[OFFICIAL] C9 Mafia (2) - GAME OVER TOWN WINS

[Streaker]

How the hell is madmitch still alive?
Almost can't believe that vote by Toad.

We need a few more posts from madmitch and sniper, then we can lynch.

[Streaker]

Sniper I see you lurking there. You'd better make a statement soon.

Unvote for now.

[elonpuckhog]

VOTE COUNT:

None

(That was easy)

Deadline: 4/27, 12 Noon CCT

5 alive, 3 to lynch

[skillfusniper33]

To be honest, yes I have Mtamb and sniper as town. I can see your point of view on toad being town (the effort of him trying to explain himself).

[spoiler]

This is my third game ever and so far I learned day one are joke votes. I don't have any knowledge about basketball, Rodman just came up (remember the Double Team movie?)

I'll admit, the number of game transcripts I've read is greater than the number of games I've taken part in, but from what I've seen, yeah, day 1 does seem to be joke votes or random votes, mainly to see how people react and get a feel for them.

Ugh, now that you mention it, I do remember Double Team.
Unvote: mtamburini. Vote: Dennis Rodman.

Bit late to switch your vote from an actual player to joke vote. Aren't you interested to find mafia?

Vote Marashu

Since he did this so early in the game, I don't see it as being a huge deal, and if we didn't have anything else to go off of I would pursue it more. But since Dakky and mtam have been bringing good points back and forth. This gives us more info to pull from on the 1st day. He did unvote the next day. The bigger issue I have right now with Marashu is that he is kinda MIA.

As for reads on other players, I think dakky is a little antsy here and pushing everyone to believe his case. I don't feel like he is scum, but he could easily be pushing hard because he is. I also feel like he is overreacting to a few statements and not forming his own opinions, but letting other people make them for him. As he uses most of our quotes to explain his feelings/thoughts.

Both Streaker and Mtam are giving me a town vibe, especially since I don't see them being able to pull anything off on day 1, that is also why I don't believe this statement by streaker.

Exploiting trust? Oh i see where this is going.

So Mtamb and Dakky are scum, playing good cop bad cop to frame me.

Out of the active players I feel like dakky is the scummiest. I will keep my vote on Pugs since he is completely MIA.

He was defending Marashu. If mafia he'd leave open a possible lynch on Marashu as backup-lynch for D1, or follow up lynch on D2. By defending him he denies himself the option for a supported lynch if he is mafia. And gut feeling. My reasons for having sniper as town.

However...

This is very interesting indeed. But good lord the fact that 2 people speed lynched dakky is crazy. I will be honest my case on him was very weak and we had plenty of time.

Streaker you need to give madmitch a little relief (like a grain of sand worth) since he did replace someone, but that is only for not posting at all, until he speed lynched dakky...

If mad flips mafia, whoever makes it to final 3 and is town DO NOT VOTE RIGHT AWAY, you could be giving mafia a free win if you choose incorrectly.

@streaker to clarify you think me and skill are town?

Can you explain skill?

I have 2 questions for you mtam? EOD is End of day correct? What would you like me to try and explain, the reason for the dumb kill on marashu, because I really can't do that at all, going into the night I figured you would be dead mtam.

[/spoiler]

This post throws all that town credit down the drain.

1) soft defending MadMitch. Just no.
2)backing off from your case on Dakky. You did manage to get him lynched and now you crawl back stating your case was weak? You are lucky he was speedlynched in this perspective.
3)actually ignoring the matter at hand, which is finding the scummate of MadMitch.

Yep looks like we have our 2 scum here.
Even though I'd insta lynch MadMitch here, gotta consider voting sniper first...

To start, I wanted to apologize for being away for a day or so. I have been reading but haven't had the time to get my own thoughts on the situation figured out.

I feel your pain and anger here streaker since MadMitch completely revealed he was mafia by doing that, and not providing anything else to the game to speak of.

As for backing off on my case on dakky, yes I feel like it was weak, but do you plan on turning it against me? If so don't wait, use it to create your own case. Then again I am also a perfectionist so I feel like everything I put together is subpar. I also try to play by the facts rather than let my emotions get involved with this type of game, especially since I can't read any facial expressions. So even with you saying you are furious with the outcome I could easily see this being complete bull. As the worst liers can sit behind a screen and type out whatever they want to hopefully make someone believe it.

One problem I see now is that none of you are trustworthy, even mtam, who I had as 95% chance of town. With that kill I really feel like it is being used to throw people off, and make it look like newer players are the mafia. As you mentioned earlier streaker:

...
@Mtamb, I don't have sniper as mafia. Honestly, he could very well be. On the other hand, you might be having the time of your life as mafia right now with that night kill
A more realistic option is that both mafia are noobs beginners. Seriously, dat night kill.
....

I am now actually very suspicious of Mtam because of this statement.

I can't believe there is no fucking cop in this game

For the one reason of as you guys said earlier in the day, the only solid case you would have would be on marashu, so the cop would likely look their to try and help solidify the case. So when marashu turned up dead why would you reveal yourself. And with the speed lynch I would have assumed if it were either of you guys it would be smarter to stay quite rather than reveal the next target for the mafia.

I will not place my vote now, but am willing to at this moment in time, but I am very scared of the speed lynch happening again and just giving this game to the mafia, especially with it already taking place in this game...

[mtamburini]

Why does that make me suspicious?

[mtamburini]

Never mind I can see what you are saying now, so what does a cop check on mars do now that he is dead?

The same thing if he was alive. With everyone being relatively new a cop check wouldve been more likely on me based on all the activity that I created on day 1.

And why havent you answered my question why would you think I would die, if you did i must of missed on ive been using my phone to read.

[mtamburini]

And mitch is gone again

[skillfusniper33]

Never mind I can see what you are saying now, so what does a cop check on mars do now that he is dead?

The same thing if he was alive. With everyone being relatively new a cop check wouldve been more likely on me based on all the activity that I created on day 1.

And why havent you answered my question why would you think I would die, if you did i must of missed on ive been using my phone to read.

Sorry I forgot to answer why I thought you would be dead, and that is because you were causing a lot of havoc, by scum hunting and it should have made them worried about you catching onto them at some point since you are the most vocal in trying to find them.

As for the cop check on mars it should have happened on night one to help prove either your case being right, or allowing us to move onto another case. The fact that he died means it would be safer to stay quite about his role today so he could hopefully get a successful investigation tonight (mafia found), which would secure a town victory. Then again he could have missed the window to check, since it was a fairly small window and if it is mitch or toad who seem to be on every other day, or every 3rd day it would be assumed that they missed the deadline...

[mtamburini]

Never mind I can see what you are saying now, so what does a cop check on mars do now that he is dead?

The same thing if he was alive. With everyone being relatively new a cop check wouldve been more likely on me based on all the activity that I created on day 1.

And why havent you answered my question why would you think I would die, if you did i must of missed on ive been using my phone to read.

Sorry I forgot to answer why I thought you would be dead, and that is because you were causing a lot of havoc, by scum hunting and it should have made them worried about you catching onto them at some point since you are the most vocal in trying to find them.

As for the cop check on mars it should have happened on night one to help prove either your case being right, or allowing us to move onto another case. The fact that he died means it would be safer to stay quite about his role today so he could hopefully get a successful investigation tonight (mafia found), which would secure a town victory. Then again he could have missed the window to check, since it was a fairly small window and if it is mitch or toad who seem to be on every other day, or every 3rd day it would be assumed that they missed the deadline...

Reasonable but unlikely, dont you think a cop check on me wouldve been much better considering I was going the hardest against him ?

Wouldnt you rather know the allignment of the person pushing on someone than the person who is being pushed on?

[skillfusniper33]

Never mind I can see what you are saying now, so what does a cop check on mars do now that he is dead?

The same thing if he was alive. With everyone being relatively new a cop check wouldve been more likely on me based on all the activity that I created on day 1.

And why havent you answered my question why would you think I would die, if you did i must of missed on ive been using my phone to read.

Sorry I forgot to answer why I thought you would be dead, and that is because you were causing a lot of havoc, by scum hunting and it should have made them worried about you catching onto them at some point since you are the most vocal in trying to find them.

As for the cop check on mars it should have happened on night one to help prove either your case being right, or allowing us to move onto another case. The fact that he died means it would be safer to stay quite about his role today so he could hopefully get a successful investigation tonight (mafia found), which would secure a town victory. Then again he could have missed the window to check, since it was a fairly small window and if it is mitch or toad who seem to be on every other day, or every 3rd day it would be assumed that they missed the deadline...

Reasonable but unlikely, dont you think a cop check on me wouldve been much better considering I was going the hardest against him ?

Wouldnt you rather know the allignment of the person pushing on someone than the person who is being pushed on?

That is hard to say for me, I think it would all come down to the specific case itself, and how things had been going before hand. There are viable cases to look into either side of that case.

Anyway we really need to hear from mitch and toad more in this game.

[Streaker]

@MOD: can you please prod toad and Madmitch?


There is only 1 course of action possible today, and that is lynch Madmitch. There is still reasonable doubt between Toad and sniper, and we cannot afford a mislynch today. I firmly believe Mad to be mafia, and a safe lynch.
We'll just see who get's killed during the night, that will take away doubt as well.

Still waiting on at least a post from toad and Madmitch.

Madmitch, do you have any final words?
Toad, what do you think about the last remaining players?

[Streaker]

Madmitch currently lurking in the forum. Hope he posts anytime soon.

[elonpuckhog]

madmitch and toad1 have been prodded.

[skillfusniper33]

@MOD: can you please prod toad and Madmitch?


There is only 1 course of action possible today, and that is lynch Madmitch. There is still reasonable doubt between Toad and sniper, and we cannot afford a mislynch today. I firmly believe Mad to be mafia, and a safe lynch.
We'll just see who get's killed during the night, that will take away doubt as well.

Still waiting on at least a post from toad and Madmitch.

Madmitch, do you have any final words?
Toad, what do you think about the last remaining players?

I agree with you that madmitch is the lynch today, but if we can I would like more input from them to see if we can gain any info on the final mafia member.

[Streaker]

I agree that they need to post first. They are prodded.

madmitch is lurking AGAIN here, so if he doesnt post by tomorrow morning i'm voting him anyway.

[madmitch]

first off I want to say i am sorry for my abscence,I was all screwed up what to do ,after reading all the statements mtamburini sounds like a cop or someone in charge, always trying to frame someone,or putting the blame on someone else.i am voting [Mtamburini] he is either a cop or someone in charge

[toad1]

I'm sorry I don't post more, but I don't really know what to say. Everyone is certain about Madmitch, so I vote Madmitch

[toad1]

Madmitch in your previous post you never said why you shouldn't be lynched.

[madmitch]

if you kill me who else are you going to gripe at,i am the perfect person to blame the nwe guy in town,well get rid of me and see what happens

[blackdragon1661]

You go to jail is what.

[elonpuckhog]

Would someone be able to tell madmitch how to post in bold? I tried, but I obviously failed.

[madmitch]

VOTE] MTAMBURINI

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Code: Select all

[b]Vote MTam[/b]

To get the Bold, press the B button just above the writing box.

[mtamburini]

if you kill me who else are you going to gripe at,i am the perfect person to blame the nwe guy in town,well get rid of me and see what happens

When we lynch you today who do we lynch tomorrow?

[mtamburini]

Annnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnd hes gone.