IB - Super Smash Smalltown (Game Over)

[Sierra_Leon]

I think we can assume MM blocked farside last night.

[farside22]

Before I claim I would like to know who Nate tageted last night. It will make a difference I believe.

[Natewolfman]

I was rollblocked last night

[farside22]

@Drench did you note the flavor of the kills as day 1 a person was shot and day 2 a person was stabbed. Do you believe there is a difference or just mod flavoring?

[farside22]

Hmmm this makes things interesting. 1 kill again last night.
I will tell you that last night I jailed Ace. I was suspicious of the fact that he did not vote derf day 1.
So either Ace or Nate in my view is either mafia or SK at this point.

[animorpherv1]

<not needed> Of course, i had no action.

That's a good thing, considering my dad took it all of 2 days ago.

[ace1217]

Hmmm this makes things interesting. 1 kill again last night.
I will tell you that last night I jailed Ace. I was suspicious of the fact that he did not vote derf day 1.
So either Ace or Nate in my view is either mafia or SK at this point.

There is a third option: you are the corrupted one here. Although I must admit that I was roleblocked last night, but you may have not killed last night.

[Drench]

edit

[Natewolfman]

To the matter of 1 kill per night...it is obvious that an anti-town faction has been roleblocked each night. The only two people that can do that (now) is the Jailkeeper and the Roleblocker. Look at night one. Nate and MM was roleblocked. Notice how MM is dead and town. This leaves one person. By no means conclusive, but something to think about. HOWEVER. If we look at the flavor (and we are going into very murky territory here that is by no means true), we can assume that the SK was blocked N1. One player is the SK. One player is unknown and roleblocked on N1. However, it is also possible Nate is scum. 50/50 chance to be blocked then if he is, but that is certainly possible.

And now for night 2. Nate and Ace were roleblocked. Nate is already on the list N1, so the flavor means nothing. Ace was also revealed as being roleblocked. This means that one of Ace and Nate are innocent, as there was only one blocked scum. Look above, where Nate comes under suspicion. At this stage, I'm willing to bet that Nate is scum and Ace is town.

Vote: Nate. L-3 people. Thoughts?

assumeing everything you say here is true, and it all sounds very nice and flashy (perhaps a little too flashy for my tastes...) ace is scum, though you painted a huge target on my back, and will likelly end up getting lynched because of it. You will see that I am town, and if after that ace ends up being town, be sure to look at Drench (this addressed to the rest of the townies)

[Drench]

edit

[Natewolfman]

To the matter of 1 kill per night...it is obvious that an anti-town faction has been roleblocked each night. The only two people that can do that (now) is the Jailkeeper and the Roleblocker. Look at night one. Nate and MM was roleblocked. Notice how MM is dead and town. This leaves one person. By no means conclusive, but something to think about. HOWEVER. If we look at the flavor (and we are going into very murky territory here that is by no means true), we can assume that the SK was blocked N1. One player is the SK. One player is unknown and roleblocked on N1. However, it is also possible Nate is scum. 50/50 chance to be blocked then if he is, but that is certainly possible.

And now for night 2. Nate and Ace were roleblocked. Nate is already on the list N1, so the flavor means nothing. Ace was also revealed as being roleblocked. This means that one of Ace and Nate are innocent, as there was only one blocked scum. Look above, where Nate comes under suspicion. At this stage, I'm willing to bet that Nate is scum and Ace is town.

Vote: Nate. L-3 people. Thoughts?

assumeing everything you say here is true, and it all sounds very nice and flashy (perhaps a little too flashy for my tastes...) ace is scum, though you painted a huge target on my back, and will likelly end up getting lynched because of it. You will see that I am town, and if after that ace ends up being town, be sure to look at Drench (this addressed to the rest of the townies)

Ex-ca-huse-me?

assumeing everything you say here is true, and it all sounds very nice and flashy (perhaps a little too flashy for my tastes...)

Elaborate please. You use alot of words and alot of exact references is all I mean

ace is scum, though you painted a huge target on my back, and will likelly end up getting lynched because of it.

One question:

Why is Ace scum in your opinion excluding my line of reasoning? because I know I am not, therefor if your resoning is correct then he must be scum, no?

You will see that I am town, and if after that ace ends up being town,

I don't know about you, but I think this is leaning to an Appeal (Emotion?). And it is impossible for both of you to be the same alignment... Dont know what you mean my Appeal emotion

be sure to look at Drench (this addressed to the rest of the townies)

...which makes this kinda redundant. aye, but it must have been stated, you would assume the same if both ace and myself turn up town

Also "addressed to the rest of the townies"? Isn't everyone trying to be town here? Was that part really necessary? probably not, but I wanted to make sure that everyone knew it was for them, and not specifically addressed to you (do to the quote)

[Drench]

edit

[Natewolfman]

only 1 part of that I think you needed me to answer, again in red

ace is scum, though you painted a huge target on my back, and will likelly end up getting lynched because of it.

One question:

Why is Ace scum in your opinion excluding my line of reasoning? because I know I am not, therefor if your resoning is correct then he must be scum, no?

I did ask for reasons other than my reasoning. How about other instances?

I have none, as I said it was all working off the assumption that you are 100% flawlessly correct and that either Ace or I am scum, and since i know 100%(though everyone else may not) that I am not scum, then logically ace is. Again this is all just *IF* everything in your post is in the exact right direction

[Drench]

edit

[Natewolfman]

only 1 part of that I think you needed me to answer, again in red

ace is scum, though you painted a huge target on my back, and will likelly end up getting lynched because of it.

One question:

Why is Ace scum in your opinion excluding my line of reasoning? because I know I am not, therefor if your resoning is correct then he must be scum, no?

I did ask for reasons other than my reasoning. How about other instances?

I have none, as I said it was all working off the assumption that you are 100% flawlessly correct and that either Ace or I am scum, and since i know 100%(though everyone else may not) that I am not scum, then logically ace is. Again this is all just *IF* everything in your post is in the exact right direction

So, you're saying you don't trust my reasoning, and that people should look at me, and yet the only reason you suspect Ace is because of the very reasoning you distrust? I smell a contradiction.

? no thats not what I said, in fact I do trust what you are saying, it seems logical, I mentioned before too many specifics make me uneasy, but your line of thinking seems rational enough. What I was saying is that what you say seems logical BUT if neither myself or ace turn up skum they should look at you, that is all.

[Drench]

edit

[Its Bolt]

Vote Count

Natewolfman (2) - Drench

Not Voting (7) - LSU Tiger Josh, animorpherv1, Sierra_Leon, farside22, /, Natewolfman, ace1217

[/]

<not needed> Of course, i had no action.

That's a good thing, considering my dad took it all of 2 days ago.

Huh, so if you were a SK and had an action to send in, you wouldn't have been able to send it?
Not that I'm saying you are, but still we can't completely rely on roleblocking theories when there are potentially missed actions.

[ace1217]

I'm rather disappointed you blocked me farside, because I watched MM last night, but I was blocked. Also, one of the killers may have attempted to kill me last night, due to the fact I was jailkept, however, I survived. The roleblockings may be irrelevant.

[Sierra_Leon]

Hi, I was gone for a few days but I'm back now. I haven't read up yet, and I'm not sure when I'll have time for it. Hopefully soon, but Friday at latest.

[animorpherv1]

Vote Count

Natewolfman (2) - Drench

[farside22]

Ace: I had thought your actions about derf lynched and leaned scum. However I will conceed that it is possible I saved you from being killed by jailing you.
That leaves Nate. I do agree with Drench with one kill only that leaves either Ace or Nate as scum or serial killer. I'm believing that shot night 1 is flavor for scum but I could be wrong.
With that I will give ace the bennifit.

vote: Nate

[Its Bolt]

Vote Count

Natewolfman (3) - Drench, farside22

Not Voting (6) - animorpherv1, LSU Tiger Josh, Sierra_Leon, /, Natewolfman, ace1217

With 8 alive it takes five to lynch
Deadline is now February 19th at 11:00 AM PST

[ace1217]

Vote nate since he's likely scum and going without a lynch today would be bad.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote Nate let's get the lynch and finish off the mafia hopefully and then nail the sk.