[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[StorrZerg]

my friends and I survived another night ,thank god, but we lost sempi and that is terrible

Claim plz

[strike wolf]

Yeah I should have followed my gut on Tal yesterday and asserted that he was probably town but logic was going against what my gut was telling me.

1. Strike wolf v2.0-Remus Lupin-town mason
2. StorrZerg-claimed third party survivor.
3. Marashu-claimed Hermione Granger-town doctor
4. got tonkaed-claimed Luna Lovegood-VT
5. mtamburini-Claimed Harry Potter
6. Endgame422-claimed Mundungus Fletcher (right?)-Vt
7. Streaker-Proffessor Flitwick-Weird two night busdriver role.
8. aage-Horace Slughorn-Vt
9. virus90-Neville Longbottom-VT
10. madmitch-Ron Weasley-hasn't claimed role. Hints have suggested something that could backfire and/or inventor type role
11. dazza2008-Unclaimed I think
12. MudPuppy-Madame Pomfrey-Variation on doctor (wand missing)
13. HotShot53-unclaimed I think
14. dd515087-Hagrid-VT (yes this is the claim I thought he was hinting at).
15. charm-unclaimed. Hinted at wand being misplaced?

Here's the thing. I would think just from the sheer number at least 2 of the claimed VTs are lying. THis would be a relatively easy lie to get away with now that Degaston is dead and cannot counter claim anyone saying they have no wand. My case on GT is weakened considering that much of it was based on him going into hard town reads onto now proven townies with flimsy support as to why and at least one of those cases can indeed be explained by his claim. I will reevaluate a little but I still don't fully trust him or anyone claiming Vt right now.

[got tonkaed]

I think if we are assuming the disarm-er is a mafia ability it might stand to try and figure out who would have targeted charm or Mudpuppy in consecutive nights. Presumably charm isn't mafia if her vote was stolen, but those seem like odd targets considering neither player was super prominent.

[strike wolf]

I am not sure that the disarmer is scum though. Charm was considered to be possibly mafia when it seemed that she was disarmed and Mudpuppy was suspected by a few and thought to be town by fewer early on.

So if Marashu is the town doc (we need to hear from him today and see what he says) it would seem that someone saved our Hermione (with Mudpuppy's wand?), I still feel as Storr suggested we should get whoever (if any) were poisoned tonight to step forward.

[strike wolf]

ebwop: Important note. Keep in mind that claiming to have been poisoned does not prove the player to be non-mafia. We still don't even have it guaranteed that mafia has that ability or that they can use it every night (and unless a poison doc hit correctly two nights in a row or the action was otherwise prevented that seems unlikely).

[dazza2008]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

[got tonkaed]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

Yeah I would post what you have.

[got tonkaed]

EBWOP, sorry did not read very well. I am for your waiting until everyone says who they are. That makes sense to me, I guess I was just worried you were not going to post in the day phase for some odd reason.

[StorrZerg]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

Explain details of your role.

Do you visit said person?

Claim all choices you made and why. Save for last night

[strike wolf]

More or less what Storr and GT suggested. We shouldn't hear who you visited last night just yet. It may not make a difference but there is little to no reason to reveal it just yet.

[Marashu]

Wow, I'm really surprised to be alive. On the other hand, I think I know now that Cruciatus is not the poison. It seems to be the roleblock - I targeted sempai last night, and was hit by the cruciatus curse again last night.

[StorrZerg]

General statement. can anyone who has a role that has had actions used. Please go into detail about what happened Each night. maybe something like

Night 1, I did this to X person because THis person is a poo poo face idc.
Night 2 i Did this to Y person, because they gave me a cookie, how ever my action was blocked etc.

Point being, all the half claims lacking information, we dont need to go about hounding shit for 4 days getting everything collected.

[Marashu]

General statement. can anyone who has a role that has had actions used. Please go into detail about what happened Each night. maybe something like

Night 1, I did this to X person because THis person is a poo poo face idc.
Night 2 i Did this to Y person, because they gave me a cookie, how ever my action was blocked etc.

Point being, all the half claims lacking information, we dont need to go about hounding shit for 4 days getting everything collected.

I can't say why Pix did what Pix did, but I can explain myself for my night action.

Night 4: I used Protego on sempaispellcheck. I was split between 3 people (withholding names because the other two are, obviously, still alive and potential candidates for tonight). sempai was my #1 pick because Tal said he thought we were dangerously close to being minority, and the double voter is more potent the closer we get to that, on top of being a very solid town player. I later was informed I was struck by the Cruciatus curse, and sempai is dead, which leads me to believe that it blocked my action.

[Marashu]

EBWOP:
Here are Pix' actions for ease of reference
N1 - mtam
N2 - degaston
N3 - Storr

[aage]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

Like Storr said post your previous choices and why, I don't see how it matters if you reveal who you targeted last night but apparently other ppl have good reasons.
Just to be clear, your role PM states "professor"?

Marashu's report is strange. If the Cruciatus curse is poison, there is no point in targeting him twice... Roleblock does actually make more sense considering Sempai wasn't saved.

Mudpuppy can you give a list of your night actions including last night? Did the notification about your wand say whether you get it back?


Some speculation. Mtam being Harry Potter and Expelliarmus being the signature spell of Harry Potter could mean he is disarming people.

[aage]

10. madmitch-Ron Weasley-hasn't claimed role. Hints have suggested something that could backfire and/or inventor type role
13. HotShot53-unclaimed I think
15. charm-unclaimed. Hinted at wand being misplaced?

We need full claims from these three people.

[madmitch]

you know my claim,you know I have a wand and you know I do not like to use it because I always screw up ,now get everyone else to claim so we can find the real VT,s

[aage]

you know my claim,you know I have a wand and you know I do not like to use it because I always screw up ,now get everyone else to claim so we can find the real VT,s

What is your ability called and what does it do? (I'm assuming you have one...)

[got tonkaed]

What spell are you able to use with your wand?

[MudPuppy]

N1: I cast Episkey on Mtambo (Harry Potter) because he's the boy who lived;
N2: I tried to cast spell on degaston because he claimed cop but was told wand was lost and couldn't.
N3: Requested to cast spell on deg if I stumbled across my wand... but it didn't happen.
N4: Didn't try to cast without wand

Mudpuppy can you give a list of your night actions including last night? Did the notification about your wand say whether you get it back?

Initial notification said nothing of the sort but mod later clarified that it was possible to get it back... I'm guessing if the person who took it dies???

[StorrZerg]

you know my claim,you know I have a wand and you know I do not like to use it because I always screw up ,now get everyone else to claim so we can find the real VT,s

Vote Madmitch

Nope that is not acceptable

[charm]

I'm the Trolly Witch. town
I was able to give one player a piece of candy that would do whatever I want.
My plan was to determine who was mafia and then cast a spell on candy that would make them throw up slugs if they were mafia or do something else if they were town or cult. Well that was my thought anyways. It's moot now. My wand was stolen 2 nights ago and I still don't have it back. Mod won't confirm if or how I get it back.

[StorrZerg]

I'm the Trolly Witch. town
I was able to give one player a piece of candy that would do whatever I want.
My plan was to determine who was mafia and then cast a spell on candy that would make them throw up slugs if they were mafia or do something else if they were town or cult. Well that was my thought anyways. It's moot now. My wand was stolen 2 nights ago and I still don't have it back. Mod won't confirm if or how I get it back.

Can you please describe your power in mafia terms?
additionally, who did you cast it on when you still had your wand

[StorrZerg]

additionally any reason your name is misspelled charm

[Marashu]

10. madmitch-Ron Weasley-hasn't claimed role. Hints have suggested something that could backfire and/or inventor type role
13. HotShot53-unclaimed I think
15. charm-unclaimed. Hinted at wand being misplaced?

We need full claims from these three people.

I'm especially interested in what HotShot has to say. Streaker's weird bus thing failed N3, when I was hit with Cruciatus. If that is the roleblock, which I am inclined to believe, then there must be something else that caused it to fail.