Moderator: Cartographers
Because G Line has only 3 territories attacking it,knubbel wrote:why is the bonus for G just 3?
N for example has as many borders but less territs and is worth 4.


Nothing yet of significance that i know of.....although several months now after Rail Europe has gone live....there is a call from some to adjust the bonuses on two small bonus lines.MrBenn wrote:I'm not aware of any discussion about imbalance etc?
Does anybody have any legitimate concerns about imbalance, or has anybody noticed any glaring errors/omissions? If not we'll have to push the boat out....

This is a switch: the Boys In Blue pushing to quench the map, and the mapmaker saying "Let's take it slow".cairnswk wrote:Nothing yet of significance that i know of.....although several months now after Rail Europe has gone live....there is a call from some to adjust the bonuses on two small bonus lines.MrBenn wrote:I'm not aware of any discussion about imbalance etc?
Does anybody have any legitimate concerns about imbalance, or has anybody noticed any glaring errors/omissions? If not we'll have to push the boat out....
Is there any chance the boat can be left at the dock for a while longer while some games finish....this is a large map to conquer.
Yes,ender516 wrote:...
This is a switch: the Boys In Blue pushing to quench the map, and the mapmaker saying "Let's take it slow".
Does anyone know how many games have been played on Rail Europe and Rail Africa, just to get an idea of how many it might take to get people to call for adjustments?

Hmm, well then, we can't really wait for Rail Africa to get up into that level of play. I must say, I am enjoying this map.cairnswk wrote:Yes,ender516 wrote:...
This is a switch: the Boys In Blue pushing to quench the map, and the mapmaker saying "Let's take it slow".
Does anyone know how many games have been played on Rail Europe and Rail Africa, just to get an idea of how many it might take to get people to call for adjustments?![]()
I thought that was novel also.
Anyway, this map has just over 100 games finished.
R Europe has 3717 games finished.
I think if there is no calls for change in a week, then the boat can probably go out then.
hmmmm but in both cases you need to stack on three territs to defend the bonus. But I'm not very experienced with mapmaking (and I hardly play flat rate/ no spoils games) so maybe my opinion should not count that much. And since I hold the N bonus in the game that I'm playing on this map...cairnswk wrote:Because G Line has only 3 territories attacking it,knubbel wrote:why is the bonus for G just 3?
N for example has as many borders but less territs and is worth 4.
whereas N Line has 7 territories attacking it.
These bonuses are what bonus creator template makes, and these bonuses were supposedly gone over by the gameplay guys, so if they're happy with them....knubbel wrote:hmmmm but in both cases you need to stack on three territs to defend the bonus. But I'm not very experienced with mapmaking (and I hardly play flat rate/ no spoils games) so maybe my opinion should not count that much. And since I hold the N bonus in the game that I'm playing on this map...cairnswk wrote:Because G Line has only 3 territories attacking it,knubbel wrote:why is the bonus for G just 3?
N for example has as many borders but less territs and is worth 4.
whereas N Line has 7 territories attacking it.

On that note....Coleman wrote:I'd just like to say this is the best looking rail map by a large margin. I'm not sure what I like so much about it, but you definitely did something great here.
Congratulations cairnswk and AndrewB, your shiny new medals are well-earned 


Wow, Coleman. thanks.Coleman wrote:I'd just like to say this is the best looking rail map by a large margin. I'm not sure what I like so much about it, but you definitely did something great here.


Congrats cairnswk!! Great job!MrBenn wrote:
Conquer Club, enjoy!--MrBenn
I think it's because the places for the army numbers aren't boxes. The shape you used instead is quite aesthetically pleasing.cairnswk wrote:Wow, Coleman. thanks.Coleman wrote:I'd just like to say this is the best looking rail map by a large margin. I'm not sure what I like so much about it, but you definitely did something great here.![]()
Shame you couldn't place what you like about it.
L has 4 lands (there's one in Capetown) and effectively 5 bordering lands, that's why a +3 bonus.nikola_milicki wrote:can somebody please explain why L is a +3 bonus with 3 lands and 1 border when O is a +2 with 2 borders? how does this make sense??

cairnswk wrote:L has 4 lands (there's one in Capetown) and effectively 5 bordering lands, that's why a +3 bonus.nikola_milicki wrote:can somebody please explain why L is a +3 bonus with 3 lands and 1 border when O is a +2 with 2 borders? how does this make sense??