Moderator: Community Team
thechuck51 wrote:GG all
What was the secret theme?
gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
aage wrote:So did both of you target me during n1?
gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Nebuchadnezer wrote:Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
sorry neb but you fooled no one...especially with your, Whats the diff between sk kills and mafia" That was th kiss of death for you.Nebuchadnezer wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.I disagree. What I think was the downfal of mafia/ was bad luck. A kill was lost night one because both targeted agee. An extra Town PR death could have turned the tide.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.I will agree on that. By day three we had all the bad guys narrowed down to a pool of 5 players. But yes the night scenes pretty much acted as a road map.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
Iron Butterfly wrote:sorry neb but you fooled no one...especially with your, Whats the diff between sk kills and mafia" That was th kiss of death for you.Nebuchadnezer wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.I disagree. What I think was the downfal of mafia/ was bad luck. A kill was lost night one because both targeted agee. An extra Town PR death could have turned the tide.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.I will agree on that. By day three we had all the bad guys narrowed down to a pool of 5 players. But yes the night scenes pretty much acted as a road map.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
Nebuchadnezer wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
Nebuchadnezer wrote:Iron Butterfly wrote:sorry neb but you fooled no one...especially with your, Whats the diff between sk kills and mafia" That was th kiss of death for you.Nebuchadnezer wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.I disagree. What I think was the downfal of mafia/ was bad luck. A kill was lost night one because both targeted agee. An extra Town PR death could have turned the tide.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.I will agree on that. By day three we had all the bad guys narrowed down to a pool of 5 players. But yes the night scenes pretty much acted as a road map.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
You're right. I sucked. Hopefully, one day I will play this game at a higher level...
Hunter S. Thompson wrote:The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over..
DoomYoshi wrote:Nebuchadnezer wrote:Iron Butterfly wrote:sorry neb but you fooled no one...especially with your, Whats the diff between sk kills and mafia" That was th kiss of death for you.Nebuchadnezer wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:good game, really enjoyed it. now i got some comments and questions
@new guy what would have happened if it came down to me and chuck, how would you have worked that out,
@chuck why didn't you kill sheep the last night, you knew he was the cop, if you had killed him you would have stood a better chance of convincing me you were town.
to everyone, during the second day i hinted that i was a watcher, in order to draw fire from the mafia, cause i was bulletproof, hence wasting the mafia's kill, but what im wondering is, how effective was it?
Good game all. Overall, I guess it was pretty balanced. The SK, however did not really stand a chance. Town had a huge amount of power.I disagree. What I think was the downfal of mafia/ was bad luck. A kill was lost night one because both targeted agee. An extra Town PR death could have turned the tide.
I did think that the stories did give away too much. It basically confirmed claims. Also, having newguy basically tell town that sheep was the cop/detective was a major blow to the scum.I will agree on that. By day three we had all the bad guys narrowed down to a pool of 5 players. But yes the night scenes pretty much acted as a road map.
I did enjoy the game, though. Lots of fun, and my first fakeclaim that was somewhat successful. Well played town.
You're right. I sucked. Hopefully, one day I will play this game at a higher level...
I've never won as SK. It's on my bucket list though.
jonty125 wrote:I did think my name being Butler was slightly curious, but I let it be.
Hunter S. Thompson wrote:The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over..
Users browsing this forum: No registered users