First Nations of South America!

[Industrial Helix]

Well, i would presume the Caribbean are part of the bonus they attach to... since there is that river there I think there's little room for doubt, even without colors.

As for central andies, what about making it even lighter?

Or swapping central and south Andies or swapping chilean and central andies.

[jefjef]

It's a little hard to tell what continent Carib is part of. Not sure what's the best way to fix that.

You could artificially enlarge those islands?

Drift Igneri island and the Caribs to the right a little and enlarge one of the Caribs. Give it a little separation from the other bonus and put it more in the sphere of the bonus it belongs to.

A color swap from N. Andes and Meso-America would work well too...

Does Campa and Inca connect? I guess not but perhaps that valley look could be made more of a mountain.

[jefjef]

That big empty space on the left. If you don't have plans for it I think an Nazca image (only visible from the sky) or a GOD image or a warrior related image would be worth looking at inserting there.

[ender516]

Whoa, that warrior is weird-looking, but seems familiar. Oh, I know, I bet he's "from France".

[RedBaron0]

Yeah... a guy Indiana Jones might be familiar with.

I dunno about the little islands, they could be a little bigger, but since they are just on territory I don't think it's a big big deal. Could you maybe add Puerto Rico to better show the color of the territory? You'd have to shift the burn mark over to the left, which will likely look better, since the top of the map from there to Central America is boringly straight. I like the spectrum effect you've got going with red to violet going from north to south so flipping colors will likely throw the balance off. I would lighten the Central Andes towards an indigo color.

[gimil]

Hi Tisha,

Love how your map is progressing. For the most part I would say the graphics are done except a few superficial things:

-Like others have said the dead space needs to be filled up. Someing subtle like a very transparent Image would go far to solve this problem. The pictures posted by jefjef would be an excellent place to start in my opinion.
-I think most of your rivers don't work very well when they just stop at the coast. I suggesting blending then into the ocean like you did with the river between Haurpe and Charrua.
-I also noticed that in Arara there seems to be black lines that just stop. Should those be there?

Excellent work Tisha, keep it up!

[Tisha]

how much does this suck?

721px × 800px

[Bruceswar]

FINAL FORGE THIS!!!

[RedBaron0]

Compass rose maybe for the space between the legend and central America?

Small map? And lets check the color blind filter again...



hmmmmmm, maybe a shade or 2 darker on the Eastern Forest.

[CoolC]

how much does this suck?

Not much, almost none at all in fact. I think it looks great

Only maybe, maybe smooth the ocean out into the paper background a bit more at the outer edges, but i dunno... i also like the watercolor look.

[Industrial Helix]

Looks great to me... though I think the tree should go.

How does the small map look?

[RedBaron0]

I dunno, I like the tree.

[natty dread]

I like the tree too but I still don't like the bridges.

[Evil DIMwit]

The tree looks kind of tropical-islandish, like it belongs more in the north of the map than the south.

[The Bison King]

The trees ok, I don't hate it, but I think some Aztec or Inca artwork would be better

[RedBaron0]

Inca ok, Aztec is Mexico... Previous suggestions advocated for Nazca lines, and wouldn't be a bad idea either.

[MrBenn]

What about some kind of Patagonian cave art?

[Incandenza]

Previous suggestions advocated for Nazca lines, and wouldn't be a bad idea either.

This seems at least worth trying, couldn't be worse than the palm tree (sorry, Tisha... rest of the map looks bitchin' tho).

[the.killing.44]

2 quick things, both about the passables (because you seem to have the artwork in the lower right under control):

1. The legend: "Passable," with one icon under it, just kinda floats out there awkwardly…is it really necessary?
2. The bridges themselves: they need some more separation from the land, like a dark glow or shadow. Nothing too extreme, but something to stop them from blending into the water/background.

[The Bison King]

Inca ok, Aztec is Mexico... Previous suggestions advocated for Nazca lines, and wouldn't be a bad idea either.

Ok you got me, but I think the eye roll was a little harsh

[RedBaron0]

Inca ok, Aztec is Mexico... Previous suggestions advocated for Nazca lines, and wouldn't be a bad idea either.

Ok you got me, but I think the eye roll was a little harsh

Well... Aztec is a territory on FNoNA after all.

2 quick things, both about the passables (because you seem to have the artwork in the lower right under control):

1. The legend: "Passable," with one icon under it, just kinda floats out there awkwardly…is it really necessary?
2. The bridges themselves: they need some more separation from the land, like a dark glow or shadow. Nothing too extreme, but something to stop them from blending into the water/background.

You could add the dotted connectors to the passable section.... but I agree it might not be really necessary to word it "Passables" Could just put "Bridges" as a label next to it in the legend. I agree with killing, and I wouldn't mind if you stretched out the ends a little bit. Having the ropes stretched a little in opposite directions would give the appearance of taut rope straining against gravity.

[jefjef]

In the legend the distance of the bridge below passable appears greater than the distance of mountains below impassable.

Would it look better with that bridge style if it was narrower? Darker?

[Bruceswar]

Can we move this along??

[Tisha]

Can we move this along??

no, we can't

because I don't like changing things I've worked on, and that I like... just because others don't like them

[thenobodies80]

Personally i think that the palm tree is wonderful.
In any case it's your map Tisha, so no one can force you to change something without a valid reason
I have only two suggestions/concerns:
1. Bridges, i know they are my obsession since you started this map, but i can't believe that someone with your graphic skill can't draw something better than that....(no offense but actually they look like wall bars)
2. In the legend, do you really need all that empty space between the passable and the impassable? I think you should try to move up all the legend.

Except for those two things the map is Forge-ready,imo.