Conquer Club

These is a suspected Secret Alliance

Suspect users: rockinthe5uburbs and man22we

Game number: Game 422351


Gilligan

bump

Gilligan wrote:bump

It hasn't even been 2 hours! Now I'm gonna let you wait on purpose before I look at it.

Sorry, but it was the 10th one on the list, so I bumped.

Bump

Gilligan wrote:8-[

Sorry, but it was the 10th one on the list, so I bumped.

hahaha! BUMP

BUMP it was about 15th on the list

Come on AK...

This post will be locked, until AK decides to look into it. There's no need to keep bumping your post here. Someone will get to it when they are ready.

Yeah, 2 days was enough. Next time don't bump it until it hits page 3.

Ok, Game 422351.... this was an interesting investigation.
First off... rockinthe5uburbs and man22we are cleared of a secret alliance.

But wait, the investigation isn't over. I also investigated strikesocom, Gilligan, and Lord Paradise because it seemed like you 3 had an alliance going on. First off, you're all 3 in the same clan but you're playing standard games together? Second, Lord Paradise owns the Great Lakes continent, but the only borders he bothers to defend are the ones adjacent to non-clan members. Coincidence? I think not.

strikesocom is busted for multiple accounts with princess553311, Mewchu11, and Idance9999.
Lord Paradise and Gilligan have been blocked from playing together.

Well that kinda backfired, eh? Bad luck Gill.

AK_iceman wrote:Yeah, 2 days was enough. Next time don't bump it until it hits page 3.

Ok, Game 422351.... this was an interesting investigation.
First off... rockinthe5uburbs and man22we are cleared of a secret alliance.

But wait, the investigation isn't over. I also investigated strikesocom, Gilligan, and Lord Paradise because it seemed like you 3 had an alliance going on. First off, you're all 3 in the same clan but you're playing standard games together? Second, Lord Paradise owns the Great Lakes continent, but the only borders he bothers to defend are the ones adjacent to non-clan members. Coincidence? I think not.

strikesocom is busted for multiple accounts with princess553311, Mewchu11, and Idance9999.
Lord Paradise and Gilligan have been blocked from playing together.

AK! Hear me out loud! Lord Paradise was the last one to go, and he DID NOT have the Great Lakes when I was taking my last turn! And what is wrong with playing standard games together? And, about the Great Lakes, we ANNOUNCED AN ALLIANCE IN THE CHAT. We did not have a secret alliance!! We are best friends in real life!

Gilligan wrote:AK! Hear me out loud! Lord Paradise was the last one to go, and he DID NOT have the Great Lakes when I was taking my last turn! And what is wrong with playing standard games together? And, about the Great Lakes, we ANNOUNCED AN ALLIANCE IN THE CHAT. We did not have a secret alliance!! We are best friends in real life!

Ok... I realize that he did not have Great Lakes on the previous turn, but he does have it now and he left his borders with you and strikesocom completely unguarded!
And about your "alliance"...

2007-05-10 11:20:05 - Lord Paradise: Alliance against red!
2007-05-10 11:22:59 - Gilligan: It is too early.

This doesn't sound to me like you agreed to anything, and you guys didn't announce that you knew each other in the chat. Sorry, but my ruling stands.

2007-05-12 18:17:48 - strikesocom: I have a theory that pink and teal are in an alliance, due to him not attacking an obviously undefended border. (Arkansas to Mississippi) If this is true, MANORMEN UNITE!
2007-05-12 19:08:10 - Gilligan: *punches sky*
2007-05-14 15:26:41 - Lord Paradise: Huzzah.
2007-05-14 15:28:09 - Lord Paradise: Make sure you hold New Mexico, Gills. Get some armies on there. Meaty, go for the Rockies.

What is all of this then? We said of our alliance. Why are we blocked anyway?

Well, Gilligan, you've really gone and done it now.

I want to know why my friend and I are blocked. I want to know.

I'd like to confirm that we did no tactical discussion of the game outside of the game, and my leaving the borders undefended was a desperate gambit based on the shaky truce we had ("Manormen unite!" was the key word there.) I understand the reasoning here, because I get that we should have noted that we were friends, but in my opinion a warning would have sufficed. May I ask if this ruling is permanent?

I've asked a Multi-Hunter to double check my investigation. He'll post here when he's finished.

And stop changing the thread title or I'll lock it up again.

AK_iceman wrote:I've asked a Multi-Hunter to double check my investigation. He'll post here when he's finished.

And stop changing the thread title or I'll lock it up again.

I'm sorry. Really. I just got mad a little. My temper is short.

I am checking this out.

Thanks a bunch, FP.

I am not the same person as Gilligan, nor would I ever want to be.

Lord Paradise wrote:I am not the same person as Gilligan, nor would I ever want to be.

The question isn't same person, it is secret alliance.

But there was no secret alliance!