Page 3 of 28
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:09 pm
by Its Bolt
So im the lyncher because I was the first to random vote you?
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:09 pm
by animorpherv1
Its Bolt wrote:So im the lyncher because I was the first to random vote you?
Yes. makes perfect sense.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:13 pm
by ace1217
I'm gonna have to vote ani. It's getting rather absurd.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:18 pm
by Its Bolt
ace1217 wrote:I'm gonna have to vote ani. It's getting rather absurd.
correct move is to vig ani
unvote
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 10:00 pm
by Nzen
Are we supposed to portray our assigned character? It seems mine is rather appropriate: Aeris from VGcats
Leo [ace1217], you fool! No one had voted for you or me at all. Roleclaims create suspicion not cooperation because they involve WIFOM. It isn't like either of us is essential for a town win, so long as we catch the scum.
vote Its Bolt
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 10:35 pm
by AceArtemis
Nzen wrote:Are we supposed to portray our assigned character? It seems mine is rather appropriate: Aeris from VGcats
Leo [ace1217], you fool! No one had voted for you or me at all. Roleclaims create suspicion not cooperation because they involve WIFOM. It isn't like either of us is essential for a town win, so long as we catch the scum.
vote Its Bolt
Could you explain the reasoning behind your vote?
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 10:45 pm
by ace1217
Nzen wrote:Are we supposed to portray our assigned character? It seems mine is rather appropriate: Aeris from VGcats
Leo [ace1217], you fool! No one had voted for you or me at all. Roleclaims create suspicion not cooperation because they involve WIFOM. It isn't like either of us is essential for a town win, so long as we catch the scum.
vote Its Bolt
True, but if you haven't noticed, we
need to survive primarily. Helping town win is just secondary.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 10:56 pm
by AceArtemis
Ok, nevermind. You voted for Bolt because of the already existing bandwagon.
The reasoning behind the bandwagon goes as follows: "Ani claimed lynchee. Its Bolt must be the lyncher because he voted for Ani during random voting. Therefore, we should lynch Its Bolt."
I disagree with this logic. Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't lynchers usually try to build a case against their targets instead of random voting them? From the games I've seen on CC, players usually aren't lynched during D1 random voting. Besides, if Ani is vigged like Bolt suggested, Bolt will have no way of winning the game if he really is a lyncher.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 11:07 pm
by Natewolfman
wtf is going on with this game?! lol 2 (or is it 3 now) claims durring RANDOM voting, not even pressure?
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 11:08 pm
by AceArtemis
Natewolfman wrote:wtf is going on with this game?! lol 2 (or is it 3 now) claims durring RANDOM voting, not even pressure?
QFT
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 1:08 am
by Drench
edit
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 3:47 am
by Iliad
Seriously people.
We've had ani claim lynchee, ace and nzen randomly claim for no reason. Thanks for giving plenty of targets for scum
Seriously what's up with this game.
Anyway I find ace quite suspicious. Perhaps he has a post restriction where he has to fake claim day 1?
Ani is worse. I find the random lynchee claim scummy. Perhaps enough to warrant checking its veracity
*sigh* and I just realised because of random people claiming before anyone votes for them, I can't even have the standard day 1 votes *sigh*
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:16 am
by icedagger
Ok.Who's idea was it to put ace and ani in a game together? Own up
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:20 am
by Drench
edit
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:57 am
by FloresDelMal
ga7 wrote:The phrase on page 1 is from a poem called The Quartet for the Dusk of Man in the game Penny Arcade Adventures : On the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness. Because I like bonus pts
Vote Masket err crap.
Vote Milifor cheating on us

vote ga7 for being such a gamer nerd and vote mili my dear

Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:03 am
by FloresDelMal
oh btw, i just ignored the ace/ani/ n(something) silliness, and went to my happy place, where you can actually enjoy random voting in day 1 without claim that i am leia princess unkillable

Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:40 am
by Minister Masket
icedagger wrote:Ok.Who's idea was it to put ace and ani in a game together? Own up

Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 8:48 am
by ga7
My, this is silly... Seems Ani is telling the truth tho. Its Bolt didn't act at all like he could be Ani's lynchee instead and just wanted Ani vigged. Being told you're a lynchee as long as you try to find out your lyncher doesn't sound too farfetched, although I believe it doesn't make Ani a townie automatically either. Well, lyncher sounds like a good day 1 lynch anyway
Unvote Vote BoltFOS Flores for scummily defending Mili her scummy scumbuddy

Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 10:27 am
by Natewolfman
whats a lynchee?
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 10:29 am
by Its Bolt
ga7 wrote:My, this is silly... Seems Ani is telling the truth tho. Its Bolt didn't act at all like he could be Ani's lynchee instead and just wanted Ani vigged. Being told you're a lynchee as long as you try to find out your lyncher doesn't sound too farfetched, although I believe it doesn't make Ani a townie automatically either. Well, lyncher sounds like a good day 1 lynch anyway

Vigging the lynchee would cause the lyncher to lose automatically, or at very best revert to a VT win condition. I am completely serious that I want him vigged as the only way having him around cant create problems later in the game is if the lyncher dies early. If ani really is a lynchee, the lyncher really doesnt want ani to get vigged given that they will of lost.
Lyncher/Lynchee is a player who wins the game by having a specific player lynched, and the player they have to lynch respectively. I have never seen one where the lynchee knows who they are though (in fact all I have seen is a 3 vanilla, lyncher, lynchee, 2 mafia)
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 10:58 am
by AceArtemis
FloresDelMal wrote:i am leia princess unkillable

Joke?
Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 11:46 am
by Nzen
It wouldn't be effective for me to deny ace1217's damn roleclaim. Which, unfortunately, makes the lovers or the lynchers the only game in town today. So, I invite the cop to check me or ace1217. The confirm will do us good.
> ace1217
Yes, lovers want to survive. Everyone wants to survive to the last day. Demanding that the other players conform to our correllary objective doesn't win any friends.
Aeris duct-tapes Leo's head to the floor so she can wrestle him into a suit for the trial of public opinion.
One mass "role"claim I would like to see is our webcomic characters. Seeing a Belkar is good for a laugh, whether played true or against type.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 12:53 pm
by pmchugh
Nzen wrote:It wouldn't be effective for me to deny ace1217's damn roleclaim. Which, unfortunately, makes the lovers or the lynchers the only game in town today. So, I invite the cop to check me or ace1217. The confirm will do us good.
> ace1217
Yes, lovers want to survive. Everyone wants to survive to the last day. Demanding that the other players conform to our correllary objective doesn't win any friends.
Aeris duct-tapes Leo's head to the floor so she can wrestle him into a suit for the trial of public opinion.
One mass "role"claim I would like to see is our webcomic characters. Seeing a Belkar is good for a laugh, whether played true or against type.
No this would be almost akin to a mass claim which isnt needed at this stage.
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 4:39 pm
by Stroop
I agree with Bolt, ani should be vigged.
Why do you think Its Bolt is the lyncher for it, ga?
Re: Webcomics Mafia! DAY 1!
Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:33 pm
by spiesr
I will be a sup. With this group of players you will certainly need 1...