[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[Streaker]

in game term I can levitate objects,which is not much fucking good in this game that is why I have been trying to ignore everyone questions,so if you must jump on the band wagon go a head kill me and the scum are closing in on the win

Stop evading the friggin questions. You claimed to have 4 different powers, and now you claim only 1.
Also what happened to your 'good luck potion' that you claimed? No mention of it now?

Ugh don't know if you just don't know what you are doing, or if you are purposefully doing this...
1 more time

CLAIM:
-All your spells or other abilities by name and action
-All your actions per night phase and result if any

I targeted HS again. It didn't fail this time.

Did Mudpuppy ever claim what exactly he can cure? It doesn't make sense that the poison failed, but he can't perform his action. The only other claimed doc didn't self-protect so that couldn't be it.
With what we have so far, this claim seems most unreliable seeing there isn't a single thing his power actually does.
Could easily be a fake claim (no main character, and a power that sounds strong but isn't, and now conveniently cannot be proven).
Actually second most unreliable after mitch.

[Streaker]

The amount of sheeping is too damn high... and I just looked at his last 10-15 posts for this.
Another thing that stands out is his half-pushing of Storr, but never commits to it. He also manages to vote storr, and unvote immediately after.

Spoiler

I think town could use a leader to get something done... and, Strike, I'm looking at you to be that lead. While not fully confirmed, you are the closest we have to a validated townie based largely on the mason thing but also on my read of you and BG. You are also a respected veteran mafia player whose lead I think many will follow.

So, who do you think we need to be going after today?

My opinion on Storr is "Play me once, shame on you; play me twice...." That's not to say I would ignore that message he supposedly got last night or any other potential leads he may offer. It was definitely worth getting the claim from Streaker... but I'm pretty skeptical of anything Storr spouts out these days.

but the scum are working too hard to create distractions.

Can we force dd5 claim before rage lynch?

Nice try!

As I said before, I'm quite skeptical of Storr. I'm also on board a ragian lynch today... but I have to agree with Storr in the sense that we shouldn't rush it. Though we clearly need a claim from you, rage. I'm also not saying the other push should be dd but I do think it would be helpful to push at least one other button besides rage.

fp'd by Storr, semp, Storr, Ep

Gonna sheep my good friend and buddy ol' town-pal; Strike's pending case on tonka. Us townies need to stick together.
'Cause if strike is town, then I'm certainly town too... since I'm his pal and all.

Anyway, hitting the road in a few... should be able to check back tonight. 'Til then, Vote got tonkaed.

@mudpuppy why not virus

Sorry, skimming a bit... I see that Strike was still pushing for a virus claim, which I'm also good with. I interpreted his upcoming case on tonkaed as his prime suspect.

Looking up flavour of his spell, all I find is that it cures things like broken bones (noses, toes).

Vote mudpuppy

[dd515087]

okay you want the truth my spell is WINGARDIUM LEVIOSA .If you seen the movies or read the books you know that is my favorite spell and the only one I can do properly

Yes anyone who has read the books or watched the movies knows this spell. No it is not your spell, you actually break your wand trying to do it. Hermione was the only one who could do it properly. STOP trying to "flavor your way out" of any situation that casts a bad light on you.

in game term I can levitate objects,which is not much fucking good in this game that is why I have been trying to ignore everyone questions,so if you must jump on the band wagon go a head kill me and the scum are closing in on the win

You can "levitate objects" that isn't a role in mafia...

I want to lynch mitch. My vote stays.

[dd515087]

The amount of sheeping is too damn high... and I just looked at his last 10-15 posts for this.
Another thing that stands out is his half-pushing of Storr, but never commits to it. He also manages to vote storr, and unvote immediately after.

Spoiler

I think town could use a leader to get something done... and, Strike, I'm looking at you to be that lead. While not fully confirmed, you are the closest we have to a validated townie based largely on the mason thing but also on my read of you and BG. You are also a respected veteran mafia player whose lead I think many will follow.

So, who do you think we need to be going after today?

My opinion on Storr is "Play me once, shame on you; play me twice...." That's not to say I would ignore that message he supposedly got last night or any other potential leads he may offer. It was definitely worth getting the claim from Streaker... but I'm pretty skeptical of anything Storr spouts out these days.

but the scum are working too hard to create distractions.

Can we force dd5 claim before rage lynch?

Nice try!

As I said before, I'm quite skeptical of Storr. I'm also on board a ragian lynch today... but I have to agree with Storr in the sense that we shouldn't rush it. Though we clearly need a claim from you, rage. I'm also not saying the other push should be dd but I do think it would be helpful to push at least one other button besides rage.

fp'd by Storr, semp, Storr, Ep

Gonna sheep my good friend and buddy ol' town-pal; Strike's pending case on tonka. Us townies need to stick together.
'Cause if strike is town, then I'm certainly town too... since I'm his pal and all.

Anyway, hitting the road in a few... should be able to check back tonight. 'Til then, Vote got tonkaed.

@mudpuppy why not virus

Sorry, skimming a bit... I see that Strike was still pushing for a virus claim, which I'm also good with. I interpreted his upcoming case on tonkaed as his prime suspect.

Looking up flavour of his spell, all I find is that it cures things like broken bones (noses, toes).

Vote mudpuppy

I disagree with you on MudPuppy. BUT you did quote something that got my attention.... Storr wanted to get me to claim before the Rage lynch. He also asked me if I had a wand or not last day phase. I know that he is claimed non-town but I have a feeling that he is not just a "survivor" as he claims to be.

[dazza2008]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

Like Storr said post your previous choices and why, I don't see how it matters if you reveal who you targeted last night but apparently other ppl have good reasons.
Just to be clear, your role PM states "professor"?

Yes it states professor. Why?

N1 I chose Endgame. I was most suspicious of him. Not based on a mega lot but it was night 1.
N2 I chose Wing. He never seemed mega scummy but something made me chose him.
N3 I chose aage. Not mega scummy again but was my choice.

My thinking nights 2 and 3 were that the person could be scum but if not we had a good player who was cleared and could lead.

[dazza2008]

Professor Sybill Trelawney – Each night I can cast Aparecium to learn their role, identity and alignment. I do not recieve a result but if I die the last person I successfully cast the spell on will be revealed.

Shall I post who I chose or wait? I always think it is best to fully claim but don't know if waiting to reveal it might be better. I will go with what the majority thinks best.

Explain details of your role.

Do you visit said person?

Claim all choices you made and why. Save for last night

I thought I claimed the details. I don't know if I visit the person. I can ask the mod and let you know after work tonight.

What other details are required? All I know is what I posted. I don't recieve a result but if I am killed the last person I successfully cast the spell on is revealed.

[Streaker]

What are you disagreeing with?
A mass claim without investigating the actual claims is worth nothing. As it stands (for me at least), MP's claim is the least likely.
I don't consider mitch as unlikely yet, until he has actually claimed.

FP'd by daz

[madmitch]

@DD yes I broke my first want trying to levitate the troll,but with my new wand I managed to levitate a twig to prod a knot of the whomping willow to allow Harry and Herione to enter the shrieking shack to streaker I used what was left of felix felicis the good luck potion on myself that is why I am still here so far,as for theprotego spell the shield charm I have not needed to use it yet,I only two I TRUST RIGHT NOW ARE MY MATES and so far they don,t seem to need my help yet.

[Streaker]

@DD yes I broke my first want trying to levitate the troll,but with my new wand I managed to levitate a twig to prod a knot of the whomping willow to allow Harry and Herione to enter the shrieking shack to streaker I used what was left of felix felicis the good luck potion on myself that is why I am still here so far,as for theprotego spell the shield charm I have not needed to use it yet,I only two I TRUST RIGHT NOW ARE MY MATES and so far they don,t seem to need my help yet.

What was unclear with the list I provided you to claim?

[dd515087]

RN I want either a mitch lynch or a storr lynch

[aage]

There are so many things wrong with Mitch's claim...
- Protego is hermione's claimed spell;
- Another "joat";
- Claimed joat, then claimed only one useless spell which does nothing;
- Ron's wand broke when he crashed the car into the Willow, not when they fought the troll.

If his wand loss is supposed flavour related, it doesn't make sense.

[aage]

We've had everyone claim now. I will also vote Mitch per the previous post. Interestingly, nobody claimed to be Dumbledore this time. It's very possible that Dumbledore was a fake claim. If it was, Ragian did a nice job of wrecking that

[aage]

a) Disarming
b) Roleblocking the BD
c) Busdriving
d) roleblocking
e) most powers (investigations, protections etc)
f) recruitments
g) kills

Disregarding HotShot's kinda-busdrive, nobody claimed to be an actual busdriver. Makes me doubt whether all these powers are really in the game. (specifically, recruitment.)

[virus90]

i think mitch is a valid lynch, im havent been sure on his claim for a while. and realy flavour is fun, but i would be dead serious if i were him now cause his ass is on the line.
8 of june:

as for which possible fake claims to follow i do agree that madmitch is a possibility. no skill is really claimed and he is only posting flavour, in this flavour he is claiming "no wand" no ability, so in my opinion a valid target.

2nd of june

But i think its clear that we have to lynch Ragian, there are inconsistensies and mistakes (checking storr n1?) in his play, besides i guess we have to start flipping even the roles we all think that are town, (dumbledore, ron hermione, harry?) im not saying that we should kill them all. no thats not what i mean at all. i mean; im afraid that the mod gave very decent fake claims, so far the flips seem to make sense alignement wise, but lets be honest, Minerva McGonagall flipping scum would be weird.

so far we have claimed:
Harry, Ron, Hermione, Dumbledore, Madeye moody, Filch, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Flitwick. Lupin. and i probably missed a claim.
dead: Fudge, Snape, Dobby, Tonks, Minerva McGonagall.
i can think of many more people who would be probable Pro-harry, Sirius, whole weasley family, Neville, Luna, whole group of his, Hagrid other teachers.
thus i woulndt be surprised if mafia had strong fake claims and i am afraid we only find out by flipping some of them, for some reason all of the claims so far havent been flipped yet, which makes me believe some are fake aswell. i mean mafia not going after Harry, Ron, Hermione, mad eye? i understand that your afraid of protections as scum but this just seems a bit too strange.

so to conclude i gladly join the vote on Ragian.
As for others then the obvious, im not sold on talapus and madmitch,
madmitch being ron should have offered more then a name claim and then just jump on some bandwagons, i got the feeling he is new but he is not acting like an important town character in fact he hasnt said much at all besides flavour wise indicating who he is.

also day 1 madmitch was still voting mtam when he already claimed HP.

its enough for me:
vote madmitch

[virus90]

oh and dazzas role is damn useless. we only know if he is speaking the truth by lynching him, since mafia obviously wouldnt do that, especially now.

[Streaker]

a) Disarming
b) Roleblocking the BD
c) Busdriving
d) roleblocking
e) most powers (investigations, protections etc)
f) recruitments
g) kills

Disregarding HotShot's kinda-busdrive, nobody claimed to be an actual busdriver. Makes me doubt whether all these powers are really in the game. (specifically, recruitment.)

I claimed busdriver. Did you forget?
Your point about recruitment is moot, because nobody is ever going to claim they are the recruiter. If there is one, it's most likely somewhere in the VT pool. We've also not had a disarm-ability claim.

FP'd by virus

[virus90]

i think the list is there to be clear on order to make sure thats never a matter of debate in the end as to who would win the game. i dont have any clue of a cult yet. and i think we shouldnt worry to much at this point. in my view this is not a list as to which characters there are but a list of rules, think we shouldnt focus to much on it.

[Streaker]

Virus brings mitch to L-2. Mitch claim now or never.
Switching my vote if I don't see you give us what everyone is asking. You have literally contributed 0 content to town, and are wasting our time now (while still not contributing).

FP'd by virus again.

[virus90]

unvote
didnt know we where at l2 already,
thats a bit to close to my likign this early in the day. some more discussion is good.
but let it be clear that i am very willing to put you right back at that spot, or L1 or even lynch. cause i dont see much contribution throughout the game.

[Marashu]

CLAIM:
-All your spells or other abilities by name and action
-All your actions per night phase and result if any

Same to you, though. You said who you targeted last night, but what about other nights? And what exactly does your thing do?

I'm trying to make a meta read on madmitch right now (if such a thing is even possible). I believe that he is aware of how out there his posts are, and that his tendency to flavour post is intentional. I also know that he can bluff claims in his ramblings, but can be clear on a role claim if necessary. He will switch his vote if a good argument can be made for doing so. When mafia, he has gone straight for the kill without being subtle about it, but a part of me feels like he has learned some discression. If he was stubborn about voting for mtam after the HP claim, and if he's waffling around so much with his claim (wandless, then broken wand with many spells including mine), then I feel like this is closer to his scum play than his town play. Why do you say you're still here so far because of the luck potion? If you trust your mates, wouldn't protego have been good to use on me when you were convinced I was going to die because of the cruciatus curse? Mitch, show some Gryffindor courage and just be specific with what you are doing in-game.

I don't want a mitch lynch right away. We need more discussion, and I don't want to be rushed to night already even if we do hit scum. Feels like we're being "distracteacted".

[StorrZerg]

googling rons favorite spell just leads me to a mass of sexy fan fics lol

[StorrZerg]

be interested in the similarities of Mrash vs MP claims.

Did marsh claim what spell he uses?

[Streaker]

Mars, I have already claimed all of my actions and results. I don't actually expect you have carefully read every single post, so here it is again:

Honestly I have no clue about the note... But I think it's best if I just do a full claim right now.

I am Professor Filius Fitwick.
Each night, I may target a player and use Confundus on him. When 2 players are targeted, they will direct their (if any) actions on each other the night of the second confundo.

Without the flavour, it works as a busdriver but each second night (I targeted storr N1, and I targeted DD N2).

Seeing as how Storr got that message, it is possible that DD sent it to him, but not confirmed. It also explains my apparently bad build up case on DD. I was hoping to trap him with it later in the day.

FP'd storr twice. I'm not a snake, I have a wand.

To clarify, I have to target 1 player each night. Once 2 players are 'under my spell', they direct their actions towards one another. Then I have to begin all over. I targeted Hotshot N3, which failed. Again on N4, which didn't fail.
As far as I know, it's a regular busdrive action but limited to the target's outgoing actions. I'm not withholding this information, I have stated all of this on D3.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

madmitch - Storr, dd, Endgame, HotShot, aage, Strikewolf (L-2)
MudPuppy - Streaker

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

[Streaker]

Epi, I think strike hasn't voted yet.