They're not back

Good thing is dgz and blacky are not scum together I think..

So I definitely would say lynch 1 of them if we're lynching active.

But I don't see blacky being scum really for the reasons I mentioned.

I'd go dgz >> blacky >> ragian >> strike.

I don't think ending the day like this is good for town ...

And so I may be falling for confirmation bias but it does seem like more things are pointing to dgz being scum.

On the other hand if I'm being objective the fact that he's possibly the most active player here is a rather strong town tell statistically so I'm a little hesitant.

Ragian where do you ...

I don't think blacky is scum, I jumped on what I felt was some inconsistencies in his narrative early in the game but since then I've got this feeling he's scum's designated mislynch.
It would also kind of explain the night kill because I don't think the average scum, particularly if somewhat new ...

Where is everyone?

I've been here 2-3 times a day looking for new posts.

But I would also not include myself in the term everyone here.

Not the worst offender by any means if at all, but everyone includes every one.

And yeah I for one don't know really how to create conversations in mafia I ...

Where is everyone?

What a lame way of posing a question

Interrogator: "Have you stopped beating your wife?"
Accused: "Any answer condemns me."

@blacky, I hope to see you back here. However, I need you to explain what it is about the voting patterns and the posts that make you think dgz is scum. I don't need you to ...

dgz345 wrote:vote blacky

Why blacky?

Ragian wrote:Why not just no lynch?

Because that would put us back to even numbers and negate our no lynch on day 1.

Dude I'm sorry my hand slipped and grazed your bum I didn't mean it.

Nice. I'm a double voter

Cheers for the VC. Now we need one of the other sleepers in here to finish the day or, perhaps unthinkable, participate in the day.


Is this how this game will go? .. L-1 .. wait a few days.. some lurker drops in to hammer?

@Aage - will the zame modkill rule in day 1 ...

Looks like strike is down to lynch both but he ended up voting my choice between skoffin/razor.

Guess I have to follow through now Unvote Vote Razor

Ragian wrote:I always feel iffy around trigger happy dgz, but I'm usually wrong about him, so I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt right now.

The thing is, BuJ, I don't see what we learn from a Raz lynch as opposed to a Skoffin lynch.

Hmm. Okay what do you think we will learn from a skoffin lynch then?

Tbh I'd rather lynch razor in this case strike, rather than risk mislynching skoffin so early in the game if she's town.

So I'll be switching my vote there if nobody agrees with my dgz case.

Ragian wrote:Why do you think dgz is scummy?

I didn't like his analysis on day 1. It felt to me like he was inventing reasons to draw conclusions based on inconsequential events where if we listened to him we would end up lynching at least 2 people to prove him wrong.

I think dgz is pretty scummy,
I have a suspicion regarding Pika dominating the discussion day 1 then less in day 2 except to once again defend his arguments of day 1 with mets.
Skoffin's responses to suspicion and reasoning for suspecting people is iffy though I'm not sure she'd be this passive as ...

:lol:

I've always been a jerk. I'm sorry that I've started to ask things of you in this game. You usually volunteer the stuff town needs for a win.

Blacky, Razor, Pika haven't been about for ages, I feel.

Nah I was just giving you a hard time.

I used to be a lot more free and less exhausted ...

She could be scum herself doing a classic deflection vote.

Something about Ragian is a little off though .. maybe it's just the recent fatherhood making him more of a jerk

Excuse me skoffin but I found a discrpeancy within his posts here and I pointed it out. I don't care if you consider him still a rookie, he's obviously far more knowledgeable than how he presents himself.

And forget rereading everything I can do that in due time.. I feel like most of the mets/pika ...

I forgot about this and haven't been able to catch up past two days.. will read up when I can

Also Ragian I suspect dgz. And I do like pressure on people not posting also. What I don't like is people who come up with cases/reasons to suspect people (whether they're good reasons or not is irrelevant for this point), but then vote somebody else who they're kinda 'meh' about or is a ...

Also Ragian I suspect dgz. And I do like pressure on people not posting also. What I don't like is people who come up with cases/reasons to suspect people (whether they're good reasons or not is irrelevant for this point), but then vote somebody else who they're kinda 'meh' about or is a popular ...

As WIFOMy as this is, I tend to think that he wouldn't have done such an obvious shady move if he were actually town scum. But that kinda assumes he's experienced enough to recognize that it will look really bad.

The whole issue from D1 is that people like Pika and dgz were arguing that not only ...

well from my perspective its real hard to tell who is bullshitting and who is not.

The only scummy post that really caught my eye was from Mets, when I ended Day 1.

Now you may say HA he just ended it to get onto night action, but that is not true. There was a lot of debate about why end the day ...