Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

[Victor Sullivan]

My character's name is just "Uncle", I guess. I didn't really get a name... Never played Red Dead before, so I'm not familiar with the characters.

Basically, I think my guy is clumsy or incapable or something, because he basically said that "if someone's in need of your small knowledge of medicine, you can help them, but if they were okay in the first place, you'll probably screw up and kill them". Obviously those aren't the exact words from the PM (as that would be cheating), but I think my paraphrase covered it.

-Uncle Sully

Your a hopeless drunk, I have no idea why you would have medical talents. That being said, you are one of the good guys if you are telling the truth. This is of course assuming that we are sticking to the games normal story, not the zombie expansion. I could see why you would have some medical powers then, zombies are hard to kill.

Yeah, like I said I have no idea what this game is about. Is it zombies? I thought the title implied like an old Western or something.

[edocsil]

My character's name is just "Uncle", I guess. I didn't really get a name... Never played Red Dead before, so I'm not familiar with the characters.

Basically, I think my guy is clumsy or incapable or something, because he basically said that "if someone's in need of your small knowledge of medicine, you can help them, but if they were okay in the first place, you'll probably screw up and kill them". Obviously those aren't the exact words from the PM (as that would be cheating), but I think my paraphrase covered it.

-Uncle Sully

Your a hopeless drunk, I have no idea why you would have medical talents. That being said, you are one of the good guys if you are telling the truth. This is of course assuming that we are sticking to the games normal story, not the zombie expansion. I could see why you would have some medical powers then, zombies are hard to kill.

Yeah, like I said I have no idea what this game is about. Is it zombies? I thought the title implied like an old Western or something.

There is some DLC that does some weird stuff. Majority of the game is an old western.

[naxus]

Just a quick announcement. As I stated on the sign up early to midgame, no DLC stuff.

Also you may vote no lynch three times to end the day

[Haggis_McMutton]

I dunno, it doesn't seem really believable to me that the character would have absolutely no relation to the role.(at least that's what i got from the wiki thing, correct me if I'm wrong)

Why would the mod do that? It kind of defeats the purpose of having a theme doesn't it?

Also, as has been mentioned, CPR doc is an awfully convenient claim to make.

I'm kind of leaning towards a lynch. What do you guys think?

[Victor Sullivan]

How about this - I won't use my action tonight. That way, I can't make excuses, right? I'm just saying, it'd be much better to try and lynch scum than lynch potentially the only doc. What I can do is just not use my action until necessary, like maybe when a cop claims or something? Idk... Just seems like it'd be better to rat out some scum early on. I promise I'll be more serious like I'm being now...

-Uncle Sully

[edocsil]

How about this - I won't use my action tonight. That way, I can't make excuses, right? I'm just saying, it'd be much better to try and lynch scum than lynch potentially the only doc. What I can do is just not use my action until necessary, like maybe when a cop claims or something? Idk... Just seems like it'd be better to rat out some scum early on. I promise I'll be more serious like I'm being now...

-Uncle Sully

Until the scum out think you, kill some one else and you implant a scalpel into someones brain. A CPR doc really is a killing role. I just don't see any connection to your character with the claim. I wonder if it could be a fake.

[Victor Sullivan]

How about this - I won't use my action tonight. That way, I can't make excuses, right? I'm just saying, it'd be much better to try and lynch scum than lynch potentially the only doc. What I can do is just not use my action until necessary, like maybe when a cop claims or something? Idk... Just seems like it'd be better to rat out some scum early on. I promise I'll be more serious like I'm being now...

-Uncle Sully

Until the scum out think you, kill some one else and you implant a scalpel into someones brain. A CPR doc really is a killing role. I just don't see any connection to your character with the claim. I wonder if it could be a fake.

Maybe he ran out of roles or characters or something? I have no idea. I think we should really try to out the real scum...

-Sully

[Haggis_McMutton]

Maybe he ran out of roles or characters or something? I have no idea. I think we should really try to out the real scum...

-Sully

Yeah, I'm not buying that.

You act very erratically(kinda like how you kept saying you were the Sultan when you actually WERE the Sultan in that other game), then you come with a conveniently unverifiable claim and then your supposed character hasn't got the slightest thing to do with the role you claim.

I don't think we're going to get anything more definite than this D1.

I'd be happy to lynch now, but since only edoc posted since he revealed his character I'm going to wait a little bit more.
Any thoughts?

[edocsil]

I'd be happy to lynch now, but since only edoc posted since he revealed his character I'm going to wait a little bit more.
Any thoughts?

This, we need input from the others.

[aage]

I'm unsure. I agree that a cpr doc can be a pain, but on the other hand it might be the only NK in the hands of town. And then there's still the possibility of a fake claim. I never played the game so I have no idea what which characters do and don't, so I'll trust the others on this, but I'm torn in doubt.

I think I'll unvote[/b to see some more discussion.

[aage]

I'm unsure. I agree that a cpr doc can be a pain, but on the other hand it might be the only NK in the hands of town. And then there's still the possibility of a fake claim. I never played the game so I have no idea what which characters do and don't, so I'll trust the others on this, but I'm torn in doubt.

I think I'll unvote to see some more discussion.

ebwop bbcode hate <_<

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Yes I read too the wiki and Uncle's page had nothing about doc skills (except for tending animals). However he could possibly be the only in practice vig role. So I guess I'll unvote for now.

I've got to go to work now, but I'll try and dig some scum up/input more on this game later on tonight.

-Tails

[aage]

Still waiting for "others"...
seriously, people, find that "post reply" button and abuse that keyboard.

btw, tailgunner, there's a mistake in your sig. If one joins the mafia it'd not be wise to "lynch some scum".

[Haggis_McMutton]

You guys are actually buying that claim? Dunno, it seems fake to me.

But yeah, input from violet, Stefunny and Commander(who should be back tomorow i think) would be good.

In the meantime, since he's now at L-3: vote Sully. Reasons are in my last post. Also:

Vote Commander9 to put the attention on someone else. Is that scummy?

Wtf mate? If you are bored, perhaps this isn't the best place to vent. Could get ya killed.

Lol, edocsil, it's not like much of anything is happening. And look, Commander9's gonna be gone, so we don't have to worry about a claim or a defense or anything! I say we lynch him while we can. Is that scummy?

I dunno, but this seems exactly like what he was doing in the Crusades game with the "playingly act scummy so that people don't realize you actually are scum" gag.

[aage]

I dunno, but this seems exactly like what he was doing in the Crusades game with the "playingly act scummy so that people don't realize you actually are scum" gag.

idk in how many games you are, but he does this everywhere. As I have said in either this thread or one of the threads just mentioned, I don't think he's mafia in all of them so I won't use it a reason for my vote...

Then again this will give Vic pretty much a free ticked to Endgame, so I will be interested in seeing some input if not later on this day then at least during d2...

[edocsil]

I dunno, but this seems exactly like what he was doing in the Crusades game with the "playingly act scummy so that people don't realize you actually are scum" gag.

idk in how many games you are, but he does this everywhere. As I have said in either this thread or one of the threads just mentioned, I don't think he's mafia in all of them so I won't use it a reason for my vote...

Then again this will give Vic pretty much a free ticked to Endgame, so I will be interested in seeing some input if not later on this day then at least during d2...

And this is why I think we should lynch him. The claim is a bit odd and if we let him off it is as you said, a free ticket to the endgame.

[edocsil]

I dunno, but this seems exactly like what he was doing in the Crusades game with the "playingly act scummy so that people don't realize you actually are scum" gag.

idk in how many games you are, but he does this everywhere. As I have said in either this thread or one of the threads just mentioned, I don't think he's mafia in all of them so I won't use it a reason for my vote...

Then again this will give Vic pretty much a free ticked to Endgame, so I will be interested in seeing some input if not later on this day then at least during d2...

And this is why I think we should lynch him. The claim is a bit odd and if we let him off it is as you said, a free ticket to the endgame.

Ya know what, my own argument isn't holding water with me now. I was thinking about my own role and my character's abilities and comparing them to the character in the game. They don't really match much so I say we let him off the hook.

Unvote

[Commander9]

Aha, I see I've not missed much

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Still waiting for "others"...
seriously, people, find that "post reply" button and abuse that keyboard.

btw, tailgunner, there's a mistake in your sig. If one joins the mafia it'd not be wise to "lynch some scum".

Yeah I would like to hear more from other people. Idk this game is crawling, but I don't want it to because I like the setup.

Thanks aaage. I fixed the sig. Does it pass muster now?

-Tails

[aage]

Hi.

Like, hey. We might want a deadline or else this is gonna die.

[Commander9]

Hi.

Like, hey. We might want a deadline or else this is gonna die.

+1

[Victor Sullivan]

Hi.

Like, hey. We might want a deadline or else this is gonna die.

+1

-1

[Commander9]

-1

Victor, there's no activity here - the game is dying. Deadline, hopefully, would bring in some life... Unless you don't want that, Sult... I mean Sully

[Victor Sullivan]

-1

Victor, there's no activity here - the game is dying. Deadline, hopefully, would bring in some life... Unless you don't want that, Sult... I mean Sully

+2

[naxus]

Vote Cout(Mayor)
Com9(4)-com9, haggis, edoc, tails

Vote Count(Lynch 1)
Com9(1)-Victor
Victor(3)-Haggis, Aage, stefunny

Deadline Set for Saturday at Midnight Standard Mountain time. When the Deadline Hits top three people(who have at least one vote) will be killed. If noone has any votes then three no lynches. I suggest you either end the day or quick lynch to avoid a mishap....

Also mass prod coming to everyone