Moderator: Cartographers


No doubt. Can you elaborate?cairnswk wrote:Mmmm. There is still room for vast improvement.

Greece (ie peninsular Greece, former Morea) became independent in 1829. Northern Greece and Macedonia remained under the Ottomans until 1914. Therefore, Natty's map is correct and there is no problem with Greece not being orange for reasons just stated.2. But what is happening with the bottom of Greece, the bit under Thessalonica, shouldn't that be orange also.
Thanks for the confirmation Rask.Raskholnikov wrote:Greece (ie peninsular Greece, former Morea) became independent in 1829. Northern Greece and Macedonia remained under the Ottomans until 1914. Therefore, Natty's map is correct and there is no problem with Greece not being orange for reasons just stated.2. But what is happening with the bottom of Greece, the bit under Thessalonica, shouldn't that be orange also.

Cairns (or anyone), can you elaborate on that? How is this vast improvement to be achieved?natty_dread wrote:No doubt. Can you elaborate?cairnswk wrote:Mmmm. There is still room for vast improvement.

Ah yes. That's one of the background images, I must have forgot it there. It's a drawing of a steam engine btw...The Bison King wrote:BUUUUUT, if you really need something to do I think I noticed some strange vertical lines in the Adriatic sea. I'm not sure if they are supposed to be there or not but they look a little funny to me.

I accept Rash's take on Greece.natty_dread wrote:Cairns (or anyone), can you elaborate on that? How is this vast improvement to be achieved?natty_dread wrote:No doubt. Can you elaborate?cairnswk wrote:Mmmm. There is still room for vast improvement.

I'll look into it, but...cairnswk wrote:I accept Rash's take on Greece.
The top right legend still doesn't sit correctly.
You've got plenty of room to move that whole legend around and centre the title and sub-wording better; also the whole legend could use the full outline of the border (same as the bottom legend)
...Are we even looking at the same map? The monopoly train is gone already!cairnswk wrote:I still don't like the monolpoly train...i'd remove it altogether. It looks like this is meant to be a monopoly board and not the Orient Express.
Well, I do have one idea for that... stay tuned...cairnswk wrote:I think you can take the graphics to a whole new level by using elements of that page 1 poster that will give the map the feeling of the orient express.
What kind of borders should there be?cairnswk wrote:The borders around the legend don't entirely express the period eloquently.

Nup, it's still there on V18.png previous pagenatty_dread wrote:I'll look into it, but...cairnswk wrote:I accept Rash's take on Greece.
The top right legend still doesn't sit correctly.
You've got plenty of room to move that whole legend around and centre the title and sub-wording better; also the whole legend could use the full outline of the border (same as the bottom legend)
...Are we even looking at the same map? The monopoly train is gone already!cairnswk wrote:I still don't like the monolpoly train...i'd remove it altogether. It looks like this is meant to be a monopoly board and not the Orient Express.
GoodWell, I do have one idea for that... stay tuned...cairnswk wrote:I think you can take the graphics to a whole new level by using elements of that page 1 poster that will give the map the feeling of the orient express.
Perhaps something in this vain..What kind of borders should there be?cairnswk wrote:The borders around the legend don't entirely express the period eloquently.

That's a different train. I thought your complaint was with the train that looked like a monopoly train. This one is similar to the locomotive used on the orient express at the time (I couldn't find a good picture of the exact model but this is very similar.)cairnswk wrote:Nup, it's still there on V18.png previous page
Thanks, I'll see what I can do.Perhaps something in this vain..
http://www.fivestarhotelsandspas.com/im ... press1.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_ef_M4U2nwus/S ... XPRESS.jpg
Perhaps Use something from the building architecture style:
http://www.fotografgalerisi.net/GaleriS ... ciGari.jpg
Be creativebut not over the top.

I know what you're trying to express there with it, but it simply looks out of place with the whole theme.natty_dread wrote:That's a different train. I thought your complaint was with the train that looked like a monopoly train. This one is similar to the locomotive used on the orient express at the time (I couldn't find a good picture of the exact model but this is very similar.)cairnswk wrote:Nup, it's still there on V18.png previous page
Or are you saying you don't want any train in the legend?




Unfortunately, this will have to wait until I can get my fonts moved from the old computer.ender516 wrote:Yes, "rail monopoly" is better.



Hm, I'm not sure if it would really suit the style of this map... I'm afraid it would make it look too cramped...What do you think of having a very thin border go all the way round the map? I think that might connect the legend with the map a bit better.
