Soundman's First Mafia [End] Arsonist Wins!!

[codierose]

sorry playing from my phone i put a weak case for you and asked for back up didn't get it.
we are on day 4 with still no leads theres a case put forward from the hipp that looks im happy to go along with that
what do you think about hipps case

[codierose]

On an unrelated topic, who's today's 4-post/no vote fellow?

Crazymilkshake5
also going back to the squirrel he did say

it was an accident from someone on my side. So whatever townie has the silencing power, you need to be careful with that.

was he hit on the head buy a mafia member by mistake
is there a townie with this power ??

[edocsil]

Doc got in a good block there. I wish there was a way to find the protected townie without exposing the doc

[codierose]

doc already lynched

[edocsil]

doc already lynched

Why sirens then? That implies doc protection pretty strongly. Could be a good RB, but that wouldn't make sense flavor wise. Perhaps a backup?

[crazymilkshake5]

i dont think i have the "only 4 post' thing on me anymore...

[codierose]

Mr. Squirrel wrote:Hey guys. Don't expect much out of me today. Someone hit me over the head last night and now I don't have a vote. I've no idea who it was, but the flavor made it sound like it was an accident from someone on my side.So whatever townie has the silencing power, you need to be careful with that. Every time you silence a townie, the mafia is a little more powerful that day. Could be a game-changer later on.

i need some help with this
ive been looking into the silencing role there could be a dentist how common is that roll but probably more likely a silencer was he warning his fellow scum

[TheGeneral2112]

A shot rang out. Sirens wailed in the distance. On the surface it seemed an almost uneventful night. But the pieces were still moving.

Day Four Start!

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

So we need a protective role to claim with who you protected, a bp townie to claim, a vested townie to claim, or a roleblocker to claim with whom you roleblocked. This could give us some clears.

[edocsil]

A shot rang out. Sirens wailed in the distance. On the surface it seemed an almost uneventful night. But the pieces were still moving.

Day Four Start!

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

So we need a protective role to claim with who you protected, a bp townie to claim, a vested townie to claim, or a roleblocker to claim with whom you roleblocked. This could give us some clears.

I am uncertain if the claims will help at this point. There are still to many players after a mass claim like that you want to be able to clean things up fast.

[codierose]

i dont think i have the "only 4 post' thing on me anymore...

so your going to add something today maybe vote

[thehippo8]

Having woken from my slumber and recalling my vivid dream ... I want to be sure that I did actually vote, or was that all in my head? So ...unvote vote Mr Squirrel ... for the reasons set out when I talked in my sleep!

[soundman]

Mr. Squirrel has to drop out due to RL issues so he is being replaced by skillfusniper33.

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Skillfusniper33 - Codierose, hippo - (L4)
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
Edocsil -
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

[zimmah]

Mr. Squirrel has to drop out due to RL issues so he is being replaced by skillfusniper33.

vote skillfullsniper33

i trust the opinion of hippo.

[skillfusniper33]

alright folks I am here and caught up on all the chit chat that has been happening

I will post something more beneficial when I hear back from soundman. Double checking on a few things with my role

[skillfusniper33]

Mr. Squirrel wrote:Hey guys. Don't expect much out of me today. Someone hit me over the head last night and now I don't have a vote. I've no idea who it was, but the flavor made it sound like it was an accident from someone on my side.So whatever townie has the silencing power, you need to be careful with that. Every time you silence a townie, the mafia is a little more powerful that day. Could be a game-changer later on.

i need some help with this
ive been looking into the silencing role there could be a dentist how common is that roll but probably more likely a silencer was he warning his fellow scum

Just a quick question, why would mafia silence a fellow scum, it would just weaken their entire side. And with them loosing 1 member already. I also don't have a clue as of where squirrel (who I am replacing) saw the flavor in the scene say which side it came from.

And if I were scum, why would he point it out when they already knew I was with them?

[chapcrap]

I trust zimmah and hippo. unvote vote skill

[codierose]

Mr. Squirrel wrote:Hey guys. Don't expect much out of me today. Someone hit me over the head last night and now I don't have a vote. I've no idea who it was, but the flavor made it sound like it was an accident from someone on my side.So whatever townie has the silencing power, you need to be careful with that. Every time you silence a townie, the mafia is a little more powerful that day. Could be a game-changer later on.

i need some help with this
ive been looking into the silencing role there could be a dentist how common is that roll but probably more likely a silencer was he warning his fellow scum

Just a quick question, why would mafia silence a fellow scum, it would just weaken their entire side. And with them loosing 1 member already. I also don't have a clue as of where squirrel (who I am replacing) saw the flavor in the scene say which side it came from.

And if I were scum, why would he point it out when they already knew I was with them?

mainly for this reason an accident from someone on my side. could be purely innocent thats why i asked for help if we have a town with these powers maybe they need to step up that way we now for sure

[thehippo8]

Mr. Squirrel wrote:Hey guys. Don't expect much out of me today. Someone hit me over the head last night and now I don't have a vote. I've no idea who it was, but the flavor made it sound like it was an accident from someone on my side.So whatever townie has the silencing power, you need to be careful with that. Every time you silence a townie, the mafia is a little more powerful that day. Could be a game-changer later on.

i need some help with this
ive been looking into the silencing role there could be a dentist how common is that roll but probably more likely a silencer was he warning his fellow scum

Just a quick question, why would mafia silence a fellow scum, it would just weaken their entire side. And with them loosing 1 member already. I also don't have a clue as of where squirrel (who I am replacing) saw the flavor in the scene say which side it came from.

And if I were scum, why would he point it out when they already knew I was with them?

First question - busdriving. Second question - PMs. Third question - an explanation for intended submarining.

[thehippo8]

A shot rang out. Sirens wailed in the distance. On the surface it seemed an almost uneventful night. But the pieces were still moving.

Day Four Start!

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

"But the pieces were still moving."

Is that "were" or "are"? What "pieces"?

[edocsil]

1. Back on day one in the jokevote stage, Rodion voted Mr Suirrel for being a "Bulletproof roussian roullete player". Mr Squirrel votes Rodion right back (jokevoting) but adds "It was the claim I was given. Not totally my fault". This is weasel talk and I suggest that Mr Squirrel is being a sinner (albeit I used the rather convoluted simile of disestablishmentarianism - come on it was the jokevoting stage). Anyways, Shield suggested that Rodion was scum in all his games and that he should be hammered for being at L-1 (he wasn't it was an error by Soundman which he later fixed) but his vote didn't count as he didn't unvote and didn't bold. Meanwhile Mr Squirrel's vote remained. Rodion, nevertheless, softclaims that he is not scum in any of his current games and that Shiled should know that. It was a pressure vote intended to cause a backdown by Shield. Shield jokes "Rodion, you know better to tell about our mafia partnership in on going games" but that is clearly not what Rodion was saying and it seems to me that Shield was softclaiming that he was mafia in another game but I cannot see that it was anything related to this game as such. Conzo chirps in with "What he said. Besides, you're lying of course... You're always scum" alluding to Shield pulling his head in as he agrees with Rodion. Mr Squirrel's vote remained up to this point. I accept this is jokevote territory but it becomed more relevant as time goes on.
2. The next phase of discussion relates to Isiah40 and his underlined clue as to who he was. Mr Squirrel, page 10, immediately leaps on the 12 spaces and suggests "mafia doctor? *Gasp* 12!" and votes for Isaiah. There is of course no such thing (as far as I am aware) as a mafia doctor (at least not by that name) and this really moves away from jokevoting to goading and smearing. Isaiah was nonplussed and said "Hey!! I just pushed the underline until I felt like it was enough! I should vote Mr. Squirrel just because he took the time to count. Hmmmmm ... I'll have to think about that one. I'll get back with you on that one!". Note at this point Mr Squirrel is the first and only vote on Isaiah. Isaiah was so rattled he said "Now that I think about this, Mr. Squirrel must be town if he thinks I am mafia doctor and wants to lynch me! Thank you Mr. Squirrel for your confession!" which came accross like a scum confession but clearly Isaiah was being too clever by half (confused himself by trying to sound clever).
3. The next phase of the game was the unfortunate attack on TeeGee which I started due to him being too quiet but the roll went too quickly fueled of course by VS who was the Mafia Godfather. It is ntoeworthy that Mr Squirrel appears to be scathing of this bandwagon and FOS' everyone who played a part, but I can only suggest that Mr Squirrel had no reason to suppose such a bandwagon would go to lynch at that point - and it didn't. The extension of that phase to TeeGee's editing of his post also met with a similar kind word by Mr Squirrel. But in my view this is a logical reasonableness designed to instill trust in Mr Squirrel on a meaningless issue which should never rationally lead to a lynchy.
4. The next phase came with General's rough-as-guts manner and Sully adds to the vote which Mr Squirrel asks Sully to explain. But note there is no accusativeness in this or blaming Sully or Fosing or anything of the like. It is a way of Mr Squirrel, now having proved trustworthy, tag teaming his Mafia Boss to raise VS' credibility. Nice move, and seamlessly done, but clear as day when pointed out. Incidentally, I pointed out that VS was acting scummy at the time and he was ultimately lynched on day 1. Mr Squirrel's vote remains on Isaiah at this point.
5. Mr Squirrel adds nothing in the remainder of day 1 and on day 2 says he was hit on the head and has only 4 posts. Possibly true, possibly not. Again, having now lost his Mafia Boss he has no-one to tag-team with and cannot risk saying things without damaging hsi credibility. Easier to submarine!
6. We have to leap to page 21 before we hear from Mr Squirrel who uses one of his immensely valuable posts to say that Soundman is a good guy and dead people shouldn't talk. Very suspicious behaviour IMHO for someone who is being careful as to what they can say! Indeed, Mr Squirrel makes no other comment on day two at all and isn't involved in the vote (which at page 26 I mistackenly hammered and din't realise but wasn't the only one considering the subsequent posts and general confusion at the time).
7. Mr Squirrel is the first to post on day 3. He is still active at that poiint. He says "Looks like most of the town is still asleep. I'm gonna read back and see max's previous actions perhaps we can figure out why he was killed. Someone please post that we've got some info in the night." This is, IMHO, an attempt to try and recoup some credibility but also it a fishing exercise to thresh out the important town-folk. And here we are on page 35 with no further comment by Mr Squirrel!

I think this case is crap.

1. Jokevotes. The whole number 1 is irrelevant.
2. I have modded a game with a mafia doc before. Firefly mafia. Also Isaiah's comments are fairly obviously in jest.
3. Surprise, he called you all out on LYNCHING THE DOC. That cannot be a scumtell.
4. Mr. S is unfailingly polite. You're saying he wasn't rude enough. This is however you best point as of yet.
5. No comment, it is all WIFOM with the silencer. That is typically a mafia role, and the my team comments make it a bit strange.
6. See point 4 I imagine he was as pissed as I was at General.
7. Mr. S had a medical emergency and you know that.

FoS Hippo for a really shity wall of text that raised few valid points.

[skillfusniper33]

A shot rang out. Sirens wailed in the distance. On the surface it seemed an almost uneventful night. But the pieces were still moving.

Day Four Start!

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

"But the pieces were still moving."

Is that "were" or "are"? What "pieces"?

I had a theory that there could be a jail keeper in this game, due to the sirens wailing. So whoever tried to make the kill got caught trying to break into the jail, and fled when they heard the sirens.

[zimmah]

A shot rang out. Sirens wailed in the distance. On the surface it seemed an almost uneventful night. But the pieces were still moving.

Day Four Start!

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

"But the pieces were still moving."

Is that "were" or "are"? What "pieces"?

I had a theory that there could be a jail keeper in this game, due to the sirens wailing. So whoever tried to make the kill got caught trying to break into the jail, and fled when they heard the sirens.

if there was a jailkeeper then where does the gunshot come from?

btw i am silenced.

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Skillfusniper33 - Codierose, hippo, Zimmah, Chap - (L2)
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
Edocsil -
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 27th

[MoB Deadly]

I have catching up to do, it seems pretty straightforward but I want to read the thread for myself before I cast.