, farside22 & Ryall55 haven't posted, also the fact that ani isn't trying to defend himself leads me to belive that he broke the pr (by not being mod killed i belive got tonkaed broke rule 6) but i could be wrong.