strike wolf wrote:1. StorrZerg claim: Filch wandless survivor. (disarmed n1) Read: Still appears to be what he said he is. Slight possibility of scum. No possibility of being town.
2. Marashu Claim: Hermione Granger-Town Doctor. Spell Protego Read: I believe Marashu. We are a little short on protective roles for a game this size and unless the poison ability died with Ragian he is definitely not scum.
3. got tonkaed Claim: Luna Lovegood-Formerly wandless VT; now has a wand he can't use. Read: I think he's scum. Given the information I have regarding picked up wands, it does not make much sense for him not to be able to use it. VT does fit with his behavior on the Skillfu lynch. Not so much on the Sempai lynch.
4. mtamburini Claim: Confirmed as Harry Potter
5. Endgame422 Claim: Mundungus Fletcher-wandless VT Read: I am leaning scum with him. He bandwagoned most of the game and still doesn't appear to be contributing much original thought.
6. Streaker Claim: Professor Flitwick. Weird 2 night busdriver role. Read: Neutral. I could easily talk myself either way right now but the truth is I don't have a good read on Streaker.
7. aage Claim: Horace Slughorn-wandless VT Read: Slight scum read at this point. I didn't like either his or Streaker's push on Mudpuppy. I liked his early play for the most part but he has been involved in strong pushes against multiple townie cases. Buddying up to Storr could have been a move to get one of the more vocal voices to tread away from him.
8. virus90 claim: Neville Longbottom-Wandless VT Read: I am going to go slight town here. It is possible he miscounted the votes and was trying to pull a fast one where Madmitch was mislynched and his "unvote" was meant to be taken as a town backing off but not realizing it was too late but that's kind of WIFOMy and partially depends on Madmitch being town. Seemed to forget about the secret vote at one point in the day. Possibly means he's not mafia but not as strong of a tell as it was yesterday with Storr
9. madmitch Claim: Ron Weasley-Back up doctor. Read: I've pretty much given up any attempts to read Mitch today. If you guys want to do it. be my guest.
10. dazza2008 Claim: Proffessor Trelawney-Wanded Death seer (person she visited has alignment revealed on death). Read: Neutral. I actually find the claim somewhat believable but after a quick skim reread, I have renoted him as something of a bandwagoner.
11. MudPuppy Claim-Nurse whatshername. Episkey-specialty doc (wand stolen) Read: He is town.
12. HotShot53 Claim-dudley? wandless VT Read: I am leaning scum. Don't like his claim and have mostly felt he hasn't contributed much throughout the game.
13. dd515087 Claim: Hagrid Wandless VT (disarmed to no effect) Read: I am reading him town. His claim fits and he has not been as blatant as I usually find him when he is scum. Contributed a solid case on Endgame that I feel should be relooked. Failed disarming appears to prove wandless state.
14. charm Claim: Troll(e)y Witch-One shot vig. Penalty death with failure. (wand stolen) Read: Cliam makes no sense in my mind. She is most likely scum. Contributed little to town and defense of what she has contributed was weak.
I am sticking with what I thought for a while now. I think GT and Charm are both scum. If I had to choose one right now, I would say Charm is more likely scum and would be slightly more comfortable with a lynch on her.
For the record, my weakest scum reads would be Hotshot and Aage and therefore by default as much as anything else my strongest after GT and Charm would be Endgame.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
For the record, I am not suggesting that spells aren't inherent into Mafia wands. I think they are and probably that is part of Mtam's use to town with disarming them. I simply think that as someone else stated early on that mafia might be able to exchange wands between them.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:3. got tonkaed Claim: Luna Lovegood-Formerly wandless VT; now has a wand he can't use. Read: I think he's scum. Given the information I have regarding picked up wands, it does not make much sense for him not to be able to use it. VT does fit with his behavior on the Skillfu lynch. Not so much on the Sempai lynch.
psh (j/k). You probably are referring to Talapus not Sempai. I was all about not lynching Sempai. The whole rationale for not jumping on that lynch was basically everyone jumped down his throat for a non-case. i didn't have any info, it just seemed like a pretty silly bandwagon so i fought against it. Turned out I got that one right.
I flavor talked myself into Talapus. I don't really see it as much different than me being stubborn about mtam d1. If anything none of storr, aage or I look super good on that one.
strike wolf wrote:3. got tonkaed Claim: Luna Lovegood-Formerly wandless VT; now has a wand he can't use. Read: I think he's scum. Given the information I have regarding picked up wands, it does not make much sense for him not to be able to use it. VT does fit with his behavior on the Skillfu lynch. Not so much on the Sempai lynch.
psh (j/k). You probably are referring to Talapus not Sempai. I was all about not lynching Sempai. The whole rationale for not jumping on that lynch was basically everyone jumped down his throat for a non-case. i didn't have any info, it just seemed like a pretty silly bandwagon so i fought against it. Turned out I got that one right.
I flavor talked myself into Talapus. I don't really see it as much different than me being stubborn about mtam d1. If anything none of storr, aage or I look super good on that one.
No I meant Sempai. Your Talapus case was a bit of an anomaly but it was after your behavior was noted on other cases so it was possible for you to adapt to fit. so to speak. On Sempai you were ambivalent but mostly pushing for more pressure leading up to the point where he got to lynch-3 and then you switched to a more hard defense of him. That was the behavior that I noted on that lynch.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
StorrZerg wrote:charm why do you have trolly name that isn't even spelled right.... its not even a real name, EVERYONE has a real name, you don't. this doens't add up
Why I didnt notice this til now is beyond stupid on my part
unvote
Waiting for response before I vote
Oh geez! Really??? The Trolley Witch never had a name - I googled her to find out more here http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Trolley_witch . She only appears on the train to Hogwarts!! You guys are really grasping at straws. I have played my character's flavor this whole game. Look back to day 1 and you will see the reference to candy. Throughout the game I referenced sending candy to the misbehaving. Also, the game started on the train to Hogwarts.
StorrZerg wrote:charm why do you have trolly name that isn't even spelled right.... its not even a real name, EVERYONE has a real name, you don't. this doens't add up
Why I didnt notice this til now is beyond stupid on my part
unvote
Waiting for response before I vote
Oh geez! Really??? The Trolley Witch never had a name - I googled her to find out more here http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Trolley_witch . She only appears on the train to Hogwarts!! You guys are really grasping at straws. I have played my character's flavor this whole game. Look back to day 1 and you will see the reference to candy. Throughout the game I referenced sending candy to the misbehaving. Also, the game started on the train to Hogwarts.
Looks like charm is likely to get it today. Ill stick with tonka though. In my mind,his deception about being wandless/not saying he "found" a wand sticks out as scummy to me and im also curious if he were to be lynched where that wand would go.Back to charm or on to another wandless? Also with MP confirmed doc im not liking mitchs claim of 3rd doc. Strike says we are short on protective roles but 3 docs seems like alot to me. Also i still do not like dazza/mars for the connection to rage and their claims. Mars because again 3 docs seems like alot and pixs play from earlier just was terrible and it seems like he should be trying really hard to make up for that. Also the fact that he is the only one to get hit with crucario(misspelled) but has not died(mets did) seems like an easy way to gain town cred. Especially if bellatrix was the one who could cast it and so now its gone but scum can keep claiming to be hit with it. Dazza claim seems like the perfect excuse for him to never be NKd and just seems like a nice neat setup and that always makes me suspicious.
10. dazza2008 Claim: Proffessor Trelawney-Wanded Death seer (person she visited has alignment revealed on death). Read: Neutral. I actually find the claim somewhat believable but after a quick skim reread, I have renoted him as something of a bandwagoner.
Is this really dazza's claim? Doesn't this happen anyway?
dd515087 wrote:10. dazza2008 Claim: Proffessor Trelawney-Wanded Death seer (person she visited has alignment revealed on death). Read: Neutral. I actually find the claim somewhat believable but after a quick skim reread, I have renoted him as something of a bandwagoner.
Is this really dazza's claim? Doesn't this happen anyway?
It shows someone elses alignment. Whoever he cast his spell on,on the previous night. It makes sense flavor wise for that to be her power but it means scum will never kill him.
StorrZerg wrote:charm why do you have trolly name that isn't even spelled right.... its not even a real name, EVERYONE has a real name, you don't. this doens't add up
Why I didnt notice this til now is beyond stupid on my part
unvote
Waiting for response before I vote
Oh geez! Really??? The Trolley Witch never had a name - I googled her to find out more here http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Trolley_witch . She only appears on the train to Hogwarts!! You guys are really grasping at straws. I have played my character's flavor this whole game. Look back to day 1 and you will see the reference to candy. Throughout the game I referenced sending candy to the misbehaving. Also, the game started on the train to Hogwarts.
Why did you miss spell the name
Because I'm human. Because I typed it and didn't cut and paste.
Hey charm would you post your reads/thoughts on everyone before you get lynched? Im thinking its inevitable that your going to get lynched but a list from you would be helpful in any case.
So, who wants to put the hammer on charm? The fact that she's sitting at L-1 and hasn't been hammered, either indicates she really is scum, or all the scum are already on her wagon... and my bet is on the former. So any last words charm?
