Best (Randomness) Of 2012 Game Over!

[Iron Butterfly]

Though I must say the quickhammer from IB, when we were waiting if there was anything else was unexpected.

It wasn't a quick hammer. You have put a bullseye on my back by putting the focus on my actions. What clicked for me was someone saying that if Doom was town he wouldn't go for a modkill but the kicker for me was him voting for himself as he seemed to admit he was caught by listing a role not on the list.

They can not both be mafia. They can both be Town...but worse case scenario Doom is a VT.

[edocsil]

No townie will push for a mod kill on a claimed doctor for rule infringement.

Your an idiot. Your logic to too comprehend. Your stupid fucking premise assumes that we know the Doc's Identity.

vote doom. For being too stupid to check the list.

This is spot on. We hit scum. Nice catch, I didn't even think to look.

[Nebuchadnezer]

No townie will push for a mod kill on a claimed doctor for rule infringement.

Your an idiot. Your logic to too comprehend. Your stupid fucking premise assumes that we know the Doc's Identity.

vote doom. For being too stupid to check the list.

This is spot on. We hit scum. Nice catch, I didn't even think to look.

Was I right or wrong, troll?

[edocsil]

No townie will push for a mod kill on a claimed doctor for rule infringement.

Your an idiot. Your logic to too comprehend. Your stupid fucking premise assumes that we know the Doc's Identity.

vote doom. For being too stupid to check the list.

This is spot on. We hit scum. Nice catch, I didn't even think to look.

Was I right or wrong, troll?

Watch it rookie. This is a game of logic. If your logic is bad you can still get lucky, and TBH that's what has likely happened. Don't give yourself any credit if he flips scum.

[Iron Butterfly]

Classic Edocsil. It brings a tear to my eye.

[Nebuchadnezer]

They can not both be mafia. They can both be Town...but worse case scenario Doom is a VT.

I'm not sure what this means...Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still think there is a possibility that he is VT?

Watch it rookie. This is a game of logic. If your logic is bad you can still get lucky, and TBH that's what has likely happened. Don't give yourself any credit if he flips scum.

This is what bothers me..."if he flips scum"? Really? "If?" Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still say "if"? Why?

And don't worry, I think Rishaed really gets the credit here for picking up on Doom's D1 antics and continuing the push on D2.

[Iron Butterfly]

They can not both be mafia. They can both be Town...but worse case scenario Doom is a VT.

I'm not sure what this means...Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still think there is a possibility that he is VT?

Watch it rookie. This is a game of logic. If your logic is bad you can still get lucky, and TBH that's what has likely happened. Don't give yourself any credit if he flips scum.

This is what bothers me..."if he flips scum"? Really? "If?" Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still say "if"? Why?

And don't worry, I think Rishaed really gets the credit here for picking up on Doom's D1 antics and continuing the push on D2.

There is a difference between saying he is a VT and stating, "The worst case scenario he is a VT".

[Kanin Usagi]

They can not both be mafia. They can both be Town...but worse case scenario Doom is a VT.

I'm not sure what this means...Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still think there is a possibility that he is VT?

Watch it rookie. This is a game of logic. If your logic is bad you can still get lucky, and TBH that's what has likely happened. Don't give yourself any credit if he flips scum.

This is what bothers me..."if he flips scum"? Really? "If?" Doom voted for himself for making a bad claim, yet you still say "if"? Why?

And don't worry, I think Rishaed really gets the credit here for picking up on Doom's D1 antics and continuing the push on D2.

There is a difference between saying he is a VT and stating, "The worst case scenario he is a VT".

But he he ISN'T a VT. He has done everything but confirm that fact by not even posting a defense as to why he made that fake claim. He's scum. There's no question about that. Saying "The worst case scenario he is a VT" is a lot like "The worst case scenario the sun won't rise tomorrow." Its a sure thing that he will flip scum, just like its a sure thing the sun will rise (unless you live in one of the arctic circles, then I apologize).

[Iron Butterfly]

NOTHING is absolute in mafia until a person is dead and flipped.

[jonty125]

VOTE COUNT
DoomYoshi (6) - spieser; Nebuchadnezar; Doom Yoshi; rishaed; Kanin Usagi; Iron Butterfly;


With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

DoomYoshi - Snuffleupagus (Mafia Goon) has been lynched.

Deadline for night actions is Wednesday 6 February @ 1600 GMT.

[edocsil]

No townie will push for a mod kill on a claimed doctor for rule infringement.

Your an idiot. Your logic too stupid to comprehend. Your stupid fucking premise assumes that we know the Doc's Identity.

Night talk, I get it, BAD. Still I was going back though the last days and I realized I fucked up. I got my wires crossed between claims in my games. I just wanted to apologize to Neb for being such a dick. I had forgotten that hank had claimed D1, and forgotten to write it down in my note-sheets as well.

I'll be a total jerk to people I think are being dumb and I've been a bit frustrated with the fora the last few weeks with one thing or another. More than a bit embarrassed that this time it was me being the fool.

[jonty125]

Night Two has been extended because my inbox has filled up, so some actions haven't been received. You have been PM'd if you have been effected.

[jonty125]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sv6dMFF_yts

Give me a second,
I need to get my story straight,
I'm going to stab you with this knife,
Your maker is waiting you, just another moment or two
Your life is going to be taken by me, asking 'bout a scar, and
I know we only met two days ago
I know you're only a butterfly
But between the votes and subtle hints
The holes in my argument, you know
I’m trying hard to take it back
So, if by the time night falls
And you feel like you're alive
I'll change that for you

Tonight,
You are dead,
So let's set your body on fire
It can burn brighter than the sun

Iron Butterfly - The Keymaker (Vanilla Townie) has died

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline is Friday 22 February @ 1600 GMT.

[edocsil]

Keymaker is IB, according to the OP. I don't know if it was intentional omitted in the above post. Flavor seems SKish to me, knives/scars and so on. However, setting scenes to songs can't be easy so maybe I'm reading into too much.

[spiesr]

Interesting that Iron Butterfly was killed, on my reread he stood out as one of the scummiest people on Day 2.
So, does anybody have something for us to start with or I do have to go dredge up a case?

[Iron Butterfly]

My job is done.

[Iron Butterfly]

My job is done.

LOL and i was looking forward to claiming for the controversy...I had the same role in Matrix Mafia...hows that for randomness?

GG all.

[rishaed]

GG IB I'll leave my comments for afterwards.
Any of our cases from D1 are dried up. We need to look at yesterday to see what sticks out. Imma going to do a readthrough to see what sticks out.

[Nebuchadnezer]

GG IB I'll leave my comments for afterwards.
Any of our cases from D1 are dried up. We need to look at yesterday to see what sticks out. Imma going to do a readthrough to see what sticks out.

Well, let's start with known facts...who did you protect last night?

[rishaed]

Speisr. . . I was initially going to protect IB after painting the target on his back, but decided that there was more of a chance that speisr would be targeted.
I would say that Edoc, Speisr, and I are all townies. . .
That being said I am going to vote the inactive >.>
vote Gregwolf
Otherwise PCM/Kanin might be good leads to go off of.

[Nebuchadnezer]

Speisr. . . I was initially going to protect IB after painting the target on his back, but decided that there was more of a chance that speisr would be targeted.
I would say that Edoc, Speisr, and I are all townies. . .
That being said I am going to vote the inactive >.>
vote Gregwolf
Otherwise PCM/Kanin might be good leads to go off of.

Those are nice opinions of Edoc and Spiesr and yourself...all backed up by ZERO fact. I thought Iron was a poor choice myself...we might have hanged him on his own.

My gut says chuck...but let's hear from some people...anyone get results?

[rishaed]

Edoc, I protected N1 (no death), his initial reaction the fact that I was doc'd+protected him, plus a half admission by doom that it would make him town, makes me 98% certain that he is town.
Speisr, I mean who after a scum mate claims, points out that his claim isn't legit b/c it wasn't on the game list. It would have to be planned the night before ( i mean given that nobody would push for doom lynch the next day).
I, because i know I am the bodyguard. If you don't believe me that's one thing, I don't know why the scum have let me live so long anyways.

[gregwolf121]

well i got nothing just a few people im going to keep an eye on but nothing but gut feelings for now,
so anybody get something last night that they want to share

[Nebuchadnezer]

Reading back on Doomyoshi's posts, I come to the following conclusion...Kanin Usagi and Pancakemix are most likely mafia. Why? Doom never once mentions either of them in his posts. I think he mentions everyone else, except for those two. I'm willing to start with one of them. Although, let's be honest, we have quite a few sandbaggers in this game, making it tough to be sure.

For review, here is the vote count...

DoomYoshi (6) - spieser; Nebuchadnezar; Doom Yoshi; rishaed; Kanin Usagi; Iron Butterfly;

So Kanin was on the wagon, pancake was off. So...who to vote...

Vote pancakemix I think his posts seem off. Also, he forced Rishaed's claim on D1 for crap reasons. Then when Edoc tore him up, he quickly backed off. Also, his statement that he would have hammered Doom seems like he's just trying to fit in. I'm all for Pancake on this one.

[jonty125]

Vote Count
Gregwolf121 (1) - rishaed;
pancakemix (1) - Nebuchadnezar;

Deadline is Firday 22 February @ 1600 GMT. If the vote count were to remain the same until deadline a 24 hour run-off period will be enforced.