Page 6 of 6
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Sat Jan 03, 2009 10:10 am
by max is gr8
ctg if half of the people they play against deadbeat they won't be coming back
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Sat Jan 03, 2009 9:34 pm
by ctgottapee
that is a great point max
i was thinking more along the lines of 4 player games, 2-3 newbs and 1-2 old guard
i would think the games would fill up fast to help limit deadbeating, but deadbeating is a part of CC so no time like the first game to learn about it for newbs.
along with keeping newbs from ruining regular games, my hope is that a little hand holding in the beginning might get a few more to stick around and be decent competitors if not friends
max is gr8 wrote:ctg if half of the people they play against deadbeat they won't be coming back
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Tue Jan 27, 2009 8:27 pm
by TooHot4Jew
If you take away the point xfer, you're depriving a winner who expended energy taking out those troops, and essentially not penalizing those deadbeats for sucking at life. I'm against it.
maniacmath17 wrote:I'm not sure what the exact numbers are on this, but from my experience, a majority of new recruits that join public games end up deadbeating. A lot of them never come back to the site, so they arent really being penalized and the only result of taking away their points is that the winner gets points he/she didn't really earn.
Is it possible to not award points for beating new recruits that deadbeat? I agree with the new rule since we can't have experienced players deadbeating on purpose if they start off with a bad position. But I've never heard of a new recruit that cared enough about their 1000 points to trying something like that.
priority: 5
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Wed Jan 28, 2009 7:51 am
by Timminz
Why is this not listed as *To-Do* anymore?
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Wed Jan 28, 2009 2:48 pm
by Artimis
Timminz wrote:Why is this not listed as *To-Do* anymore?
Maybe it's been done?
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Wed Jan 28, 2009 2:53 pm
by Kotaro
Terrible idea. If you're playing someone who has a brain, and is new, and he's quite quick and catches on. Then, oh no, he starts losing. Knowing he won't lose points if he deadbeats, what do you think he does?
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Wed Jan 28, 2009 3:02 pm
by Timminz
Kotaro wrote:Terrible idea. If you're playing someone who has a brain, and is new, and he's quite quick and catches on. Then, oh no, he starts losing. Knowing he won't lose points if he deadbeats, what do you think he does?
Considering how often that is likely to happen, and the fact that anyone could only do it 5 times (at most), I would say that's not much of a problem.
Re:
Posted: Wed Jan 28, 2009 3:02 pm
by sailorseal
HighBorn wrote:that is a great idea manic.. dont know how hard the programing would be though
Probably just another restriction on new recruits...
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Sat Jan 31, 2009 12:08 am
by pissedoffsol
I ONLY support the no points IF and ONLY IF:
- 2 player game
- noob plays 0 rounds.
that's it.
if you take away winning of points, i will NEVER play a game with a ? again. Any that joins my games, i will drop.
Why bother?
I think others will feel the same way, and you'll get NO new members because they will never get a game going.
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Sat Jan 31, 2009 10:35 am
by Timminz
pissedoffsol wrote:I ONLY support the no points IF and ONLY IF:
- 2 player game
- noob plays 0 rounds.
that's it.
if you take away winning of points, i will NEVER play a game with a ? again. Any that joins my games, i will drop.
Why bother?
I think others will feel the same way, and you'll get NO new members because they will never get a game going.
This suggestion would NOT stop you from winning points from other players. Just from any new recruits who were kicked out for missing 3 consecutive turns.
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 5:44 pm
by pissedoffsol
i understand that.
but in a 3 player game, if the new guy deadbeats, it puts a significant sway one way or the other sometimes-- effectively changing the game.
2 player and he never plays, sure. no points. i'm cool.
3+ player and 1 newbie deadbeats, he still loses points and i would gain (if i win).
Re:
Posted: Thu Mar 19, 2009 10:57 am
by lmac
Kahn wrote:as far as deadbeats go in a team game I think that they should have to pay the total team cost in points. Also any points that the team may win should be split up with the remaining members. None to the deadbeat they just interupt the game they need stiff fines for so doing. This should apply to us all.
Peace through strength
I AGREE 100% on this.... deadbeats should take the hit in team games, its nearly impossible to win if you have a deadbeat in a doubles game.....
Re: No Points For New Recruit Deadbeats
Posted: Thu Mar 19, 2009 1:17 pm
by Timminz
New recruits can't join team games anyway. This suggestion has nothing to do with what the last couple people were talking about.