Mass Effect 1 - Thorian (Cult) Wins!

[benga]

So you are claiming that you are scum? Interesting how you two go along together so fine.

[DoomYoshi]

With logic like that, I'm tempted to vote myself to make this day end.

[Skittles!]

i am REALLY confused by benga's logic. wtf?

[dakky21]

I think Benga's logic is - IF there are 4 scum in the game and 3 of them are dead ... and he jailed Mitch, but the kill still happened means Mitch was not a killer.

[madmitch]

Thank you, FINALLY!!!

[benga]

Thank you, FINALLY!!!

LOL that is my line

who thinks there is 5 or more scum and what are reasons for it?

[Minister Masket]

I think Benga's logic is - IF there are 4 scum in the game and 3 of them are dead ... and he jailed Mitch, but the kill still happened means Mitch was not a killer.

I'm pretty sure the kill happened cause Skoffin was still alive at the start of the night phase. The scene itself seems to back this up.
I'm not voting mitch because I think he's a killer, I'm voting him because I think he's cult.

Scum are basically toothless at this point, and I strongly advise those townies who haven't been turned yet to look very closely at those on yesterday's lynch bandwagon.

[Skittles!]

Thank you, FINALLY!!!

LOL that is my line

who thinks there is 5 or more scum and what are reasons for it?

Did anyone state that they thought there were more than 4 mafia?

[Skoffin]

Vote Count:

(2) Madmitch - (Masket, Doom)
(2) Doom - (Dakky, mitch)

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch!

Last Posted:

1. Ragian ------------- 2 days ago
2. Dakky21 ----------- Under 1 day ago
3. Skittles! ----------- Under 1 day ago
4. Madmitch --------- Under 1 day ago
5. Samlen ------------ 2 days ago
6. Minister Masket -- Under 1 day ago
7. Benga -------------- Under 1 day ago
8. DoomYoshi -------- Under 1 day ago
9. lord voldemort --- 2 days ago
10. TA1LGUNN3R ---- 2 days ago

Deadline set for the 28th of August.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Aye. I was indeed lurking this morning. No new input. Nothing more to say.

It seems I need to decide whether I think mitch-dakky or doom-tails is worse for town.

@Tails, what were you up to last night?

Being a good lil townie.

My internet is not dependable right now, i have to go to the library for access. I'll be able to post Thursday night or Friday. Otherwise spotty.

-Tails

How am I to interpret "being a good lol townie"?

Lil', as in the contraction of 'little'.

-Tails

[dakky21]

And then we have Tails who made 17 posts in 31 page game with 759 posts. Call it lurking or inactivity but I don't like it either way. Tails in all 31 pages voted once for Skitts and no one else (screw the willy-nilly theory), never tried to make a case around anyone and did not contribute anything worthwhile. He said his internet will be "spotty". I'd call that lurking, as he was today here and again didn't said anything of substance (clarifying that "lil" means "little" is an "i'm here" post)

I'm willing to vote him instead of DY if you people agree.

[Skittles!]

And then we have Tails who made 17 posts in 31 page game with 759 posts. Call it lurking or inactivity but I don't like it either way. Tails in all 31 pages voted once for Skitts and no one else (screw the willy-nilly theory), never tried to make a case around anyone and did not contribute anything worthwhile. He said his internet will be "spotty". I'd call that lurking, as he was today here and again didn't said anything of substance (clarifying that "lil" means "little" is an "i'm here" post)

I'm willing to vote him instead of DY if you people agree.

I would have to agree. He's been fairly quiet a lot of the game, except for when he tried to start a bandwagon against me.


MM - two mafia kills, gloated. Thought he was JOAT but the second kill shows that isnt true. town
ragian - pretty quiet, not saying much of anything, but kinda active and different from his usual playstyle. town
LOVO - quiet, and strangely attached to mitch. most of his recent posts have just reiterated the same thing regarding mitch. i think he's town.
mitch - even tho he is erratic, i believe his claim. i think there are more than just 2 vanillas left.
dakky - not 100% sure on this, but his constant harrassing of thorth eventually allowed MM to be sure enough to kill him.

Unsure of -
benga - starting strong on day 2 but has gone quiet since. possible cult imo
doom - not super helpful, possible scum/cult
tails - not super helpful, possible scum/cult
samlen - still not 100% on, but playing similar to how i would play a vt

I'm going to go ahead and Vote Tails. He hasn't helped town at all imo.

[DoomYoshi]

I think Benga's logic is - IF there are 4 scum in the game and 3 of them are dead ... and he jailed Mitch, but the kill still happened means Mitch was not a killer.

I think everybody already understood that. The question was his second post. Where did MM or me admit to being scum?

As MM already said, the case on mitch is that he is cult.

[benga]

I think Benga's logic is - IF there are 4 scum in the game and 3 of them are dead ... and he jailed Mitch, but the kill still happened means Mitch was not a killer.

I think everybody already understood that. The question was his second post. Where did MM or me admit to being scum?

As MM already said, the case on mitch is that he is cult.

when according to you did he turn cult?

and why didn't you vote for him day 3?

when I presented my case of mitch you held back to comeback now and say he is cult?

and you never said you were scum, you just put it as you knew there were more than 4

[Ragian]

I'll have to vote tails. One thing is the stuff you guys mentioned, but he's being deliberately counterproductive to town with his cryptic cryptic answers (and indirectly calling me thick, but I wouldn't hold that against anyone).

[madmitch]

@ MM , Christ you said I was mafia and that was proven wrong and now I am cult ,if I wasn't sure you were town because of your kills I would go after you.So far we have 3 town gone, 3 scum gone and 1 cult gone ,I am not sure what the total amount of scum and cult is compared to town ? How many scum is left? Out of the 10 left I believe along with me we have MM ,benga,skittles ,Rag,and Dakky as town ,that leaves about 4 for scum/cult and we still really don't know what Pika was , I am willing to move my vote if needed

[dakky21]

Since there is no momentum in my case against DY, I'll go ahead and put some more pressure on Tails. Reasons said above.

unvote, vote Tails

[DoomYoshi]

I think Benga's logic is - IF there are 4 scum in the game and 3 of them are dead ... and he jailed Mitch, but the kill still happened means Mitch was not a killer.

I think everybody already understood that. The question was his second post. Where did MM or me admit to being scum?

As MM already said, the case on mitch is that he is cult.

when according to you did he turn cult?

and why didn't you vote for him day 3?

when I presented my case of mitch you held back to comeback now and say he is cult?

and you never said you were scum, you just put it as you knew there were more than 4

I don't know when he turned cult. Day 3 I believed until the end when he used evidence from his past life to hang a real vanilla townie. Did you notice how fast that counterwagon happened? Somebody was really really really trying to save madmitch's life. Why would so many people be willing to save a suspicious vanilla townie over a real vanilla townie? Earlier in day 3 I thought he was just an idiot (because he presented 2 cases both of which were total opposites; if one was true the other couldn't be*) After that speedlynch, there was no doubt in my mind he had to die.

I never said anything about more than 4. You will notice in my list of all the players I wasn't even interested in mafia. I listed everything in terms of cult/non-cult.

*He called me scum for thinking he was town and not voting for him. Let that sink in for the sheer, immense, mind-baffling amount of stupidity. That is the absolute worst case in the history of the game and that's why there is no such thing as an over-reaction to him. a)player a thinks player b is town; b) player a doesn't vote for player b; c) therefore player a is scum. Once this game is done that's going in my signature because it is a wonder of the internet world; a Great Wall of idiocy, a Colossus of illogical thought.
He also called MM scum for thinking he was scum and voting for him. Let that sink in also. a) player c thinks player b is scum; b) player c votes for player b; c) therefore player c is scum.

It's one thing to be an idiot townie but when you are a lying cultist (and possibly cult recruiter) you need to die.

----------------------------------

On another note. I think someone may have recruited Fircoal early and that made Fircoal just have no interest in the game. However, if he was just a vanilla cultist, DDS probably would have let him be slain.

Does anyone know the flavor well? I'm wondering if cult-recruiting is an ability that can be transferred.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

My vote train is cult. Beware anyone voting for me, for it spells endgame or close. Ten players still live, there's probably one scum left. Three nights for recruitment puts cult at four members, minus one killed. Three cult, one scum, six town. If a townie like myself is lynched, and the scum uses his nk erroneously, that makes four cult, three townies, one scum, give or take one in scum/townie column depending on who cult recruits.

-Tails

[Ragian]

Well done, tails. Who is scum? Who is cult? Everyone voting you? Who are you voting for?

@Doom, Strike didn't look town. At all. Calling him "real vanilla town" is weak. You never knew till he flipped.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Well done, tails. Who is scum? Who is cult? Everyone voting you? Who are you voting for?

@Doom, Strike didn't look town. At all. Calling him "real vanilla town" is weak. You never knew till he flipped.

My vote train is cult.

[Minister Masket]

Skittles, I want to know why you think madmitch is town, and not cult.

He's been settling into mafia more successfully recently, surely a return to his old confused ramblings ways is more indicative of him receiving a role he wouldn't be familiar with?

[TA1LGUNN3R]

And then we have Tails who made 17 posts in 31 page game with 759 posts. Call it lurking or inactivity but I don't like it either way. Tails in all 31 pages voted once for Skitts and no one else (screw the willy-nilly theory), never tried to make a case around anyone and did not contribute anything worthwhile. He said his internet will be "spotty". I'd call that lurking, as he was today here and again didn't said anything of substance (clarifying that "lil" means "little" is an "i'm here" post)

I'm willing to vote him instead of DY if you people agree.

I would have to agree. He's been fairly quiet a lot of the game, except for when he tried to start a bandwagon against me.


MM - two mafia kills, gloated. Thought he was JOAT but the second kill shows that isnt true. town
ragian - pretty quiet, not saying much of anything, but kinda active and different from his usual playstyle. town
LOVO - quiet, and strangely attached to mitch. most of his recent posts have just reiterated the same thing regarding mitch. i think he's town.
mitch - even tho he is erratic, i believe his claim. i think there are more than just 2 vanillas left.
dakky - not 100% sure on this, but his constant harrassing of thorth eventually allowed MM to be sure enough to kill him.

Unsure of -
benga - starting strong on day 2 but has gone quiet since. possible cult imo
doom - not super helpful, possible scum/cult
tails - not super helpful, possible scum/cult
samlen - still not 100% on, but playing similar to how i would play a vt

I'm going to go ahead and Vote Tails. He hasn't helped town at all imo.

Pretty specious reasoning, bru. By that logic LoVo is also a candidate for your vote, but methinks he's your cult buddy, so the same rules don't apply, eh?

-Tails

[dakky21]

Well done, tails. Who is scum? Who is cult? Everyone voting you? Who are you voting for?

@Doom, Strike didn't look town. At all. Calling him "real vanilla town" is weak. You never knew till he flipped.

My vote train is cult.

Well Tails if that is so, why don't you present a case so we could move on to someone else?

"everyone who votes me is cult" isn't a case, it's a lol defense.

[DoomYoshi]

Well done, tails. Who is scum? Who is cult? Everyone voting you? Who are you voting for?

@Doom, Strike didn't look town. At all. Calling him "real vanilla town" is weak. You never knew till he flipped.

That doesn't matter. The fact is he is a 100% confirmed vanilla townie. Madmitch isn't.