chapcrap wrote:strike, I don't know how I've been less active lately... I mean, I don't post 20 times a day and from my phone at the beach (I wish I was there), but I don't feel like I'm less active. I did have a busy weekend in RL if that's what you're referring to. And starting being a mod as well.
Anyway, I'm pretty sure that Vio is hinting at being Barrett. Town bomb is always a great fake claim for mafia. Not only that, we have been trying to get Barrett to claim the past 2 days and no one has said anything, so if it is a fake, Barrett would be a good person to try because there may not even be a Barrett in the game AND because if there is a Barrett, they probably don't want to claim because they are probably the SK, so what good would it do them to claim?
Victor it's nice to have you show back up since someone started saying your name... You never answered me about that video when I asked last week. It's ok, I've seen it now because I went home since then, but it's odd that you disappeared for 2+ days and then didn't even answer the question that I asked you twice.
She is hinting at it, but we know at least one of the beretts is likely to be a vig soo...
Edoc'sil
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
codierose wrote:so what you saying lets just do it i will revote
I wasn't saying let's just do it, I was just saying that the setup of the game gave her a good fake claim and town bomb is a good fake role claim for mafia as well. I was saying that if I were mafia, this would be a claim that I might try to use.
Also, I meant to ask this before and got lost in my post: Are Wedge and Biggs (codie's claimed role) related in the game? Someone said something about how we should have caught it earlier or something, but I have no idea about the flavor in Final Fantasy.
codierose wrote:so what you saying lets just do it i will revote
I wasn't saying let's just do it, I was just saying that the setup of the game gave her a good fake claim and town bomb is a good fake role claim for mafia as well. I was saying that if I were mafia, this would be a claim that I might try to use.
Also, I meant to ask this before and got lost in my post: Are Wedge and Biggs (codie's claimed role) related in the game? Someone said something about how we should have caught it earlier or something, but I have no idea about the flavor in Final Fantasy.
Running gag in FF series, never see one without the other.
Edoc'sil
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
codierose wrote:so what you saying lets just do it i will revote
I wasn't saying let's just do it, I was just saying that the setup of the game gave her a good fake claim and town bomb is a good fake role claim for mafia as well. I was saying that if I were mafia, this would be a claim that I might try to use.
Also, I meant to ask this before and got lost in my post: Are Wedge and Biggs (codie's claimed role) related in the game? Someone said something about how we should have caught it earlier or something, but I have no idea about the flavor in Final Fantasy.
Running gag in FF series, never see one without the other.
Yeppers! In FFVIII, Wedge and Biggs are Galbadian soldiers.
1. Newguy1-Rude-turk. Apparent 3rd party survivor group? Killed night 1 by the Shinra corporation
2. edocsil-Role unknown. Play style indicative of 3rd party (possible SK?)
3. Agentcom-Tseng-Turk Killed night 1 by gattling gun. Had been mostly inactive
4. Wildwilliam-Heidegger-Mafia Framer. lynched day 2. fake claimed Tifa (from game).
5. Slowreactor-Tifa Lockhart (from movie)-Town lover Killed Night 2 by Gattling gun. Had been mostly inactive
6. Killboy108-Cloud Strife (From movie)-Town lover/1 shot vig Killed Night 2 along with Slowreactor. Had been mostly inactive.
7. Zimmah-Wedge-VT Lynched Day 3 on guilty investigation result (evidence of Mafia Busdriver?)
8. Drunkmonkey-Yuffie Kisaragi (from movie)-Town Roleblocker. Killed Night 3 by Masamune (Sephiroth). Had been active.
9. Doomyoshi-Reeve Tuesti-Town cop. Killed Night 3 by Shinra Corporation. Had been active. Meta-gamed guilty result against Jgordon lead to him being lynched Day 4.
10. Commander9-Cait Sith (from Game)-Town immortal double voter/secret one-way lover. Active. Appears to have been the one using the secret vote day 1. deactivated due to Doomyoshi's death Night 3.
11. Jgordon1111-Scarlet-Mafia roleblocker. Lynched Day 4. Fake claim Red XIII.
12. Dukasaur-Reno-Turk. Killed Night 4 by Shinra Corporation. Had been more or less active.
13. DJFireside-Aerith-Town Doctor. Killed Night 4 by Sephiroth. Had been inactive.
14. strike wolf-Vincent Valentine-Town JOAT. Role blocked Night 1. Successfully counter-claimed WildWilliam Day 2. Got a false guilty result upon investigating Zimmah (Indicative of mafia busdriver?) Day 3
15. Victor Sullivan-unclaimed.
16. alt1978-unclaimed. Inactive.
17. VioIet-Unclaimed. mostly inactive. Skimmed and tried to rush through a day when the consensus was to wait for Commander's case and otherwise discuss the game.
18. drake_259-Unclaimed. Semi-active at best.
19. maximumbandit -> replaced by codierose-Claimed Biggs-VT. Active. Possible defense of Vio though I'm more recently leaning towards him being town at this point.
20. MOB Deadly-unclaimed mostly active.
21. thehippo8-unclaimed. Inactive but apparently reading back up on the thread.
22. ghostly447-Active. Strange case regarding him and Jgordon (dead mafia). Not sure what to say about him right now.
23. Eldario-unclaimed. inactive
24. dazza2008-active unclaimed.
25. chapcrap-unclaimed active early but less so lately.
I believe this covers most things. If there is something inaccurate or missing feel free to add/edit. A couple questions based on what I am seeing.
1. How likely is Sephiroth to be part of a mafia? Whatever was left of Jenova was apparently helping him through out the game and Comm9 suggested there maybe someone else who is a possible mafia member tied to Sephiroth called Hojo.
2. Is Barrett the only significant character who uses a Gattling gun in FFVII?
I think its a little hard to call me inactive, even though I haven't said much, I clearly stated that I was off celebrating my birthday this weekend and would not be back until today
I say you're inactive because throughout the game you have not been saying much.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
I can believe that Rodion would throw in a bomb so I say don't hammer just yet. I'd like to see if we can get vio to name claim first. After that, I'm willing to let Mob hammer if he feels he reasonably can or search out someone to force the hammer.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:I can believe that Rodion would throw in a bomb so I say don't hammer just yet. I'd like to see if we can get vio to name claim first. After that, I'm willing to let Mob hammer if he feels he reasonably can or search out someone to force the hammer.
I would agree with that. The problem is, when will Vio be back? Who knows.
strike wolf wrote:I can believe that Rodion would throw in a bomb so I say don't hammer just yet. I'd like to see if we can get vio to name claim first. After that, I'm willing to let Mob hammer if he feels he reasonably can or search out someone to force the hammer.
Yeah I feel like its best, my activity in this game is sub par to other games. I think 25 players is too much for me I am overwhelmed. And my character is on the "probable mafia fake claims" list so I think I should save the hassle now and use myself to see if she is mafia.
chapcrap wrote:
strike wolf wrote:I can believe that Rodion would throw in a bomb so I say don't hammer just yet. I'd like to see if we can get vio to name claim first. After that, I'm willing to let Mob hammer if he feels he reasonably can or search out someone to force the hammer.
I would agree with that. The problem is, when will Vio be back? Who knows.
Can we have an official vote count?
Im not going anywhere, we can use this time to get some of the other obvious inactives back on board. Just shout my name to hammer and I will come back.
I think the Gatling gun may be tied to Sephiroth's faction. The same night that the gatling gun stopped appearing in scenes, people started dying from the masamune. Secondly the targets were similar. The first two people who were directly killed by the gatling gun were inactives. The two people who were killed by the masamune, one was active but searching through his recent posts I think he was killed because his posts were interpreted as not taking many stands and just blending in and the other was another inactive. It's a stretch but it is the reason I've been asking if someone other than B. Wallace may use a Gatling gun.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
codierose wrote:can anyone help with the huge mako cannon hows that being used is it just a weapon the mafia uses for there kills
Read the game plot buddy. That's going to be someone in the shinra corporation. That is the Mafia. So I would be willing to bet that's just the weapon the kill with.
As for Barrett and sephiroth, I seriously doubt that they would be connected. I mean, Barrett fights for avalanche and sephiroth starts with shinra corporation and goes rogue.
Since we have 2 Barrett claims and one of them does not have the gun I am willingto bet that 1 is a big and 1 is townie since I myself can't see either as a Mafia or sk.
codierose wrote:can anyone help with the huge mako cannon hows that being used is it just a weapon the mafia uses for there kills
Read the game plot buddy. That's going to be someone in the shinra corporation. That is the Mafia. So I would be willing to bet that's just the weapon the kill with.
As for Barrett and sephiroth, I seriously doubt that they would be connected. I mean, Barrett fights for avalanche and sephiroth starts with shinra corporation and goes rogue.
Since we have 2 Barrett claims and one of them does not have the gun I am willingto bet that 1 is a big and 1 is townie since I myself can't see either as a Mafia or sk.
Ghostly my point is that from their claims neither Barrett is taking credit for the Gatling gun. I do not believe that Barrett is part of the mafia but that one of the mafia tied to Sephiroth uses a Gatling gun as his kill flavor.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
all this aside there are still 3 that are not adding anything to this one who said he would monday popped in said hi then went again another who was already asked then straight away posted couple of times didn't add anything then disappeared again then there's alt who still hasn't added anything or am i missing it also why would there be two berrets there hasn't been two other characters ???
codierose wrote:all this aside there are still 3 that are not adding anything to this one who said he would monday popped in said hi then went again another who was already asked then straight away posted couple of times didn't add anything then disappeared again then there's alt who still hasn't added anything or am i missing it also why would there be two berrets there hasn't been two other characters ???
As far as the G Gun goes, I did a very exhaustive search to see if any others from VII use one before doing a CC and I could find no one. A lot of goons use machine guns, but that is not the same thing. That gun HAS to belong to Berret if flavor canon is being followed.
A few issues. If the gun isn't hers, and it isn't mine, whose is it? If she is Berret why would she lie? If she is lying why hasn't there been a second Berret CC? Something isn't adding up and I think the only way to find out is to test her claim.
There is the argument of play the game not the mod that has me slightly concerned however. Could the gun belong to another simply to mess with us, and to reinforce play the mod not the game? I also was considering the Mamasomething(this is from a mobile, that sword) starting up where the G Gun left off. If Vio isn't lying I think we have to consider that those two kills are linked.
Anyhow, just my thoughts.
Edoc'sil
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
I think it is a bit early to say that no one has counter claimed Edoc. I'm not sure about the Gatling gun. I have a feelign it could be somehow related to Hojo and an invention of his (as I remember there were robots in VII that used a Gatling gun but I never played long enough to know if Hojo had anything to do with creating any of them.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:I think it is a bit early to say that no one has counter claimed Edoc. I'm not sure about the Gatling gun. I have a feelign it could be somehow related to Hojo and an invention of his (as I remember there were robots in VII that used a Gatling gun but I never played long enough to know if Hojo had anything to do with creating any of them.
Lol, I guess it has only been 3 hours or so. We will see what happens.
Edoc'sil
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
I did have a busy weekend in RL if that's what you're referring to. And starting being a mod as well.
