Ok, for any mafia who normally skim the thread or confused townies that missed it, I vetoed the lynching. I would have saved our Vigilante, but when I asked him to roleclaim and give us his thoughts on who was Mafia:
Nyvek wrote:@ CBlake
CBlake, you've already been lynched. Your role will be revealed soon. Would you mind giving your thoughts on who is mafia and tell us your role so we can continue the discussion with more info?
He was kind enough to respond with:
CBlake wrote:nope
Then he screwed around a bit more, so I couldn’t confirm his identity without saying my role. If I did that, we couldn’t trust his claim.
Colaalone wrote::roll:
I see the veto comment now, I didn't have a clue what he meant.
What convinced him to veto?
I wasn’t convinced Max was town. He made some very questionable comments. But, he had no way of knowing my role. It is possible, based on the rescue mission thread, to assume omega sector had a lynch-blocker as well. By Max’s wild role claim, its possible Max made up something rare enough to avoid a counterclaim by a legitimate townie power role. But, for now, I’m counting Max as town. Autoload has been known to enlist interesting roles that no one expects.
That being said, here are the vote counts for the past 2 days.
autoload wrote:9 CBlake (HoussamTheGreat, Machiavelli, Senfive, mandalorian2298, everywhere116, AK_iceman, got tonkaed, unriggable, Puff)
3 max is gr8 (red bull, Nyvek, cmckinney)
1 AK_iceman (max is gr8, )
3 Not Voting (CBlake, Huguenots, Sam Jam)
autoload wrote:8 max is gr8 (unriggable, everywhere116, Colaalone, Nyvek, Puff, got tonkaed, Machiavelli, mandalorian2298)
6 Not Voting (max is gr8, s.xkitten, Sam Jam, red bull, cmckinney, Senfive)
Now, I don’t believe this a who’s who of Mafia, but there are definitely mafia on CBlakes wagon.
Max’s wagon I’m not so sure. This is partly because I posted we should start with the voting lists, and because there are some apparent changes in voting preferences.
For instance, Red Bull and cMckinney both voted Max on Day 1, but were absent for his lynching on day 2. I don’t think Max provided a sound defense until his roleclaim, so why change votes?
Aside from that, we need to find out if Max’s claimed role is worth anything to us. (If he is a cop, watcher, or whatever) If Unriggable comes up Mafia, then we know Max’s role is Sane Cop/variant. Should that happen, then I will bid you all good luck and farewell, because he will need the Doc’s protection more than me.
Although I full intend to vote Unriggable, I’m not voting because we need to hear from townies that are not posting. We can’t base our lynches on power roles alone.