commanderdave Farming [warned] BG

[KraphtOne]

Accused:
commanderdave

The accused are suspected of:
Farming New Recruits

Game numbers

Game 11310445
Game 11310444
Game 11310442
Game 11287350
Game 11287349
Game 11287347
Game 11287346
Game 11287345
Game 11405004
Game 11405003
Game 11405002
Game 11405001
Game 11405000
Game 11404998
Game 11404997
Game 11404996
Game 11404995
Game 11404994
Game 11404993
Game 11404992
Game 11404991
Game 11404990
Game 11404989
Game 11359238
Game 11359237
Game 11359235
Game 11359234
Game 11359233
Game 11359232
Game 11359231
Game 11359229
Game 11359228
Game 11359227
Game 11359226
Game 11359225
Game 11359224
Game 11350452
Game 11350451
Game 11350450
Game 11350449
Game 11350448
Game 11350438
Game 11350437
Game 11350436
Game 11337340
Game 11337338
Game 11337337
Game 11337335
Game 11337334
Game 11337332
Game 11337331
Game 11337330
Game 11337328
Game 11319871
Game 11319868
Game 11319865
Game 11319864
Game 11319863
Game 11319860
Game 11319859
Game 11319857
Game 11319856
Game 11319855
Game 11319853
Game 11319852
Game 11310454
Game 11310453
Game 11310452
Game 11310451
Game 11310450
Game 11310449
Game 11310448
Game 11310447
Game 11310446

Comments:

Ladies and Gentlemen step right up! for a limited time only even YOU can attain a really high rank!!!
what's that you say?
"i only win 20% of my games"
well not a problem! just set up 10+ 5 person games on simple maps at a time and wait for the new recruits to jump in the boat!
"what about other players joining"?
no worries my friends... that's why you set up so many of them at a time... even if someone wants to join 1 or 2 there's no way they are joining all of them, and after a few minutes these games are off the back page and just waiting to be shuffled to the front of the new recruits' join games pages...
"but won't they be at the front of a normal players page as well"
no sir! because the games at the front of our pages are team games and games that are on complicated maps... new recruits don't even see those!!! so its almost impossible for anyone BUT new recruits to join your games, unless they are purposefully seeking out those random settings you created!!!


edit: wait no sorry guys this has been proven to be a no-no so don't do it
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... d#p3595342
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... ing+warned
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... d#p3496058
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... d#p2588800
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... w#p2367088
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... ing+warned

and the one that started it all....
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewto ... ing+warned

[Dibbun]

Holy shit that's a lot of games.

Point reset at the least, plus at least a month vacation because this is VERY intentional.

[jgordon1111]

looks kind of obvious but the difference between him and glg he is playing other open games,going to be a tough call for sure.

[rhp 1]

hahahahahaha... I side with whatever K-One is sayin just from laughin my ass off for the last 5 minutes... fuckin classic...

[rhp 1]

ok... now I actually looked at the games...

HOLY SHIT

[rhp 1]

looks kind of obvious but the difference between him and glg he is playing other open games,going to be a tough call for sure.

RU OFF YOUR MEDS?

[jgordon1111]

looks kind of obvious but the difference between him and glg he is playing other open games,going to be a tough call for sure.

RU OFF YOUR MEDS?

LOL read the first word of your avatar and get back to me.

[Frox333]

LOL read the first word of your avatar and get back to me. [/quote]

[hmsps]

I don't think he will get a point reset. Cases like this in the past the accused has been asked to change from 5 player to 6 player games for example

[Arama86n]

I don't think he will get a point reset. Cases like this in the past the accused has been asked to change from 5 player to 6 player games for example

Sad isn't it So open and shut. But it is as hmsps says, so I can't even bother comamnedting further, not like it will help.

[eddie2]

hummmm i just looked at this guys game page. and although he does have a lot of games joined by new recruits he also has a lot of games he plays...

looks tome like ww2 western front is his fav map this can be seen because he plays a lot of 6 player doubles games on this as well. fact also he changes the maps. i do not think this is a farming case i think this is more a case of a player wanting to play and n/r's keep on joining his games. he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

[Arama86n]

hummmm i just looked at this guys game page. and although he does have a lot of games joined by new recruits he also has a lot of games he plays...

looks tome like ww2 western front is his fav map this can be seen because he plays a lot of 6 player doubles games on this as well. fact also he changes the maps. i do not think this is a farming case i think this is more a case of a player wanting to play and n/r's keep on joining his games. he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

Or he changes things around a little not to make it too obvious? You make a bunch of 5-player games you know what will happen. I like 5-player esc too, but if i feel like playing it I put them in callouts with a PW, open for all, jsut stops NR's arriving en mass.
At the very least he thinks it's fine that 90% of his 5player games are filling with NR's only. instead of doing a simple thing like I suggested above he is content to play large amoutns of games against NRs.

[Woodruff]

hummmm i just looked at this guys game page. and although he does have a lot of games joined by new recruits he also has a lot of games he plays...

looks tome like ww2 western front is his fav map this can be seen because he plays a lot of 6 player doubles games on this as well. fact also he changes the maps. i do not think this is a farming case i think this is more a case of a player wanting to play and n/r's keep on joining his games. he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

Or he changes things around a little not to make it too obvious? You make a bunch of 5-player games you know what will happen.

I still maintain that if you're not inviting noobs to your games and so they're just joining a public game, you shouldn't be punished as you're not at all controlling who may or may not join your game. I really believe the C&A mods screwed the pooch on that precedent.

For me, it's when the invite system is being used OR the individual who is "farming" is the one joining the games that already have the noobs in them that's a problem.

[jghost7]

hummmm i just looked at this guys game page. and although he does have a lot of games joined by new recruits he also has a lot of games he plays...

looks tome like ww2 western front is his fav map this can be seen because he plays a lot of 6 player doubles games on this as well. fact also he changes the maps. i do not think this is a farming case i think this is more a case of a player wanting to play and n/r's keep on joining his games. he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

Or he changes things around a little not to make it too obvious? You make a bunch of 5-player games you know what will happen.

I still maintain that if you're not inviting noobs to your games and so they're just joining a public game, you shouldn't be punished as you're not at all controlling who may or may not join your game. I really believe the C&A mods screwed the pooch on that precedent.

For me, it's when the invite system is being used OR the individual who is "farming" is the one joining the games that already have the noobs in them that's a problem.

I agree, Woodruff hit it on the head here.

[BGtheBrain]

commanderdave has been warned for farming.

After reviewing the history, the user was attracting a disproportionate number of new recruits to his games. This can be avoided by changing the game to 6, 7, or 8 player which the accused has been advised to do in the future.

Punishment Scale for Farming

Warning
1 Month New Recruit Vacation
3 Month New Recruit Vacation
Permanent New Recruit Vacation

[jghost7]

commanderdave has been warned for farming.

After reviewing the history, the user was attracting a disproportionate number of new recruits to his games. This can be avoided by changing the game to 6, 7, or 8 player which the accused has been advised to do in the future.

Punishment Scale for Farming

Warning
1 Month New Recruit Vacation
3 Month New Recruit Vacation
Permanent New Recruit Vacation

This is dumb. If creating 5 player games is against the rules, either state it in the rules or remove the option. You also could put the code in to disable the option by the users score. Either way it is ridiculous to punish someone for this.

[BGtheBrain]

If creating 5 player games is against the rules, either state it in the rules or remove the option

Systematically Farming "New Recruits"

If you are found guilty of New Recruit Farming---that is, systematically joining games with New Recruits. Systematically Farming "New Recruits" may also systematically creating unappealing games that more savvy users avoid because of unpopular or niche game settings, thus luring New Recruits into stumbling into said games. Either of these practices are done in order to "farm" newbies for points, and if you find yourself doing one or both of these practices, you will find yourself escalating on the New Recruit Farming Vacation scale.

[ad10r3tr0]

what's the "standard" definition of an unappealing game then? While I do agree with the ruling, this whole rule set of creating unpopular games is stupid. If he likes the setting, let him play it. Its not his job to monitor his games on who is joining. There needs to be some form up submitted suggestion to allow us to prevent NR from joining a game when he sets them up. We have many options already, why not like a "check box" that says block this game from the NR list that can be seen.

[eddie2]

well yipee,

how many people want to prevent new recruits from joining there games... i have seen many saying this...

well this is how to do it.

create the 5 player game mentioned in the op same settings report yourself when warned tell them to get notted create another load report again do this 4 times then you get the n/r ban you wanted.

[jghost7]

If creating 5 player games is against the rules, either state it in the rules or remove the option

Systematically Farming "New Recruits"

If you are found guilty of New Recruit Farming---that is, systematically joining games with New Recruits. Systematically Farming "New Recruits" may also systematically creating unappealing games that more savvy users avoid because of unpopular or niche game settings, thus luring New Recruits into stumbling into said games. Either of these practices are done in order to "farm" newbies for points, and if you find yourself doing one or both of these practices, you will find yourself escalating on the New Recruit Farming Vacation scale.

That is bullshit. Don't quote this vague statement like it specifically states that creating 5 player games is against the rules. If you don't have anything better than this to refer to for a rule reference then you either need to specify 5 player games or remove the option altogether. Or even as has been suggested previously, present the option to ban NRs from joining. You could even just ban NRs from all 5 player games since you think that they are unable to handle it. I don't really care but don't go pushing bullshit on the rest of us. Currently creating 5 player games is an option that we have here at CC. I see no reason not to do so as long as this remains so. Personally I don't see anything wrong with a 5 player game but if the site does then it should do something about it and let its players play the game.

Thanks,

J

[eddie2]

The problem is once a new recruit joins the game nobody else will ???

once a new recruit joins a game other new recruits join it as they see the ? rank same as theres.

meanwhile players who play games dont get them filled because of this and 5 player is a big difference to 6 player on starting positions etc. it has also been mentioned before to limit new recruits to 1 only allowed in the game(denied). and bg please tell me from your quote 3 things..

systematically creating unappealing games that more savvy users avoid because of unpopular or niche game settings, thus luring New Recruits into stumbling into said games.

1) the 3 maps he was using were these difficult maps
ww2 europe western (has a small bombard area uk only difficult part to it.)
cairns coast(basic play map like classic.)
portugal (basic play map like classic)

i do not class these in the same tense as feudal das scholls city mougal and a few others they are basic maps.

systematically creating unappealing games that more savvy users avoid because of unpopular or niche game settings, thus luring New Recruits into stumbling into said games.

2) the settings he uses..
standard
automatic
no spoils
unlimited
fog

plz point out the difficult setting here for a basic map...

3)know look at you awnser to ? 1 and 2 then tell me he was picking awkward maps and settings. and if these are classed as such then they need to be removed from new recruits joining them.

[KraphtOne]

I feel like you guys missed something...

jghost7 wrote: If creating 5 player games is against the rules, either state it in the rules or remove the option

making 5 player games isn't against the rules... making a bunch of them at a time is...

Click Join Games, now look at the games on the first page... Guess what? new recruits do not see these games...

They only see simple 5 player and under, non-difficult map games...

Now how could i get MY 5 player game to show up right there for them to join? why... make a ton of them at one time so its impossible for all of them to fill with actual players...

The problem is once a new recruit joins the game nobody else will ???

The problem is that once these games hit the front of the new recruit page... they fill within MINUTES... and WE never even knew the games existed...

he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

the guy changed maps because he's not an idiot, and thought he could skate the rule...

quick... make 20 games on 20 different simple maps with these settings "no spoils, adjacent reinforcements" (make sure the map isnt stupidly simple like lux)

no psycho is going to join more than maybe 1 of these games while they are on the back page... and within 15 minutes, they are gone baby gone off the back page and just waiting a day or 2 on the new recruit train to roll in...

[eddie2]

ok for starters they were unlimited forts not adjacent ..

and if this is how it is happening would it make it easier to code that games cannot go to new recruit list till they been on the normal page for 1 week. then that will make it easier ???

[jgordon1111]

Hells no just give us the option to block NR's from our games. Its that simple. I asked KA once if he would just make it where NR's couldnt join my games,he told me no.

But this is going to be the backlash, commanderdave farming or not,if you like 5 player games odds are sooner or later you will be answering questions if you play alot of games.

[jghost7]

I feel like you guys missed something...

jghost7 wrote: If creating 5 player games is against the rules, either state it in the rules or remove the option

making 5 player games isn't against the rules... making a bunch of them at a time is...

...

Once again, this is not stated anywhere in the rules. If there is a limit then there should be a note addressing it or a hard limit implemented by code. If the only reason bringing attention to 5 player games is NRs, then they should address it from that direction rather than from the creators of the game. Plenty of solutions, with this warning being among the worst.

he is not creating 1 map 1 setting all the time to attract new recruits he keeps on changing the map..

the guy changed maps because he's not an idiot, and thought he could skate the rule...

quick... make 20 games on 20 different simple maps with these settings "no spoils, adjacent reinforcements" (make sure the map isnt stupidly simple like lux)

no psycho is going to join more than maybe 1 of these games while they are on the back page... and within 15 minutes, they are gone baby gone off the back page and just waiting a day or 2 on the new recruit train to roll in...

You are making assumptions regarding another players intent, dramatizing it to make it sound like it was his intent to farm. Either way, he should be able to create the games that he enjoys playing without being subject to this. There are too many possible solutions for this perceived issue for it to have to depend on a vague statement of a rule.

The ability to prevent NRs from joining specific games is already a feature of the site as is evident by the ability to enforce a 'New Recruit Vacation'. If you are going to try to punish players for playing NRs at least give them the option to screen them out so that you can eliminate 5 players games from CCs vague ass rule.

Thanks,

J