[Beginner] Straight Mafia - TOWN WINS

[TimWoodbury]

yh i think the noobies saying no lynch dont realize its worse to no lynch then it is to mislync so im gonna give them a pass and call them town (they will slip up if they are skum)

[madmitch]

unless they know more than they let on? A classic WIFOM

[bosaardbeitje]

Unless they know we know they know... aaah nevermind

[TimWoodbury]

unless they know more than they let on? A classic WIFOM

are you trying to say ur acting as you normally do when you should be acting differantly because you are differant this tie around....

[AladdinSane]

Okay, thanks Mitch and TIm. To the gallows then! Let's also draw and quarter the victim so we can be sure he is dead. If it's good for the town, then I'm right behind the idea. as a right-thinking citizen, I could come to no other conclusion, now that you opened my eyes as to the necessity of lynching. I guess the only question now, is who?

[AladdinSane]

Now I can't wait for lynching day, so we can kill off someone who might be mafia. Better safe than sorry.

[TimWoodbury]

the wh we deicede throughout teh dy going abck and forth saying this person is bad this person is good no that is good and this is bad and eventually 1/2 the players agree on 1 person and hope we get 1 of the right people

[rizky_biznezz]

Not much happening in here ... Thought soldier would have come back to defend himself by now...
Mitch tim did write it was a joke vote against u he just hasn't changed his vote yet..
DJ I was just trying to be friendly.. the new guys tend to make it further because they seem less of a threat than the experienced ones so u came across a little paranoid there noone had even mentioned u as suspicious

[rizky_biznezz]

Not sure that voting for no lynch is all that scummy I was worried about voting for an innocent in my first game so I was hesitant too.. I would think scum would be more interested in pushing us to vote for someone seeing as they know who is scum and can influence us away from them thus getting rid of 2 townies instead of just the nightkill... so not reading too much in to Aladdin but soldiers quick flip is still questionable

[Ragian]

Just back from festival. Will post later today. Just need to sober up.

[the white rose]

the wh we deicede throughout teh dy going abck and forth saying this person is bad this person is good no that is good and this is bad and eventually 1/2 the players agree on 1 person and hope we get 1 of the right people

really finding your posts more and more difficult to understand.....even if you are town, you are not much use to us if we cannot understand you.....therefore vote tim

happy now mitch?

[bosaardbeitje]

Since Soldier hasn't come back yet to explain his reasons for his actions, I am going to unvote vote Soldier. Maybe that will help to get an answer.

[madmitch]

Four , just hope I don't mix up my roles with my games

AND I DID

[AladdinSane]

Not sure that voting for no lynch is all that scummy I was worried about voting for an innocent in my first game so I was hesitant too.. I would think scum would be more interested in pushing us to vote for someone seeing as they know who is scum and can influence us away from them thus getting rid of 2 townies instead of just the nightkill... so not reading too much in to Aladdin but soldiers quick flip is still questionable

You make a good point, risky_biz. Now I'm wavering again. After all, if we lynch someone without being sure they are Mafia, are we any better than them? Still, if they're going to kill us at night, I guess it's a matter of survival. So, yeah, let's lynch someone. I am leaning toward someone who remains silent.

[Soldier4Christ]

sorry, was out of town..i voted for you Tim because you wanted to random lynch and then attacked me for not wanting to. In reality, random lynching day 1 almost always benefits the Mafia. Hence, why I suspect you now.

[Soldier4Christ]

I think its awfully suspicious that TIM went from wanting to random lynch to attacking me for going against it, I say we put up Tim guys. No townie would want to do that.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

mitch - Tim, whiterose*
Tim - Soldier, mitch
Soldier - Bos

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: Thursday at 14:02 pm CCT.

*Whiterose, I didn't move your vote because you didn't unvote.

[madmitch]

Sorry Tim, I missed where you said it was a joke vote so unvote and at this moment I am inclined to vote for I.B. because we have not heard from him and that is scummy. vote I.B.

[the white rose]

*Whiterose, I didn't move your vote because you didn't unvote.

ah sorry, different game, different mod.....unvote vote tim

better now?

[TimWoodbury]

the wh we deicede throughout teh dy going abck and forth saying this person is bad this person is good no that is good and this is bad and eventually 1/2 the players agree on 1 person and hope we get 1 of the right people

really finding your posts more and more difficult to understand.....even if you are town, you are not much use to us if we cannot understand you.....therefore vote tim

happy now mitch?

with 4 active games i am feeling rushed to post in all games often thus the horrid spelling i do appolagize for that and i will work to better the spelling by looking for the red underlines before i hurry up and click submit

[TimWoodbury]

Not sure that voting for no lynch is all that scummy I was worried about voting for an innocent in my first game so I was hesitant too.. I would think scum would be more interested in pushing us to vote for someone seeing as they know who is scum and can influence us away from them thus getting rid of 2 townies instead of just the nightkill... so not reading too much in to Aladdin but soldiers quick flip is still questionable

You make a good point, risky_biz. Now I'm wavering again. After all, if we lynch someone without being sure they are Mafia, are we any better than them? Still, if they're going to kill us at night, I guess it's a matter of survival. So, yeah, let's lynch someone. I am leaning toward someone who remains silent.

we lynch someone because it will give us aim as to where to look at the next day if we no lynch skum gets the kill at night and were left with nowhere to go the following day.
ie if im lynched today if i flip town you look at who did what towards me and such
if im flipped skum you look at who i was staying away from you look at who i was pushing (they would likley be town) and such.

so i hope this clears up why were saying a lynch is best on D1(D1 lynches are 99.999999% of the time "random" ) only once that ive played has sum been caught day 1

[TimWoodbury]

sorry, was out of town..i voted for you Tim because you wanted to random lynch and then attacked me for not wanting to. In reality, random lynching day 1 almost always benefits the Mafia. Hence, why I suspect you now.

look at post i made just up above this reponse will explain it

[TimWoodbury]

I think its awfully suspicious that TIM went from wanting to random lynch to attacking me for going against it, I say we put up Tim guys. No townie would want to do that.

look 2 posts up from this response will explain why i was doing things, (that was a INFORMATIVE post not a kill me to see what i flip post)

[Epitaph1]

[quote="Epitaph1"]VOTE COUNT

mitch - Tim,
Tim - Soldier, whiterose*
Soldier - Bos
Butterfly - mitch

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: Thursday at 14:02 pm CCT.

*thanks

[rizky_biznezz]

i understand why we lynch day 1 i was just saying that i dont think its altogether scummy that the new guys dont want to lynch so not going to base my arguments on that... gotta do a read through again and see if i have missed anything