Moderator: Tournament Directors
frankroz wrote:Banana Update:
98 games in the books
Colson has clinched 1 of the 2 automatic bids.
Herus has been eliminated.
Total Points:
Colson 481
Lisbon 475
Globe 470
Roz 467
Lunatic 444
Chadwick 437
Kid 434
Herus 398
colson wrote:One error is your scoring in the Banana group is that Lisbon101 doesn't have any bonus points yet... yet you have him with 11. Chadwick has 11 but you only have him with 6. That needs to be fixed.
colson wrote:Your totals are also off for the Banana group. You might want to check your spreadsheet totals. Personally I have around 508 as I calculated it by hand.
Is officially changed to:Round 3
This round will have 24 players split into 3 groups
Top two players move on. There are two wildcard spots that will go to the two highest scores not already in the final game
Could we change the Rule additions and changes:To move to the Final round you must be 1 of the top two players in your group. Two wild cards will also advance. Wild cards will be determine by Total MBIV wins from rounds 1-3.
to reflect the change?Rule Additions and Changes
Look here for any changes that may occur during the tournament
1. I have added an extra round to the Tourney so a total of four rounds will be played
2. Changed Bonus rounds to 2nd and 3rd rounds
3. New Maps have been added. Games 84-86 look for a PM with the new games
4. New Maps have been added for a total of 97 eight player maps
5. ]Two more maps have been added to the play list
The Citadel
Archipelago
Donedanalan wrote:If this original rule:
Is officially changed to:Round 3
This round will have 24 players split into 3 groups
Top two players move on. There are two wildcard spots that will go to the two highest scores not already in the final game
Could we change the Rule additions and changes:To move to the Final round you must be 1 of the top two players in your group. Two wild cards will also advance. Wild cards will be determine by Total MBIV wins from rounds 1-3.
to reflect the change?Rule Additions and Changes
Look here for any changes that may occur during the tournament
1. I have added an extra round to the Tourney so a total of four rounds will be played
2. Changed Bonus rounds to 2nd and 3rd rounds
3. New Maps have been added. Games 84-86 look for a PM with the new games
4. New Maps have been added for a total of 97 eight player maps
5. ]Two more maps have been added to the play list
The Citadel
Archipelago
Also, I protest this change -- total wins in the tourney were never mentioned as a deciding factor, and that changes strategy pretty drastically. I understand where you're going -- the tourney scoring rewards a 'safe' strategy, rather than a 'win' strategy. You could have taken my suggestion in Round 1 to change the scoring (1 for 8th, 4 for 7th, 6 for 6th, 8 for 5th, 10 for 4th, 12 for 3rd, 15 for 2nd, 20 for 1st -- like 'spoils' distribution) to fix this structural deficiency, but to make a rule change in the 3rd round is pretty arbitrary, IMHO.
In any case, the tourney has been great, but grueling, and I look forward to MBV -- although please consider my scoring recommendation to improve the competition.
Great thanks for the feed back...I will change the scoring for MBV to discourage not playing as for MBIV is for it appears that the scoring will remain the samePhr34ky wrote:If it matters, I agree with dan's idea of changing the scoring, although not this late in the tournament.