These solutions do not address the Core issue:

The OLD System worked fine for EVERYONE except lazy mods and players with bad attitudes.

Star Ratings are always going to be arbitrary, especially if given a # value. the simple, efficient, positive, Neutral, Negative system, along with the ...

gotta say that the new system replaces simple, easy to understand Positive/Negative ratings and informative information about players with meaningless arbitrarily assigned numbers. (the difference between a 4 and 5 means nothing when assigned by different people). A person can miss turns and still ...

Robinette wrote:So is the glass half FULL, or half EMPTY ???

If half the container has water, I have water.