Best mafia game of all time(pre nomination)

[ga7]

When you say Super Mario, do you mean this classic or XG's game?

The classic obviously I went for that one, mostly because of how the game flowed, and I love comeback victories. NJO was also high on my list for the same reason

[pancakemix]

When you say Super Mario, do you mean this classic or XG's game?

I just looked back at that one (yours) and I have mad roleblocking skills.

[Fircoal]

Why is no one else voting for NV3 >_>

[InkL0sed]

Neighborhood Mafia was the best I played in... Asylum would have been better for me if I had been a better player at the time. I guess it still says a lot that I liked it anyway.

[icedagger]

I probably enjoyed naruto or wrong turn the most

[Minister Masket]

I probably enjoyed naruto or wrong turn the most

YES!
A nomination! That I was not expecting!

On a jokey level, I personally would vote for any game where I was either:
A) A jester
B) Innovative enough to infuriate ga7 and possibly ruin the game for him.

Seriously, I enjoyed the New Jedi Order game immensly, the Vong one. My vote goes to that one.

[Iliad]

Does my gothic mafia count? You were a necromancer and I accidentaly made the role too powerful (night 1 he knew all of one mafia(4 people) and he had a one time invulnerability

[0ojakeo0]

if any1 wants to make a list of newly nominated games i can make another poll and then make a finals poll will top 5 of this and top 5 of that

[FloresDelMal]

grimms was promising

[nagerous]

I declare myself greatest mafia mod evar having most combined votes

[sheepofdumb]

NV3 was my first mafia game if I remember correctly. Good times.

[kwanton]

Civil War, Bad Poets Society (someone do a second one!!!!), and Dawn of War stick out for me.

Batman was good too but that was in my early days and I don't remember it that well.

Edit: Wait a minute! I already posted here. Who was the jerk who bumped?!

[jnd94]

BPS Take 2!!!

I love it!

I still remember my role:Nina Stickler, you write nonets.

[kwanton]

BPS Take 2!!!

I love it!

I still remember my role:Nina Stickler, you write nonets.

I got some french dude. Rondeau style bitches.

[mandalorian2298]

BPS Take 2!!!

I love it!

I still remember my role:Nina Stickler, you write nonets.

GRAAAAAAAHHHRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!

Please don't say 'Nina Stickler' anymore Jnd, the reflexive head-banging hurts my head.

Someone should totally run BPS 2, though. Anyone knows where Aimless can be found?

[cena-rules]

civil war

[animorpherv1]

Ninja Stickler.

I'd like to see umm..... let me think...... I don't know, really, but I'd like to see Tal make another grimms.