Page 5 of 15
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 4:09 pm
by william18
MeDeFe wrote:A votecount would be greatly appreciated, and how many bad guys can there be in a 15-player game anyway?
Approximatley 1 quarter. It would be five max, more like 4 or 3.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 5:41 pm
by MeDeFe
william18 wrote:MeDeFe wrote:A votecount would be greatly appreciated, and how many bad guys can there be in a 15-player game anyway?
Approximatley 1 quarter. It would be five max, more like 4 or 3.
And since this is probably(?) a three-party game, 3 bad guys plus a few, maybe as few as one or two. Nale and Sabine third party? hmm... an evil incarnation of illicit sex running around shouldn't be too hard to spot.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 6:14 pm
by pmchugh
This is an awful bandwagon, fair enoguh to stroop as he was just looking for someone scummy but it is clear that many of you on the wagon don't even know why you are voting.
And by a mile kwan is the worst, he even admits it.
kwanton wrote:Should be 3 votes on ga7 now: mm stroop and hologram
I'm tossing another one on cuz he's ga7
If ya wanna accuse me of bandwagoning then nyah!
With a deadline aprroaching random bw hopping is very poor play, either your scum hiding in plain sight (if that's the right saying) or your a townie who certainly wouldn't trust to make good decsisions come end game.
unvote vote kwan
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 6:37 pm
by ga7
I'm busy planning my wedding, gimme a break. From what I read which wasn't so long ago I didn't see any other "serious" discussions than what could mean the grey colour which isn't really relevant; and obviously didn't see a better suspect so far since it's day 1. Now of course, that unjustified bandwagon attempt should give us enough to go on, seeing the poor excuses the scum that vote me use. Yes, it is likely they're all scum

We should have enough time before the deadline for a lynch hopefully so I'll try to reread and chip in tomorrow.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:19 pm
by Suspect101
unvote vote kwan
I agree with pmc. I think that Kwan is trying to hide amonst a deadline vote.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:43 pm
by Iliad
Vote count
ga7-4 Minister Masket, stroop, hologram , kwanton
stroop-1medefe,
kwanton-4-/, ga7, pcmhugh, suspect
pcmhugh-1-william
Takes 8 to lynch.
Approximately 4.5 days left.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:26 pm
by Iliad
Prods have been sent out for inactive people. There may be possible replacements
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:28 pm
by sheepofdumb
Well then vote ga7. for the hell of it.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:30 pm
by Iliad
Vote count
ga7-5 Minister Masket, stroop, hologram , kwanton, sheep
stroop-1medefe,
kwanton-4-/, ga7, pcmhugh, suspect
pcmhugh-1-william
Takes 8 to lynch.
Approximately 4.5 days left.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 11:18 pm
by AceArtemis
It seems I've forgotten about this game. I've read through the thread after being prodded, and here's my contribution:
We have a serious deadline here, and this blind bandwagoning of an inactive isn't exactly helping. It's one thing to bandwagon for lurking, but it's another thing entirely when people are adding to the bandwagon without knowing why they are voting.
kwanton wrote:Should be 3 votes on ga7 now: mm stroop and hologram
I'm tossing another one on cuz he's ga7
If ya wanna accuse me of bandwagoning then nyah!
That would be great if we were in the random vote stage, but since we have a deadline in under 5 days, we shouldn't mess around.
FoS: kwanton.
sheepofdumb wrote:Well then vote ga7. for the hell of it.
You're even worse than kwanton.
Vote: sheep
To be honest, if I could vote for both, I would. However, I only have one vote, so I must make the best possible use of it. I am voting for sheep because there is already plenty of pressure on kwanton, and I want to hear sheep defend himself. Once kwanton and sheep defend themselves, we can decide who is more scummy and is the better Day 1 lynch.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 12:38 am
by Minister Masket
I can't switch my vote now, not when ga7 is close to a lynch.
Remember people, he's always scum in games with me.
Even that one time when he wasn't at first, then came back as replacement and then was!
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 1:02 am
by kwanton
Maybe it has been a while since i've played but I doubt perception of time could have changed that much while i've been afcc. hiding behind a deadline isn't really valid when there are 5 days until the deadline. Hell 5 days was an imposed deadline halfway through the first game day, and when games in my experience have usually had a regular deadline of 3 days the number 5 doesnt seem all that scary to me. Has mafia really slowed down that much here that people are getting nervous over a 5 day deadline?
Anywhoo lol @ people who thought my vote was serious. Like I said before it takes 8 to lynch and in a 15 player game there's gotta be at least 1 person out of that 8 to unvote off a stupid bandwagon like this. To prove my point, I'm gonna leave my vote on. (Also I'm stubborn and ga7 is stinky

). I guarantee that now that suspicion is shifting away from him, all the scared little ones are gonna unvote and hide. I have absolutely no reason or valid suspicion to be voting ga7 and no argument to make others do so, other than the fact that I know people are gonna unvote before he gets lynched. Everyone needs to lighten up and not take these things so seriously, especially when there's only about half of the needed votes for a lynch and days of arguments before we have to decide who to off.
Also, grats on the marriage
Thanks for keeping me informed jerk -_-
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 3:07 am
by /
Sorry, forgot it was still day. I don't know, nothing scummy so far in my opinion, just a typical day one where a random lynch is needed. I suppose a five day deadline is cutting it close if the accused claims a valid role and we end up having to redo the bandwagon, I'll contribute to the bandwagon to assure us some form of evidence. Unvote vote GA
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 3:14 am
by Iliad
Vote count
ga7-6 Minister Masket, stroop, hologram , kwanton, sheep, /
stroop-1medefe,
kwanton-3- ga7, pcmhugh, suspect,
pcmhugh-1-william
sheep-1-aceartemis
Takes 8 to lynch.
Approximately 4 days left.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 3:16 am
by MeDeFe
I think what pmc said makes sense.
unvote stroop
vote Kwanton
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 6:59 am
by Suspect101
I am usually against early claiming, but L-2 with a deadline looming is like being at L-1. GA, you might want to claim. This way, if you are town, you will give people ample time to jump off and onto someone else. This is going to suck if we lynch a townie because they are too busy planning a wedding to reply. Guess it doesn't matter anyways, once you are married we will never see you on CC ever again!

Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 7:34 am
by pmchugh
omg this is the worst bandwagon in history. Too much scummy behaviour!
KWAN- you are voting for him to prove he wont be lynched?

He is at L-2 and close to claiming, you even admit you have no reason to believe him scum.
/ wrote:Sorry, forgot it was still day. I don't know, nothing scummy so far in my opinion, just a typical day one where a random lynch is needed. I suppose a five day deadline is cutting it close if the accused claims a valid role and we end up having to redo the bandwagon, I'll contribute to the bandwagon to assure us some form of evidence. Unvote vote GA
Now you are just voting for him just because you have nothing better. Lets see mindless bandwagoning or no apparent reason what is the best reason to vote
Minister Masket wrote:I can't switch my vote now, not when ga7 is close to a lynch.
Remember people, he's always scum in games with me.
Even that one time when he wasn't at first, then came back as replacement and then was!
A joke vote near to a deadline, nice one.
sheepofdumb wrote:Well then vote ga7. for the hell of it.
Where do I start with this one?
I wish I had four votes as this is ridiculous. I know why don't we vote hologram for having 2 o's in his name! It would be a better bandwagon than this one...
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 9:46 am
by sheepofdumb
lol, it wasn't a serious vote. I don't even know why people want ga7 dead. unvote. I'd go look now but I'm busy.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 5:56 pm
by Minister Masket
pmchugh wrote:
Minister Masket wrote:I can't switch my vote now, not when ga7 is close to a lynch.
Remember people, he's always scum in games with me.
Even that one time when he wasn't at first, then came back as replacement and then was!
A joke vote near to a deadline, nice one.
How is this a joke vote?
I am dead fooking serious.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 10:18 pm
by sheepofdumb
Ok Stroop I'll go along with you. Ga7 is definitely fishy with 3 joke votes and then submarining. What I find even more fishy is Stoops behavior regarding Ga7. So this is what I purpose. We lynch Ga7 and if we don't like the results then we have a perfectly good lynch lined up for tomorrow.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 12:21 am
by /
Agreed, if GA has a good role to claim he should claim now, otherwise he is just hopelessly derailing our chances of lynching scum today.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Not nailed Nale nailed!
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 12:48 am
by Iliad
Vote count
ga7-5 Minister Masket, stroop, hologram , kwanton, /
kwanton-4- ga7, pcmhugh, suspect, medefe
pcmhugh-1-william
sheep-1-aceartemis
Takes 8 to lynch.
Approximately 3 days left.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 5:25 am
by pmchugh
/ wrote:Agreed, if GA has a good role to claim he should claim now, otherwise he is just hopelessly derailing our chances of lynching scum today.
I say he should be prodded or replaced. Do you honestly believe he is a better target than kwan? If you swtched your vote to kwan then he would be closest to a lynch the same as ga7 is now. We then force a claim that we can actually get since kwan is much more active.
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:37 am
by ga7
Sigh... This stupid ass wagon is dying out and yet people are still crying for a claim. I don't see why I should paint a bigger target on my back right now, but at least with the last few developments I can pick my scumbag for the lynch.
First of all I wasn't submarining: I explained my reasons for being not very active; then again there was no deadline yet so it's pretty meaningless. I didn't see / getting called out for being more inactive than me when he says:
/ wrote:Sorry, forgot it was still day. I don't know, nothing scummy so far in my opinion, just a typical day one where a random lynch is needed. I suppose a five day deadline is cutting it close if the accused claims a valid role and we end up having to redo the bandwagon, I'll contribute to the bandwagon to assure us some form of evidence. Unvote vote GA
"Oh my scum wagon vote will be totally justified now that there is a deadline!!1!"
Suspect101 wrote:I am usually against early claiming, but L-2 with a deadline looming is like being at L-1. GA, you might want to claim. This way, if you are town, you will give people ample time to jump off and onto someone else. This is going to suck if we lynch a townie because they are too busy planning a wedding to reply. Guess it doesn't matter anyways, once you are married we will never see you on CC ever again!

Again, deadline looming how? We have 4 fucking days in a relatively small game with many active players. And hah, that won't happen
sheepofdumb wrote:Ok Stroop I'll go along with you. Ga7 is definitely fishy with 3 joke votes and then submarining. What I find even more fishy is Stoops behavior regarding Ga7. So this is what I purpose. We lynch Ga7 and if we don't like the results then we have a perfectly good lynch lined up for tomorrow.
That's a classic sheep scum move: "Oh I know! These two townies are in opposition so town will lynch them both, hypnotized by my brilliant logic!" I like how you forget I can actually claim to prevent my lynch
/ wrote:Agreed, if GA has a good role to claim he should claim now, otherwise he is just hopelessly derailing our chances of lynching scum today.
What is derailing chances to find scum today is that you people are too damn lazy to dig in on actually suspicious people.
To me it's a close one between / and Sheep. The banter between Pmc and Stroop didn't leave me much trust in both of them but it doesn't strike me as that suspicious in comparison. Kwan could be anything as I feel he could act the same way as town or scum and if he was actual scum I think he would have been more cautious about it and simply removed his vote instead of trying to actually get more attention to himself

Then again it can be a WIFOM lol.
I'll chip in a name claim which should hopefully prevent people to actually stick to this crap of a case and feel bad about their scummy selves; while giving me protection. I certainly didn't plan to claim seeing as there's an unknown daykiller and possible scum blockers but at least it should provide an incentive to follow the right lead today
I am Hinjo. I smite evil, biatches.
Unvote Vote / Lurking, wagonning, pushing for a claim.
P.S.: Sorry Kwan still luv you <3
Re: Order of the Stick mafia Day 1-Deadline looming(Need 1 sub)
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:13 am
by sheepofdumb
Lies! I'm Hinjo!

I'm still not taking this game seriously yet.