Italian Style Mafia Thread: FSO wins!

[SPARTACUS1974]

ok skillfur i took it to L1 to try to force Leehar to make his claim because in the previous post he made he said he would but unless i missed it he still has not claimed .

[dazza2008]

ok skillfur i took it to L1 to try to force Leehar to make his claim because in the previous post he made he said he would but unless i missed it he still has not claimed .

I think it is always best to stop at L-1 in case of secret voters or him being "hated"(meaning 1 less vote to lynch him) or someone not paying attention and accidently hammering him.

I don't think you have played many games. Might even be your first so I will let you off for not knowing but in future its always best to stop at L-2 and let the guy claim.

[SPARTACUS1974]

sorry yea its my first game i thought L1 was the way to go but will stop at L2 next time to try to get the claim .

[Leehar]

Sorry, was busy with Dispatch stuff, guess there's nothing else for it but to claim.

I'm Mafia Poisoner
Targeted edocsil night 1, and wildwilliam night 2.
I think you can see why I was hesitant to claim because I'm probably more 3rd party seemingly than town, but I assume everywhere thought there was a need for both me and a hitman?

[dazza2008]

Sorry, was busy with Dispatch stuff, guess there's nothing else for it but to claim.

I'm Mafia Poisoner
Targeted edocsil night 1, and wildwilliam night 2.
I think you can see why I was hesitant to claim because I'm probably more 3rd party seemingly than town, but I assume everywhere thought there was a need for both me and a hitman?

Do you have to poison each night or can you choose not to?

In my opinion this could be a good lynch even if you are mafia. Seems like it could do more harm than good.

[dazza2008]

The only think that Lehar has done is kill 1 mafia and probably another will die tonight as Saf has now cleared WW.

[codierose]

dazz
safari cleared WW only if hes telling the truth sorry for the run around with jgord just passes the time at work
ok so leheer has killed ww for tonight is that right thats a possible 2 members of the mafia that cant be good if thats the case WW needs to claim to be protected or not if the case hes scum lol sorry for the noob questions so basicly the claim is anti mafia i cant see it as a fake claim can it work in our advantage to get an extra kill on top of the lynch
question for leehar why did you choose those targets

[codierose]

oh if ww dies tonight that could be good that would prove safaris claims if hes lying we could end up with 2 extra scum up for grabs still depends on WW role though i guess

[jgordon1111]

Yes WW now is the time to step up. 2 games I have been in with you prior to this, one you were town the other you were mafia, but in both you played a very active role, This time you are saying almost zero. just to bring you up to speed WW I know who you targeted N1. Shall we discuss who and then why, or are you going to defend yourself. And please none of the nastiness of the first 2 games. You already know I will go down for town to win.

[jgordon1111]

sorry for the double post I want to clarify town in previous post, in this game it means mafia. In before anyone jumped to conclusions

[codierose]

lol didnt even give me chance 2

[dazza2008]

lol didnt even give me chance 2

Chance to what? I never have a clue what you are on about in games

[codierose]

. In before anyone jumped to conclusions

[dazza2008]

. In before anyone jumped to conclusions

Ah got you now. I do find it hard to keep up with your posts though or follow what you are talking about most of the time.

[codierose]

thats the idea
its my Cornish charm or probably the inbreeding

[codierose]

everywhere can you give wildwilliam a prod its been 2 days since his last post dead line coming up if he dont responded soon we need an extension

[jak111]

My vote stays with Leehar atm, but reading what's been posted last night and this mourning.
Jgordon and MoB, I'm still questioning. Jgordon for making accusations again and again that were either false or questionable, and MoB for seeming to go under the radar yet again.

But Leehar, unless you start using your role to our advantage you're going to need to go so we don't have 3 mafia dropping every night.

[codierose]

what does everyone think about extending the dead line
Deadline is 4:00 ConqST Friday. is that 04.00 am or 16.00 pm
unvote vote Mob for flying under the scumdar

[jgordon1111]

codi,Jak I would prefer at this time to have WW step up before MoB. This ties into me asking WW to step up before.

[codierose]

agree but hes going to do tonight anyway and we need a lynch before the days out mob sounds to me to be the best bet right now or even sparta

[everywhere116]

what does everyone think about extending the dead line
Deadline is 4:00 ConqST Friday. is that 04.00 am or 16.00 pm
unvote vote Mob for flying under the scumdar

I'll prod him. He hasn't posted anything since Monday Oh, and it's PM. I thought I had that in there.

No extensions

EDIT: I might be willing to extend it further into Friday night. But no further.

[codierose]

cheers boss
no extension ok we all need to agree on something

[skillfusniper33]

Well this game has some very odd roles in it for our side of things, especially with a couple of killing roles. But this kinda makes since with the theme. We also can test leehar's claim by seeing if WW dies tonight, and if not we lynch leehar tomorrow, but for today I am not sure what to do for a lynch, especially with very little time left on the clock.

WW claiming might not be a bad idea, that way if he does have a power role he can tell us who the targeted each night.

[safariguy5]

True, WW claiming might be nice, but that's partly working under the assumption that we have a choice on whether he's going to die. If we have a poison doctor, then WW could be saved tonight. If we don't have a poison doctor, it's nice if WW can give us his night actions, but he's probably dead anyways.

Man...having a town aligned poisoner is like having a town vig. Shooting people early on rarely hits scum.

[jgordon1111]

LOL unless there is something very funny going on. I know who he targeted the first night. And right now he is most definetly not playing in his usual manner. I have my thoughts on the reason for that, but I will hold them for now. But codie If your target was true then WW's will be to.

Fast posted BY Safari.

My first game I didnt understand the term meta gaming Safari. I believe I have a better grasp now.

First you say you hid behind him night one, thus clearing him per your role.
Now I may be wrong but you seem like you are trying to put distance between you, by saying his claiming would be nice, then saying he is probably dead anyways.

Easy middle of the road talk, but still in its own way, saying dont worry about him claiming its not important.

And then if he is forced to claim or is lynched and flips scum you can say, well I made a mistake this game confused me on what my role really did.