star wars mafia game over rebels win, with survivers help

[UTAlan]

It would only make sense for Colton to have been killed by the rebellion since the empire would have known he was imperial. I think it would make sense for the empire to not have a doctor since the game started with fewer rebels than empire.

Out of the remaining players, I haven't a clue which is rebel scum and needs to be lynched. :/

Unless I'm having a blackout, this statement is entirely nonsensical.

A) The Empire would NOT know Colton was imperial.

B) Town almost always has more people than scum and it almost always has a doctor.

Vote UTAlan though it won't make a difference.

I figured out later that it was the empire. My mistake on the workings of mafia games - that's the problem w/ being a rookie. Maybe I should have kept my mouth shut, but I was trying to contribute because at that point, not many people were posting anything helpful.

[Koesen]

I still think you need to be investigated and a replacement or modkill of Wolverine Mutant would be nice.

With that, I am going back to real life

[gregwolf121]

vote count
LSU (1) RE
RE-koesen (2) ga7, safari
UTA (1) koesen

with 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch
safari you never unvoted so your vote on page 32 wasn't counted
day will end at around 5 pm my time so in about three hours

[safariguy5]

ah....unvote vote Wolverine Mutant...not that it will matter...

[UTAlan]

I'm gonna vote Wolverine Mutant for his apparent submarining earlier, although I wouldn't do it if I thought he'd actually get lynched unless he'd be here to defend himself.

[UTAlan]

vote count
LSU (1) RE
RE-koesen (2) ga7, safari
UTA (1) koesen

with 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch
safari you never unvoted so your vote on page 32 wasn't counted
day will end at around 5 pm my time so in about three hours

Shouldn't RE's vote not count since Koesen has replaced him?

[cubfanpgh]

First, claim with no pressure. Why would you claim vanilla townie with no pressure?

As I recall, I had let my mouth run a bit, and wanted to clear suspicion. The PM to me indicated that it was in my interest to claim the role.

However, the role is not vanilla townie. Did I think it was? Yes, but I've never played mafia online before, and I was confused. I am a third party survivor.

Second, conflicting claim. First, he says third party, then says he's imperial citizen, then name drops owen lars. Also, a survivor claim.

Those are not conflicting. I am a third-party survivor. I am an imperial citizen. At least in my understanding, what would be considered vanilla townie is stormtrooper. As I said previously, I believe that spiesr had the same role. He was confirmed by the mod as an imperial citizen and a third party.

9. spiesr, imperial citizen, survivor, killed night 2

Now, with Owen Lars, I could see this as being a third-party survivor role. All the same, I suggest whatever investigative roles we have left to check him out tonight. Just to be sure.

I'm down with that. Do it. I don't know how many investigative roles are left, but investigate me. Killing would help no one (especially me).

[gregwolf121]

vote count
LSU (1) RE
RE-koesen (2) ga7, safari
UTA (1) koesen

with 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch
safari you never unvoted so your vote on page 32 wasn't counted
day will end at around 5 pm my time so in about three hours

Shouldn't RE's vote not count since Koesen has replaced him?

yes it shouldn't thank you for pointing that out

[gregwolf121]

vote count
RE-koesen (2) ga7, safari
UTA (1) koesen
wolverine mutant (2) UTA, safari
with 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch
day will end at around 5 pm my time so in about an hour and a half

[strike wolf]

I don't think anything I can say at this point would make much of a difference today as it has been pointed out but I would say that of all people the one I find most suspicious is wolverinemutant. I think any kind of night kill against him would be premature however I do feel he's someone that needs to be questioned if not investigated by any remaining cops out there.

[Koesen]

Unvote
Vote Wolverine

Cause he's my second suspect and the only one that is marginally likely to be lynched.

[captainwalrus]

I have been trying to reread, and I was going to do what I tried for Wecool again, but 32 pages is a lot, so I gave up.

Also, WTF? so many third party survivor claims. A few of them were fake too (isn't that what vodean claimed?) which makes me really wonder about the setup.

[cubfanpgh]

Also, WTF? so many third party survivor claims. A few of them were fake too (isn't that what vodean claimed?) which makes me really wonder about the setup.

Vodean turned out to be a 3rd party survivor with a nightkill.

[gregwolf121]

vote count
RE-koesen (2) ga7, safari
wolverine mutant (3) UTA, safari, koesen
with 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch

[gregwolf121]

night 5
well since there weren't enough votes to lynch anyone day 5 will end with no one dying
and just so you all are aware i may be replaceing wolverine mutant if he doesn't post by wednesday by 5

[safariguy5]

First, claim with no pressure. Why would you claim vanilla townie with no pressure?

As I recall, I had let my mouth run a bit, and wanted to clear suspicion. The PM to me indicated that it was in my interest to claim the role.

However, the role is not vanilla townie. Did I think it was? Yes, but I've never played mafia online before, and I was confused. I am a third party survivor.

Second, conflicting claim. First, he says third party, then says he's imperial citizen, then name drops owen lars. Also, a survivor claim.

Those are not conflicting. I am a third-party survivor. I am an imperial citizen. At least in my understanding, what would be considered vanilla townie is stormtrooper. As I said previously, I believe that spiesr had the same role. He was confirmed by the mod as an imperial citizen and a third party.

9. spiesr, imperial citizen, survivor, killed night 2

Now, with Owen Lars, I could see this as being a third-party survivor role. All the same, I suggest whatever investigative roles we have left to check him out tonight. Just to be sure.

I'm down with that. Do it. I don't know how many investigative roles are left, but investigate me. Killing would help no one (especially me).

Ah, ok, see here's the thing. I believe we have the roles mixed up. If you are imperial citizen, you are town. Third party means a cult or lone player (like vodean). So you are claiming a town survivor. Just got the alignment screwed up.

[Wolverine Mutant]

This is an interesting game to observe. So, am I supposed to post even though it's apparently nighttime now?

[Koesen]

No, night time would be the only time in which nobody wants you (or anybody else, it's not personal) to talk.

[gregwolf121]

since the majority of the night actions are in i will say that night will end sometime tomorrow

[duday53]

Some notes I took while reading Day One:

* Vodean votes somebody who suggests being part of the empire: major scum tell. Combined with the rest of his behaviour, he was by far the most suspicious person that day. Everyone who voted for him scores townie points, especially Ga7 for hammering. The fact that he turned out to be third party doesn't change that.

* LSU's fishing for a counter claim of Darth Bane looked slightly fishy at that stage, but apart from that he looks more town than scum.

* Safariguy looks generally protown.

* Duday didn't really contribute anything and merely seemed to fill space in order to look active. Slightly suspicious.


***

All of the above is based on Day One alone. If new evidence appeared later in the game to refute these impressions, I haven't read it yet.

Posting this just in case I die tonight in the hope that I can contribute at least a tiny little bit.

Duday has been having real life issues to attend to, so yes he's been mostly inactive.

Yes and I'm terribly sorry I wasn't as active as I should be. I will try to contribute more during this upcoming day.

[gregwolf121]

day 6

during the day confusion reigned people were claiming this and that no one knew what was right and what was a lie. when the night fell and people went to sleep to think on what was the truth, a couple of storm troopers came out hunting again the two times they tried to follow orders they had failed so they started out on an easy mission, a regular citizen who looked to be bad to them, so in the dead of night the two troopers entered his house and found the man they sought in bed, as the troopers burst through the door the man awoke and started to yell two blasts cut him off as he slumped back in bed to sleep forever
mean while in another part of the galaxy a black figure goes out on a mission of his own his target drinking in a casino. a few hours latter the drunken citizen stumbles towards his home and as he passes an alley is pushed in and some force holds him against the back wall. he watches as a black shadow from across the street separates from the night and a man in black approaches, as he comes to stand before the drunk, the drunk slurs who are you, in reply the dark figure raises his hand and a bar of red leaps forward cutting through the drunks heart. when the red bar retreats the now dead drunk falls to the ground and the dark figure fades back into the night.

cubfanpgh, imperial citizen has been killed
ga7, imperial citizen has been killed

it is now day 6 and with 10 alive it will take 6 to lynch

[cubfanpgh]

Oh, well. I had fun, and gained valuable experience.

[Koesen]

So, two misguided town kills, then? I can see why someone might go after cubfan, but Ga7?

[ga7]

I can't play survivor to save my life
If you don't mind, PM me the setup Greg, I'm curious

[safariguy5]

So, two misguided town kills, then? I can see why someone might go after cubfan, but Ga7?

2 Town kills? Sounds more like 1 town kill and perhaps one vig kill on the second one? The whole hooded person thing seems suspiciously like third party.