Moderator: Tournament Directors
Swifte wrote:sailorc got kicked from our game for missing turns. Game 11309393
chapcrap wrote:Round 4 getting ready to go!
merch313 wrote:Tourney still active
ThrushAAX wrote:Hey chapcrap can we get some clarity on Game 12308443. Is blue or yellow correct? Thanks
Night Strike wrote:The organizer did not put a rule against such actions in his tournament structure, and there is not currently an overall tournament rule against such actions, even in assassin games, so the result of the game should stand.chapcrap wrote:cwinslow22 wrote:pindary deliberately killed the wrong target so that he would not be eliminated and would advance to the next round. This can't possibly be acceptable, right?
I'm going to bring Night Strike in because he's the Head TD and in charge of rulings.
So, I'm going to say my thoughts, but if NS wants to overrule me, that is fine. NS, we're talking about Game 12308443.
Basically, there is no punishment for this. In tournament games, winning the tournament, is a goal. So, historically, there is no wrong in what he did. I think that it sucks for someone to do that instead of just trying to win the game himself, but what he did was advance himself.
For reference see this: viewtopic.php?f=239&t=171114#p3738909
chap
sandman175 wrote:I think 9 rounds into the tourney is a little late to start changing the rules. Are we going to go back and replay every game where this happened in this tourney? Personally, I like to win games, but if someone finds a loophole to stay alive then good for them. I agree with Night Strike that the game should stand.
cwinslow22 wrote:sandman175 wrote:I think 9 rounds into the tourney is a little late to start changing the rules. Are we going to go back and replay every game where this happened in this tourney? Personally, I like to win games, but if someone finds a loophole to stay alive then good for them. I agree with Night Strike that the game should stand.
Says the guy who only won the game because someone else took out his target. Go figure. I think we should go back and replay every game where this happened. What's that? This is the only game it happened in?? I'm utterly shocked. Look, i have nothing to gain from a replay since i was already advancing, just think it's ridiculous for someone to benefit by deliberately throwing a game.
chapcrap wrote:Congratulations on making the finals. The last lady in my life. Her name is Saundra.
I had just moved back from Seattle. It was the middle of June and I was meeting some friends at a swimming pool and Saundra was there. We met and started hanging out in the summer. I had already graduated college, but she was still in school. She moved back to her sorority in August and came back to town occasionally to see family. So, we saw each other sometimes. However, it wasn't until Christmas that I really let her in and we started dating. We got engaged in May, on my birthday, and we were married by the next Christmas. She won't break your heart like all the other girls!!
Good luck!
P.S. Go pester her to play more!! Her name is cardinal.baby
chapcrap wrote:cwinslow22 wrote:sandman175 wrote:I think 9 rounds into the tourney is a little late to start changing the rules. Are we going to go back and replay every game where this happened in this tourney? Personally, I like to win games, but if someone finds a loophole to stay alive then good for them. I agree with Night Strike that the game should stand.
Says the guy who only won the game because someone else took out his target. Go figure. I think we should go back and replay every game where this happened. What's that? This is the only game it happened in?? I'm utterly shocked. Look, i have nothing to gain from a replay since i was already advancing, just think it's ridiculous for someone to benefit by deliberately throwing a game.
We don't need to have the thread devolve into something else. Sandman175 has voted no, so that's that.
I will say that this happened in no other game. I have checked every game along the way and the only winners were people who killed their own target.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users