Conquer Club

Iliad wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:

sheepofdumb wrote:Normally this is where I'd feel sorry for the newbie who doesn't understand:

Iliad wrote:2 lynches a day =VERY GOOD.

Except that 2 town lynches a day = VERY BAD

WHAT?

Suspect what part of-lynches are very, very good don't you understand. Yeah we'll get town. That's how it works. And after each lynch we get mroe and more information. Who defended whom, who attacked whom, who voted and went back to lurking. We are essentially getting two days for each night the mafia has. If you cannot comprehend that then you're a pretty lost cause. We will lynch town. That is a fact, but that's how it works and we will find the mafia. By having two days to every night the mafia has that will hopefully be not too difficult.

Yeah uhm...

Suspect, two lynches a day is very good. We always lynch town because the scum have an advantage. That's the idea behind mafia. And they would like it far better if there was just one lynch because their real power is at night. An extra lynch basically means another day without a night. If Iliad kills the person who is about to be lynched, we have another chance at lynching a scum. If he didn't then the lynch would still go through but the mafia would get a night in which to kill someone.


Seriously, there is just no way to defend the statement that two lynches a day isn't good.

spiesr wrote:

ace1217 wrote:

Minister Masket wrote:I will begin again my eternal search for replacements, although do bear in mind the amount of "fresh meat" these days is limited.
And despite the nasty posting, at least there is discussion - better than none. However, the price you pay for such vulgarity may be your life.

Is what I'm worried about.

Really? I interpreted this to mean that those who lost their cool while arguing were liable to be lynched...

Possible, but MM rarely does such mundane things, which was why its generally a rather idea to be paranoid in a game with MM modding or playing.

Well, while having a daykill and a lynch every day is certainly a useful tool, if the mafia is smart (which they may or may not be) they can lower the advantage it provides by setting suspicion against the right person early in the day to try and sway the daykiller, as it could possibly be easier to influence than a full town lynch?

Anyhow, I still don't see Iliad as mafia. He looks much more like third party. Whether in the long run he turns out to be compatible with a town victory or just an sk, we shall see.

As for Suspect, I am still not sure he is not telling the truth. His continued argument are shaking my faith though and I could see myself switching vies on him...

spiesr wrote:Well, while having a daykill and a lynch every day is certainly a useful tool, if the mafia is smart (which they may or may not be) they can lower the advantage it provides by setting suspicion against the right person early in the day to try and sway the daykiller, as it could possibly be easier to influence than a full town lynch?

Anyhow, I still don't see Iliad as mafia. He looks much more like third party. Whether in the long run he turns out to be compatible with a town victory or just an sk, we shall see.

As for Suspect, I am still not sure he is not telling the truth. His continued argument are shaking my faith though and I could see myself switching vies on him...

So the mafia's strategy would be for all of them to try to attack one person. Because that wouldn't expose them all, not at all.

Well they might try it since it's already assumed they would never try it.

/ wrote:Well they might try it since it's already assumed they would never try it.

They might try, just then they will be exposed and lose.

You post like you are certain that they would be instantly exposed. Would they really? I mean we have had lynches and prelynches turned to daykills already bu you act like we know for sure that the mafia didn't set any of these up because if they did such a thing they would be instantly exposed. How exactly could we be sure that the mafia is or is not doing such things. If they are smart, they could quietly build up support to lynch/kill someone outside their group without being exposed. I mean the mafia is capable of blending in and voting for or arguing against people.

On a slightly differnt topic, two "lynches" per day is a good thing, if they are properly used. If they are mishandled, either by poor town work or mafia influence, they can get the town in trouble faster than one person dying each day phase. So far our performance with these "lynches" has been not overly great. But, it is still not like

Suspect101 wrote:Except that 2 town lynches a day = VERY BAD

Iliad wrote:I said f*ck, once. And not even directed at anyone.

wrong it was directed at me.


sorry for my poor form this game everyone.

Right then, we have the lovely (and short) Skoffin lined up to replace one of our wonderful deadbeats. Here are the three worst offenders:

Snorri1234 wrote:

6) icedagger

10) Natewolfman

13) animorpherv1

All people who haven't really contributed much.

But what's this?

Iliad wrote:But him exactly. Out of all the people inactive MM judged that he was the most important and the most needed to replace. After all who is more important than mafia godfather?

Accused of role favourtism now? Well if that's the way you feel, you lot can decide which of the three is replaced by Skoffin. Simply put their name at the end of your next post. I love breaking new ground.

ace1217 wrote:Possible, but MM rarely does such mundane things, which was why its generally a rather idea to be paranoid in a game with MM modding or playing.

I see someone brought over more memories of Trivial Twist than he should've done.

Bonus: Vote Count!

icedagger - 0
Nzen - 0
Natewolfman - 1 (nagerous)
Snorri1234 - 0
Stroop - 0 ()
ace1217 - 0
spiesr - 0
animorpherv1 - 0
nagerous - 0
Suspect 101 - 6 (Iliad, Snorri, Nzen, /, Stroop, sheep)
sheepofdumb - 0
/ - 0
Iliad - 1 (Suspect)

Had you lot realised that Suspect is at Lynch -1?

Minister Masket wrote:Right then, we have the lovely (and short) Skoffin lined up to replace one of our wonderful deadbeats. Here are the three worst offenders:

Snorri1234 wrote:

6) icedagger

10) Natewolfman

13) animorpherv1

All people who haven't really contributed much.

But what's this?

Iliad wrote:But him exactly. Out of all the people inactive MM judged that he was the most important and the most needed to replace. After all who is more important than mafia godfather?

Accused of role favourtism now? Well if that's the way you feel, you lot can decide which of the three is replaced by Skoffin. Simply put their name at the end of your next post. I love breaking new ground.

ace1217 wrote:Possible, but MM rarely does such mundane things, which was why its generally a rather idea to be paranoid in a game with MM modding or playing.

I see someone brought over more memories of Trivial Twist than he should've done.

Except skoffin has already said she can't replace.

Skimmer.

Well, had at one point figured that it was -1 or 2, but out of mind out of mind.


icedagger

Yeah, I agree with replacing icedagger. Nate seems to be on the site at least.

sorry guys ive been crazy buisy, I didnt even know day 4 started up

anyone wana give me a recap of what I missed?

My watcher powers combined with info from the scene led to Iliad killing Drench (Mafia Usurper) with town support. Afterwords Suspect (who recently replaced Militant) got into an argument with Iliad (The daykiller of uncertain alignment). Each has accused the other. Suspect has claimed minimandy, the town role blocker, and stated that militant never used the power. The town has mostly sided with Iliad in the argument and Suspect is now one vote away from being lynched.

Ice seems to be somewhat active in posting elsewhere, he could probably be prodded.
I vote to replace animorpherv, even if he somehow came back after nearly a month offline, him coming back drastically lowers any faction he belongs to survival rate.

/ wrote:Ice seems to be somewhat active in posting elsewhere, he could probably be prodded.
I vote to replace animorpherv, even if he somehow came back after nearly a month offline, him coming back drastically lowers any faction he belongs to survival rate.

oh uhhh,
animorpherv1

You want to bring back the claimed lynchee?

Are you hoping that once he is replaced he can be lynched so you, the lyncher, can win?

This has gone on far enough. Hammertime! vote suspect101.

spiesr wrote:You want to bring back the claimed lynchee?

Are you hoping that once he is replaced he can be lynched so you, the lyncher, can win?

hm? oh it's been awhile can't keep track of things, I had completely forgotten that claim, I should really start writing evidence down.
Well that claim happened to lead up to a JOAT's death, but I guess we really won't find anything either way there.... since he never gave us a name and he's obviously not sending in any potential actions. let's just hope we don't mislynch to the point where we are in fact endgamed by an absentee mafia.
I'd change my vote, but it doesn't really matter anyways.

Actually Iliad she was concerned about game info, but I PM'd her and it's fine now. Obviously I couldn't post anything like that in the forums.

Rotten Civilities
Despite the loss of her brother, Mimimandy had struggled through. However, after cussing to her fellows in rhymes, the drawn had had enough. The poetry would end here...


Suspect101 - Minimandy (Roleblocker) has been lynched!

Night 5 Begins!

Oh, and animorpherv will be replaced. I know icedagger can be reliable, but he will be prodded.

JESUS f*ck!

normally I'd be a bit dismayed that we lost a townie but if I was mod he would have been mod killed on the spot. So good riddance.

Modkilled for what?

Excessive cursing.