[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[charm]

Mtam is literally out of the country on vacation, so I think it is a bit much to expect him to be like oh yeah, HP mafia, better post a ton in that thread.

MTam is back. He asked for a summary.

[StorrZerg]

Mtam is literally out of the country on vacation, so I think it is a bit much to expect him to be like oh yeah, HP mafia, better post a ton in that thread.

MTam is back. He asked for a summary.

he is not back, he posted while on vacation.

[StorrZerg]

aage lets talk about stuff

[MudPuppy]

@mudpuppy why not virus

Sorry, skimming a bit... I see that Strike was still pushing for a virus claim, which I'm also good with. I interpreted his upcoming case on tonkaed as his prime suspect.

[Streaker]

End, did you start the game wandless or were you disarmed? The VT claim is believable to link to that character, but the character would actually fit 3rd party more then town.

[Endgame422]

End, did you start the game wandless or were you disarmed? The VT claim is believable to link to that character, but the character would actually fit 3rd party more then town.

Started wandless.

[Endgame422]

Are we going to pressure someone else today or just lynch me and call it a day?
I dont like the case on virus much and my lone vote on tal does not seem like much pressure to me.
I dont remember the case on HS honestly.
Id be okay with a push on dazza(did i mention that already?)

[dazza2008]

So you think I am scum and voted Ragian as soon as he claimed? Surely if he was my scum buddy I would have believed the claim at least for a while. I get that it was a shit fake claim but I would not have voted so quickly if I was scum.

If you think I have posted nothing creative I probably never will. This is how I play. I vote for who I think is scummy. You also say I just sheep votes. In what way? I was one of the first to vote Pershy and Rage. I voted Endgame today because he was my top suspect. It seems like you read people saying it about the voting on Storr and Mtamb on day 1 and are still just using that shite.

fastposted

[Endgame422]

Glad youve had a laugh at least dazz.
What do you think about the pushes on virus/talapus?
Any interest in either of them?

[Streaker]

So you think I am scum and voted Ragian as soon as he claimed? Surely if he was my scum buddy I would have believed the claim at least for a while. I get that it was a shit fake claim but I would not have voted so quickly if I was scum.

If you think I have posted nothing creative I probably never will. This is how I play. I vote for who I think is scummy. You also say I just sheep votes. In what way? I was one of the first to vote Pershy and Rage. I voted Endgame today because he was my top suspect. It seems like you read people saying it about the voting on Storr and Mtamb on day 1 and are still just using that shite.

fastposted

The first half of your post is just pure WIFOM. You still wanna lynch endgame today? Would you like to lynch him now, or pressure someone else? Who then?

End, what is your case on dazza? I think you'll vote for just about anyone now to escape a lynch.

----------

Now for the case on virus.

Storr starts off with this vote, and a reference to the notes. Tonka insta-wagons without contributing anything else.

It also doesnt hurt mitch that he is Ron who isn't going to get bothered much by the town.

This.

I think we should explore the notes more. It's possible the person mentioned in the note had an interaction with the recipient.

vote virus90

Honestly the push on virus regarding the note is purely role fishing. It's just a nice thing to know with a scum push

That's quite a strange follow-up post to make.

Mitch also blatant wagoning. I was too quick saying virus didn't post enough for me to read, but what mitch is posting surely does beat that.

HotShot also votes virus with a more elaborate post, but the actual case is weaksauce. What he writes about virus' actions is true, but don't hit me as that scummy.

The main case on virus comes from, big surprise, storr:

I can link you many games with virus having fantastic scum hunting. The thing he lacks as a player is the ability to follow up with his suspects and convince others. (likely cause he posts rarely is a large factor) Given that, its quite strange how often he has voted. I think this is one of his more active voting games.

Order of his votes
Madmitch soft claiming ron in his first post (joke vote yes)
Strike Wolf (same post, joke on his name being wolf)
BGtheBrain His first real push. Weak push.
Sempai Sheeps on this vote (lightly defends rage in this post for not knowing flavor) Gives some reads in the post (him not seeing past mtambs stubbornish is odd, he knows better about tambs play. His vote on sempai, is a sheep from town reading streaker.
mtamburini THis vote is bad from virus. Because he is hunting a role, "are you vig" "is the shot limited" "is annoyed by mtambs threats" Yet how is this different from any other game...
mudpuppy I really dont understand his push on mudpuppy. its not even a case, just i'd like to vote him
ENd of day 1

Skillfullsniper Strangely this vote comes in pretty late into day 2. He has no other input since then, and had decided to not make a new case, and instead pick from one of the ones present, so he follows strike on skill.

End of day 2

NO vote day 3 or 4.

Main thing here is meta (how he can scumhunt when town in other games). I also like the remark on number of times he's voted. Sheeping is the other main issue. So meta and sheeping.

I like my case on talapus over virus simply because it has better points then meta in it. If virus is pushed it's over meta (and for good reason, because even when he posted that long ass post, it still contained nothing).

FP'd end

[Streaker]

So with a claim from end, one that seems plausible and fortified by dobby being VT as well, i'm going back to my main lead today.

Unvote, vote Talapus

[StorrZerg]

Streaker your power last night would swap dd5 and whom ever you targeted last night?
or doe sit revert back to 0, having to target 2 consecutive people

[Streaker]

Streaker your power last night would swap dd5 and whom ever you targeted last night?
or doe sit revert back to 0, having to target 2 consecutive people

No it takes 2 nights again. I targeted hotshot last night, but it failed. I did not get confirmation that it was me that was blocked or something, or hotshot. I am trying again tonight.

[StorrZerg]

Interesting that you would get notification that it failed.

Mtamb suggested that voldemort could not be hit by night actions till he himself died. Why are you not looking into pushing hotshot like a mad man today?

[StorrZerg]

So while you defend virus more by attacking meta, could you throw in some content about virus himself? You still have refused to take a stance on his actions.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

Endgame - sempai, dd, Daz, Talapus, charm
virus - Storr, mitch, HotShot, Streaker
tonka - MudPuppy
Talapus - Endgame

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[Streaker]

I am not sure what mtamb exactly meant about the night actions.

Unvote
Vote Pershy
WTF - Why would you start the game that way if you were HP?

Explain how your play has been better than mine.

He wasn't forced to claim - you were.

Says the guy with admits to only playing one game

Info I can bring to the town, I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions (probably means night vigi shots) As long as Im alive Voldemort can only be lynched. Keep that in mind if there is another vigi whos shot does not go through it may not be because there was a medic save or a protection role and could just be voldemort you attacked.

I make of this that mtamb cannot be nightkilled, until voldemort is dead.
Going flavour here, it would make most sense if this goes both ways.

I might have been blocked. He might have been blocked. I shall indulge storr tomorrow by posting what I like and dislike myself about him.
In the meantime, storr, feel free to pressure the players who refuse to step up and explain their votes.

How do you explain the contradiction you posted (my previous post) about the rolefishing?

Coming back to that claim from mtam regarding night actions, it was stated very unclear:
' I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions'.
Cannot compute that sentence.

[got tonkaed]

Just seems like a flavor way for the mod to make Harry Bulletproof.

[StorrZerg]

Difference between cannot and will not.

Mafia will not target tamb. Be broken as f*ck if only way to kill tambo is lynch.

[StorrZerg]

Him being blocked doesn't stop your power wtf are you spewing bs for. Jail maybe. But you did say that

[got tonkaed]

Him being blocked doesn't stop your power wtf are you spewing bs for. Jail maybe. But you did say that

Page 1 says the busdriver can get blocked.

[StorrZerg]

Streaker your power last night would swap dd5 and whom ever you targeted last night?
or doe sit revert back to 0, having to target 2 consecutive people

No it takes 2 nights again. I targeted hotshot last night, but it failed. I did not get confirmation that it was me that was blocked or something, or hotshot. I am trying again tonight.

I dont understand your contradiction in this post or the previous one.

@tonked. He isn't bus driving this night, he claimed hotshot was possibly blocked preventing his action as a possibility

[Streaker]

Go look at what I posted. You wanted to look into the notes, used it as your main reason in that post to vote virus.

Next post or second next says the push on virus regarding the note is pure rolefishing. so either you are contradicting yourself, or you are admitting to rolefishing.

[Endgame422]

Streaker if i were desperate to save myself i would be pushing virus. I dont see much of a case on him right now but he has the same amount of votes as i do atm so i think hes the easy target but not the best one.
My thoughts against dazza are his defense of pix makes zero sense to me. He says pix always plays like this and would rather be lynched than have us lynch pix. Thats some serious commitment over an essentially meta town read and it just does not add up to me.
I would not die for another player unless they were confirmed and more powerful than I was. Pix is not confirmed(we are taking him at his word) and is yet to save anyone as far as i can tell.
Case on tal is largely based on his attempt to find the real dumbledore and his softdefense of rage yesterday.
Probably the best case we have currently and i would rather get a claim from tal rather then a claim from virus.

[StorrZerg]

Go look at what I posted. You wanted to look into the notes, used it as your main reason in that post to vote virus.

Next post or second next says the push on virus regarding the note is pure rolefishing. so either you are contradicting yourself, or you are admitting to rolefishing.

I'm not contradicting myself I made an observational comment regarding that reason.
I found virus scummy before the note. Their is information to be had with a virus claim in relation to the note. Pushing that only is role fishing.

You spat at me for defending end, yet town read him after the claim. Actually defend virus actions please instead of only talking about my accusation.