[These cases have been closed. If you would like to appeal the decision of the hunter please open a ticket on the help page and the case will be looked into by a second hunter.]
Tisha and Razox conspired to give the game to Tisha, after Razox had enough armies come on to wipe Tisha from the board, claims to have miss deployed, but never forted for attack, and hasn't attacked. This is a Secret Alliance.
It's clear that the Alliance was broken by posting in this forum about it. There was a Clear and Open Alliance that was to Exist until Round 8, but after Round 8, the Alliance continued, with Razox clearly trying to GIVE the game to Tisha. I'm no sore loser, but CHEATING to GIVE Someone Points with a Secret Alliance is just WRONG.
I read the game log, and when razox attacked trep, he took him out on that turn. That is prove that he was playing for himself, and not to help someone else. He also went on to win the game, he did not give it to tisha.
Having looked at the game logs again, I can clearly see that Tisha had nothing to do with this, but that Razox in trying to impress Tisha did all he could to GIVE the game to Tisha. Not Tisha's fault that Razox tried to give her the game. Razox on the other hand would not have taken this game had I not Posted here in the Forum. Sorry Tisha, didn't realize that Razox ALONE tried to give the game away.