CLUE Mafia- Mafia Win!!!! MVP- Rodion

[ben.cleuch]

Insert Generic Name Here

That is what when mean when we say color.

Ok I get it now, I am a stranded motorist, it was written in blue.

[F1fth]

I have some very interesting things I'd like to share but it should wait until after the claims are done. We have unclaimed the following: falko/safari, target, and shield in that order. Should we skip falko/safari for now due to the replacement while saf gets caught up and move on to targetman? It seems we're at kind of a lull in the day and that might help to move things along.

[dazerazer]

I say we give safari a chance to catch up and get the claims from the other few players left to claim. Then we can circle back and get safari's

[targetman377]

i am the cook

[Rodion]

i am the cook

Isn't that Mrs. Ho?

Boy, we're getting some weaksauce claims here!

Only you left, Safari!

[shieldgenerator7]

i am the cook

Isn't that Mrs. Ho?

Boy, we're getting some weaksauce claims here!

Only you left, Safari!

and me and target. but we can have saf claiim if he's ready.

[Rodion]

i am the cook

Isn't that Mrs. Ho?

Boy, we're getting some weaksauce claims here!

Only you left, Safari!

and me and target. but we can have saf claiim if he's ready.

You're Professor Plum.

And target just said he's "the cook" (it's inside the quote pyramid).

[dazerazer]

So who is Ms Peach?

[Rodion]

So who is Ms Peach?

As soon as Safari claims we'll have to declare our cellar cards and see which characters exist and which ones were made up. We don't have enough cards, so we'll have to rely on other things, such as investigations results for names.

[safariguy5]

Confirm. I'm Captain Brown. I don't think I have any cellar cards or investigations.

[Rodion]

Confirm. I'm Captain Brown. I don't think I have any cellar cards or investigations.

So, Falko knew Captain Brown was in the game not due to the ability of seeing /'s card, but rather because he was Captain Brown himself.

Now, Safari, please disclose what you know about "Slash" - it must be somewhere in your role PM.

I guess we can now proceed to declaring our cards so we clear people and conclude the likeliest fakeclaims.

Here's mine: Ms. Ho (Yoshi) is innocent.

[freezie]

In case people forggotten, I got this here one card ( which of course nobody claimed )

Monsieur Brunnette is guilty.

[safariguy5]

My role PM says that / is probably a crooked cop, but not much else.

Also, my card is that Professor Plum (Shield7 apparently) is innocent.

[DoomYoshi]

Player List

16 of 20 remain

1. Rodion - Colonel Mustard
2. DoomYoshi - Mrs. Ho town according to Rodion
3. / - Sergeant Gray
4. Anarkistsdream - Mr. Gold
5. mass miracle - Debra Hill
6. Edocsil - Wadsworth
7. Victor Sullivan - The Chief town according to lalaland
8. got tonkaed - Singing Telegram Girl
9. pyrhhus - Mr. Green
10. gimli1990 - Mrs. White
11. F1fth - Mrs. Peacock
12. lalaland - Ms. Scarlet reported by Victor Sullivan
13. shm78 - Motorist?
14. freezie - Mrs. Silver
15. safariguy - Captain Brown
16. ben.cleuch - Motorist?
17. targetman377 - the cook?
18. commander9 - David Bill
19. shieldgenerator7 - Professor Plum town according to saf
20. Dazerazer - Lady Lavender

Leftover: Ms. Peach
Monsieur Brunnete

[DoomYoshi]

So who is Ms Peach?

Nobody is Ms. Peach. Which is why we said to not reveal the cards until afterwards. I specifically didn't draw any cellar cards, since I figured the mafia would try to off me since I was the ringleader of the mass claim. However, they saw through me I guess. Anyways, once all cellar card results are revealed, we will go ahead and test out some of the possible liars. Depending on how many scum there, we have this game in 2-4 days. Good work town:)

[gimli1990]

now that we have all claimed we have to figure out how many mafia there are. i doubt it will just one.

[/]

Oh, makes sense, My card is that Captain Brown is innocent.

My role PM says that / is probably a crooked cop, but not much else.

and this is also indeed true, but that's no secret by now. For example since mass miracle hasn't bribed me at this point I will say that flavor wise my PM states that he doesn't belong here and that I recognize everyone else from somewhere or another, which makes for kind of an odd plot-hole considering supposedly two people's entire existence is defined as nothing more than owning a broken down car.

[shieldgenerator7]

Wait... how did you know I was Professor Plum? Did I claim already?

[F1fth]

Ok, here's the big summary/revelation/accusation post I promised. I can confirm two things via cellar cards:

1. The Stranded Motorist is innocent. That's right, the phrasing was the "Stranded Motorist," not simply "The Motorist." Now look at the two claims. This leads me to believe that shm78 is the liar, along with the fact that ben has been much more forthcoming about information. I'm almost certain about this.

2. A Yvette exists in this game as well. Clearly, she is guilty or she would have claimed her name by now but I can confirm her existence and guilt.

There remain three scum characters: Mrs. Peach, Yvette, and Monsieur Brunnette.

Mrs. Ho is the cook so we know targetman is lying. So we have two scums, target and shm78, and one to find. If you remember, got tonkaed has accused Victor of being a cult recruiter. He's either lying (which makes him our last scum), or telling the truth, in which case we have a big fish to fry.

Thus, what I suggest we do is lynch Victor. If cult recruiter, yay he's dead! If not, kill GT. We'll lynch the other ones afterward regardless, but we must take care of the cult ASAP if it exists.

[freezie]

Ok, here's the big summary/revelation/accusation post I promised. I can confirm two things via cellar cards:

1. The Stranded Motorist is innocent. That's right, the phrasing was the "Stranded Motorist," not simply "The Motorist." Now look at the two claims. This leads me to believe that shm78 is the liar, along with the fact that ben has been much more forthcoming about information. I'm almost certain about this.

2. A Yvette exists in this game as well. Clearly, she is guilty or she would have claimed her name by now but I can confirm her existence and guilt.

There remain three scum characters: Mrs. Peach, Yvette, and Monsieur Brunnette.

Mrs. Ho is the cook so we know targetman is lying. So we have two scums, target and shm78, and one to find. If you remember, got tonkaed has accused Victor of being a cult recruiter. He's either lying (which makes him our last scum), or telling the truth, in which case we have a big fish to fry.

Thus, what I suggest we do is lynch Victor. If cult recruiter, yay he's dead! If not, kill GT. We'll lynch the other ones afterward regardless, but we must take care of the cult ASAP if it exists.

I must say this post is full of QFT. Lynching victor seems our best choice, yet.

But for now let's look at those other cellar cards

[F1fth]

EBWOP

Colonel Mustard did it in the conservatory with the rope.

(Can't be an accusation post without that).

But yes, agreed, freezie. Let's milk this day for all the info we can get because thing are probably going to get a little hectic if cult turns up.

[safariguy5]

Oh man! I was typing something and then I pressed some random key and it exited me out of it! frustrating...
I'll try to remember all of what it was I posted.

I am professor plum. I doubt falko or target are scum but I have no evidence so I'm just hoping they're not (or else I would have helped them fakeclaim)

ben and shm... work it out who's who as we can't have two motorists (or can we?).

This is where you claimed.

I think lynching Victor sounds like a good idea, we have some mafia square in our sights.

vote Victor

[freezie]

Colonel Mustard did it in the conservatory with the rope.

I know you meant this as a joke, but looking back at the day flavour scene, it may very well be factual well except the conservatory part

On the floor was the body of Mr. Gold with rope around his neck. Leaning over the body was Colonel Mustard.

[shieldgenerator7]

oh, thanks, saf. I had completely forgotten that I had claimed. I must be tired.

Anyway, what about Colonel Mustard / Rodion? I found Colonel Mustard's fingerprints on the revolver and I found him doing something fishy in the lounge. I think that's rather suspicious. Does anyone have Rodion's cellar card so we can prove this one way or the other?

And about Victor, maybe I'll reread later but right now I completely forget what ccusations were made on him. And it seems he is the confirmed Chef, and didn't he admit to being a recruiter or something? Then he probably isn't a threat to the town. Unless I'm forgetting something. Will post more on this later.

[ben.cleuch]

Ok, here's the big summary/revelation/accusation post I promised. I can confirm two things via cellar cards:

1. The Stranded Motorist is innocent. That's right, the phrasing was the "Stranded Motorist," not simply "The Motorist." Now look at the two claims. This leads me to believe that shm78 is the liar, along with the fact that ben has been much more forthcoming about information. I'm almost certain about this.


Thus, what I suggest we do is lynch Victor. If cult recruiter, yay he's dead! If not, kill GT. We'll lynch the other ones afterward regardless, but we must take care of the cult ASAP if it exists.

Thanks you got that right. Not sure what a cult is but as you nailed the motorist thing I will go along
vote victor