[Official] NBC Mafia Town Win MVP=trinicardinal

[jonty125]

Well if dazza was 1 closer to lynch than his nearest rival then the vote isn't split but could very easily be split by someone so that's what I mean via "us".

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

leitz (4)- MoB, dazza, trini, MeDeFe
dazza(3)- PCM, leitz, jonty
jonty(3)- strike, betiko, chap

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline Midnight on January 23rd PST. If a lynch is not made by that time, no lynch will be declared.

[Epitaph1]

I suck at math. I thought MeDeFe's vote + my vote would have put Leitz at L-1.

Vote Leitz

[Leitz]

You are Sally, Town One-Way Lover.

I'm claiming because I'm at L-2 & we only have a few more days left to find mafia! I thought the heat on me would cool down but then it started to increase again the last couple of days. I hope everybody realizes almost all town is revealed and no mafia has been lynched.

[dazza2008]

You are Sally, Town One-Way Lover.

I'm claiming because I'm at L-2 & we only have a few more days left to find mafia! I thought the heat on me would cool down but then it started to increase again the last couple of days. I hope everybody realizes almost all town is revealed and no mafia has been lynched.

Is one-way lover a common role? I had never heard of it till today when someone died as it in another game.

[strike wolf]

You are Sally, Town One-Way Lover.

I'm claiming because I'm at L-2 & we only have a few more days left to find mafia! I thought the heat on me would cool down but then it started to increase again the last couple of days. I hope everybody realizes almost all town is revealed and no mafia has been lynched.

Is one-way lover a common role? I had never heard of it till today when someone died as it in another game.

Not common but Sally is a strong role claim so I tend to believe him.

[dazza2008]

You are Sally, Town One-Way Lover.

I'm claiming because I'm at L-2 & we only have a few more days left to find mafia! I thought the heat on me would cool down but then it started to increase again the last couple of days. I hope everybody realizes almost all town is revealed and no mafia has been lynched.

Is one-way lover a common role? I had never heard of it till today when someone died as it in another game.

Not common but Sally is a strong role claim so I tend to believe him.

I just found it odd that an uncommon role comes up 2 times in 1 day. Not saying it could not happen just it is odd.

I also disagree that a strong claim should get anyone off the hook straight away. I don't believe the mafia would only get shite characters as fakeclaims.

[MoB Deadly]

unvote to at least regroup

[strike wolf]

Leitz without revealing who it is were you told who your lover was? Again please don't mention names.

[Leitz]

Leitz without revealing who it is were you told who your lover was? Again please don't mention names.

Yes

[trinicardinal]

Unvote

[trinicardinal]

You are Sally, Town One-Way Lover.

I'm claiming because I'm at L-2 & we only have a few more days left to find mafia! I thought the heat on me would cool down but then it started to increase again the last couple of days. I hope everybody realizes almost all town is revealed and no mafia has been lynched.

Is one-way lover a common role? I had never heard of it till today when someone died as it in another game.

Not common but Sally is a strong role claim so I tend to believe him.

I just found it odd that an uncommon role comes up 2 times in 1 day. Not saying it could not happen just it is odd.

I also disagree that a strong claim should get anyone off the hook straight away. I don't believe the mafia would only get shite characters as fakeclaims.

The plus side of knowing so many town members is that we've narrowed the field a lot towards finding the actual mafia members as well. As for whether the mafia would only get simple fake claims or not is uncertain. Its why I earlier mentioned the possibility that strike's zero claim could be a fakeclaim. In this case though I tend to believe Leitz's claim at least to some extent.

[dazza2008]

I won't unvote. I just find it too convenient that one way lover died in another game and on the same day he claims it here.

[betiko]

so basically if jack is killed/lynched leitz dies? if what he says is true we gotta be extra careful. i believe leitz.
my vote stands on jonty.

[jonty125]

I think Leitz's claim is genuine.

[Leitz]

so basically if jack is killed/lynched leitz dies? if what he says is true we gotta be extra careful. i believe leitz.
my vote stands on jonty.

Indeed betiko. I'm not going to spill out the name as I feel enough town has already been revealed. If a case on the person in question is being made, I will not be joining.

[Leitz]

I won't unvote. I just find it too convenient that one way lover died in another game and on the same day he claims it here.

You keep astonishing me. It's not because this role appears in another game (I don't read other games besides the one(s) I am in fyi) that it cannot appear here. My vote on you stands.

[strike wolf]

I also believe Leitz claim. The flavor fits and the role is strong. As far as other cases. I still feel jonty was splitting hairs on the splitting the vote issue so I'm not changing my stance. The other option is follow through and lynch Dazza for a vanilla claim.

[dazza2008]

I won't unvote. I just find it too convenient that one way lover died in another game and on the same day he claims it here.

You keep astonishing me. It's not because this role appears in another game (I don't read other games besides the one(s) I am in fyi) that it cannot appear here. My vote on you stands.

At any point did I say it was not possible? I think you will find I said I found it convenient and pretty unlikely. I find it scummy again that you put words in my mouth that I did not use.

[trinicardinal]

I'm tending to agree with strike on this issue. between jonty and dazza I choose jonty. Overall i believe dazza's claim so far so

Vote jonty125

[Epitaph1]

Well, I take it Dazza is not Jack or Leitz wouldn't be voting for him. On that note, it would be best if Leitz did not try to protect Jack unless he is very close to getting lynched. To come to his defense too early would telegraph to the mafia who is Jack and provide a 2 for 1 NK scenario given Leitz's lover status.

The role fits the character very well, so I'm inclined to believe Leitz as well.

unvote

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

leitz (2)- dazza, MeDeFe
dazza(3)- PCM, leitz, jonty
jonty(4)- strike, betiko, chap, trini

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline Midnight on January 23rd PST. If a lynch is not made by that time, no lynch will be declared.

[chapcrap]

I honestly have no feel for who to vote or what's going on. I continue to look at MeDeFe. I feel like Leitz and dazza have both been cleared. My vote remains on jonty, because he is the best case of those 3, but not a good one.

[dazza2008]

It feels to me like we are clearing people just for a strong character. Do we not think that fakeclaims would be strong in this game?

[chapcrap]

It feels to me like we are clearing people just for a strong character. Do we not think that fakeclaims would be strong in this game?

They may have strong fake claims, but when given a very strong fake claim, should we just say, no, that's too strong, you're lying or should be we try to find someone else? I mean, it's not like we can just lynch everyone even if they claim.

And if we're talking about things being fake claims, strike's claim of zero could easily be a fake claim as well.