Good enough for # 2
Moderator: Community Team
JBoy wrote:Hi Blitz..have a new one for top 5 under 40%..10 JBoy 3879 1061 283 (27%) General General......thanks...



How do you mean,you want to put only people who get medal,or do you want to put map makers who work all job on creating a map?ok, I am going to revamp this and only count the TOP map makers who receive a medal for making the map
anyone help me with th top 5 that have this info?
qwert wrote:How do you mean,you want to put only people who get medal,or do you want to put map makers who work all job on creating a map?ok, I am going to revamp this and only count the TOP map makers who receive a medal for making the map
anyone help me with th top 5 that have this info?



barterer2002 wrote:Blitz I recently went and looked at the medals for a tournament. I don't have the exact numbers in front of my but will link to the players so you can check (also in case it changes)
cairnswk
Widowmakers
Yeti C
Qwert
oaktown
Coleman
Dim
RjBeals
edbeard
gimil
Jota
mibi
I think those would be the names with at least 5 mapmaking medals but its possible i missed someone

qwert wrote:I must say,that you must check very carefull who get medal for what.
Rule is that only 2 medal can be awarded for creating a map,but in some cases(i think that these is not right) 6 people get medal for creating a map(Classic Art). Who realy deserve medal for work on these map,its still mistery for many map makers,except for these 6 people who know exactly who work what.These is not correct,and i will not count these medals.
Also i think that you need to create new category-Top 5 XML Developers,because you now have in your list only people who not create any graphic on map,and work only in XML development(Yeti,C).These will be more correct.

qwert wrote:http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=127&t=73937
these will help you,its not update with new quenched maps,but can be good for start(and you have Medal Awards)

qwert wrote:Map Maker
1.Cairnswk-20
2.WM-12
3.Qwert-8
4.Oaktown-6
5.Jota-5
6.Mibi-5
7.Dim-5
8.Rjbeals-4
9.Edbeard-3
10.Gimil-3
XML Designer
1.Yeti_c-12
2.Coleman-8
3.Lanyard-3
4.Zimmah-3
5.High.Commander-2
--------------------------------------------
i need to check for new updates



I'm not sure you should split them out like this, as some mapmakers do their own XML...Blitzaholic wrote:is this right now qwert?
Map Maker
1.Cairnswk-22
2.WM-19
3.Qwert-8
4.Oaktown-7
5.Dim-6
XML Designer
1.Yeti_c-13
2.Coleman-8
3.Lanyard-3
4.Zimmah-3
5.High.Commander-2

Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
gimil wrote:Widowmakers is on 20 medals. I do not think it is fair that qwert has 'decided' that those who made the classic shapes map don't get their medal counted. They put the work in and obviously admin decided they deserved it.


It seems like the fair and just solution is that if you earned a medal for graphics, gameplay, XML, or whatever in regards to a map, it should just count as a map contribution medal across the board. I say the best way to do it is to make your Top 5 list based on the total number of medals that person has, regardless of the reasoning behind why they got it in the first place. Map development incorporates many different aspects. With the graphic designer, it wouldn't look good, without the person to write the XML it wouldn't play at all because it literally wouldn't work.Blitzaholic wrote:gimil wrote:Widowmakers is on 20 medals. I do not think it is fair that qwert has 'decided' that those who made the classic shapes map don't get their medal counted. They put the work in and obviously admin decided they deserved it.
ok, how would you suggest it gimil?