Interesting Mafia! GAME OVER ~ MAFIA WINS ~

strike wolf · Post by **strike wolf** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 12:14 pm

Anyone have anything to say.

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 12:28 pm

dazza2008 · Post by **dazza2008** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 12:36 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:Daz is scum......

Why? Because I was protected or you were roleblocked?

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 12:39 pm

zimmah · Post by **zimmah** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 1:21 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:Pretty much.
I'm confused and this game isn't moving.

isn't moving? did you skim that much?

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 1:28 pm

zimmah · Post by **zimmah** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 1:32 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:
zimmah wrote:
BGtheBrain wrote:Pretty much.
I'm confused and this game isn't moving.
isn't moving? did you skim that much?
talking in fucking circles and having 4 people with votes placed does not classify as moving.
Of course you say its skimming, when in reality im just stating the obvious.

Your case is just as stupid as mine. We have a bunch of puzzle pieces, with no clue what goes where.
it doesnt matter because even if i said I was a cop and had a guilty result, not enough people would even read the thread and vote.

So no, the game is not moving, why are you always so difficult?

i'm not difficult, but the case on andy and the case on spiesr are quite good cases, so pick one, and don't say the game isn't moving because you don't like either case and just want to start you own case and noone votes for a day 3 joke case.

spiesr · Post by **spiesr** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 1:34 pm

Well guys, I don't really know what to say in my defense here. As Victor pointed out, Andy's case basically rests on me being me, and/or secret evidence that I don't what enough about to even attempt to refute...

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 1:37 pm

zimmah · Post by **zimmah** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:16 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:Did you read the fucking reasoning as to why its not moving?

Want to start my own case?
yes, I expect everyone to pile on my brilliant case.

Whats your case again?
You tried to recruit someone and you couldnt. That means theyre power role,or mafia.
Oh and you want all the vanillas to claim.... yeah great fucking case man.....

Why are you so sensitive about the game being called "not moving?" Its bizarre.

unvote vote spiesr

it's you who's sensitve here, you're getting all angry that you can't figure out what's going on and therefore thnk the game is not moving. it's not moving the way you want it to move is a more accurate description.

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:18 pm

BGtheBrain · Post by **BGtheBrain** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:28 pm

AndyDufresne · Post by **AndyDufresne** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:39 pm

We do indeed need to get some more input from those on the more quiet end: Gilligan, Iron Butterfly, Victor Sullivan, Soundman (I had forgot soundman was even in our game actually).

--Andy

zimmah · Post by **zimmah** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:42 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:Post count during D3 (estimate) (Underline means actually voted)
Zimmah - 22
BGtheBrain - 15
Daz - 12
Strike - 10
Andy - 8
Spiesr - 4
Vic - 2
Soundman - 1
Iron Butterfly - 1
Gilligan - 0

i agree we should try to make those people participate more into the forum, lurking and/or inactive people are never good, but i don't see how this is different from any other mafia tread, unfortunately it's quite common that half of the people are inactive.

MoB Deadly · Post by **MoB Deadly** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 2:52 pm

Day 3 - Vote Count 5

(1) AndyDufresne - zimmah
BGtheBrain -
(1) dazza2008 - BGtheBrain
Gilligan -
Iron Butterfly -
strike wolf -
soundman -
(3, L-3) spiesr - AndyDufresne, Strike Wolf, BGtheBrain
Victor Sullivan -
zimmah -

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 votes to Lynch or No Lynch.

I prodded the following players:
Gilligan
Iron Butterfly
Soundman
Victor Sullivan

[/quote]

soundman · Post by **soundman** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:15 pm

I've been here and have been reading. I just don't have much to add at this point as I'm trying to decide if spiesr is really town or not. I find it hard to believe he could have fakeclaimed such a role and therefore am leaning towards him being town. I really wish I knew what his role did...

I find it interesting that BG claims vig and shoots dazza N2 but dazza is still here. Not sure what to make of that...

AndyDufresne · Post by **AndyDufresne** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:19 pm

soundman wrote:I've been here and have been reading. I just don't have much to add at this point as I'm trying to decide if spiesr is really town or not. I find it hard to believe he could have fakeclaimed such a role and therefore am leaning towards him being town. I really wish I knew what his role did...

I find it interesting that BG claims vig and shoots dazza N2 but dazza is still here. Not sure what to make of that...

Could you elaborate on why you find it hard to believe he could have fake-claimed such a role? I'd like to hear more from you.

--Andy

dazza2008 · Post by **dazza2008** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:24 pm

soundman wrote: I find it interesting that BG claims vig and shoots dazza N2 but dazza is still here. Not sure what to make of that...

I have said already I must have been protected or BG rolevlocked. Is that really so crazy and hard to believe?

soundman · Post by **soundman** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:51 pm

AndyDufresne wrote:
soundman wrote:I've been here and have been reading. I just don't have much to add at this point as I'm trying to decide if spiesr is really town or not. I find it hard to believe he could have fakeclaimed such a role and therefore am leaning towards him being town. I really wish I knew what his role did...

I find it interesting that BG claims vig and shoots dazza N2 but dazza is still here. Not sure what to make of that...
Could you elaborate on why you find it hard to believe he could have fake-claimed such a role? I'd like to hear more from you.

--Andy

I don't think someone could have just come up with that role. Mostly just a gut feeling really. I'm actually putting together a case on someone else and should have it up soon.

AndyDufresne · Post by **AndyDufresne** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 4:25 pm

soundman wrote:
AndyDufresne wrote:
soundman wrote:I've been here and have been reading. I just don't have much to add at this point as I'm trying to decide if spiesr is really town or not. I find it hard to believe he could have fakeclaimed such a role and therefore am leaning towards him being town. I really wish I knew what his role did...

I find it interesting that BG claims vig and shoots dazza N2 but dazza is still here. Not sure what to make of that...
Could you elaborate on why you find it hard to believe he could have fake-claimed such a role? I'd like to hear more from you.

--Andy
I don't think someone could have just come up with that role. Mostly just a gut feeling really. I'm actually putting together a case on someone else and should have it up soon.

I think it is possible that since MOB Deadly has mentioned at various times in this topic...that the game is 'Interesting' and unique, it isn't too far fetched to come up with a wild role out of the blue.

--Andy

soundman · Post by **soundman** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 4:33 pm

Well I started putting together my case against Dazza but kept finding holes in my logic. The only suspicious thing I could find is him living through BG's shot. And like he said that could easily be explained by a roleblock. (I don't think protection would have saved him as both the doctor and naive doc are dead). So I'm not going to continue that case for the time being.

After looking through the thread for stuff against Dazza I did come to the conclusion that I am going to follow Andy on this one and go after Spiesr.

AndyDufresne wrote:
zimmah wrote:
strike wolf wrote:
zimmah wrote:andy i'm going to throw a FOS at you. not only are you continuously avoiding my question, also you're trying to paint a claimed and confirmed townie as scum.

i'm pretty sure you're scum. if you were a VT you'd not make such a fuzz about claiming it. i have allready explained i have some info on you, and still you refuse to answer one simple question, yet you frame a townie. are you really thinking you'll get away with this?
Umm what claimed or confirmed townie? Dazza's not confirmed. Spiesr certainly isn't confirmed.
he's more confirmed then you think.
Then we've got a predicament if you think he's something (and say you have evidence) and I think he's something else (and say I have evidence to the contrary). I agree, Victor, that my case about his posting isn't that great, but it is the only evidence to which you all have access. Right now, I only feel confident trusting Strike Wolf.

We're getting close to a make or break vote I think, in terms of town numbers vs scum. I'll do my best to keep the town going.

Vote: Spiesr

He's practically saying that he has evidence outside of this thread that shows Spiesr as mafia. If he does have something then it seems logical to follow that evidence, whatever it might be.

Also he says "Right now, I only feel confident trusting Strike Wolf." (Above quoted post)

AndyDufresne wrote:Strike Wolf is also pretty right about dropping hints. It sometimes works, it sometimes doesn't. I don't think I've ever been a good hint dropper in the games I've played over the years.

--Andy

strike wolf wrote:I've looked back and I think I know what Andy is doing right now.
vote spiesr

They have somehow figured out who each other are (or at least that each is town). It could just be that they are both mafia but I'm going to take a chance and side with them on this. If Spiesr turns up town then we have a good lead for Day 4.

Vote Spiesr

Victor Sullivan · Post by **Victor Sullivan** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 4:52 pm

Prod received. I've been following, but haven't had much time to make a good post. At any rate, Andy's behavior is highly suspicious IMO. For a monkey, he seems awfully antsy. I'm just not quite seeing the similarities in Andy's posting in this game and Andy's posting in Futurama, which concerns me. At any rate, I largely agree with soundman's logic in this case. I think spiesr's alignment will shed some light on what's happened today.

vote spiesr

-Sully

dazza2008 · Post by **dazza2008** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:00 pm

I don't know if this is the right or wrong move but spiesr has already made his claim and I am not sure what else he could tell us so I will hammer him.

I think it needs to be done. If he is innocent then we have a lot more to go for tomorrow.

vote spiesr.

MoB Deadly · Post by **MoB Deadly** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:50 pm

SILENCE THAT IS A LYNCH! SCENE AND NIGHT START SOON:

Day 3 - Final Vote Count

(1) AndyDufresne - zimmah
BGtheBrain -
dazza2008 -
Gilligan -
Iron Butterfly -
strike wolf -
soundman -
(6, LYNCH!) spiesr - AndyDufresne, Strike Wolf, BGtheBrain, soundman, Victor Sullivan, dazza2008
Victor Sullivan -
zimmah -

MoB Deadly · Post by **MoB Deadly** » Thu Jan 12, 2012 6:09 pm

The colorful townies got together again to find the one responsible for the killings. They pointed fingers back and forth a bit, but in the end, spiesr got 7 fingers pointed at him. Before he could react they had surrounded him. He tried to resist but he was no match for all of them. Like wild animals they started ripping him apart. Colorful blood sprayed everywhere, and the others wondered if he was telling the truth, if he really was a rainbow. They ripped through his ribcage and one of them ripped out his heart, sure enough, it was black.

SPIESR - MAFIA GOON - HAS BEEN LYNCHED!

The Town went to bed with ease. They killed the killer! Now, they can rebuild their future tomorrow.

IT IS NOW NIGHT 3! PLEASE SEND IN NIGHT ACTIONS! DEADLINE: SUNDAY 7PM

Interesting Mafia! GAME OVER ~ MAFIA WINS ~

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [13/13] - DAY 1 - A Colorful Murder

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark

Re: Interesting Mafia! [10/13] - Day 3 - Shots in the Dark