Dukasaur wrote:The concept has served the Scandinavian nations well.
Adherence to the rule of law is an attitude, not a procedure. The minor details aren't important. What is important is that there is general agreement on the fact that the rule of law matters, and that the government is not above the law. Which, for the most part, is the prevailing attitude in Israel. The people can smell a rat when someone like Nutty tries to cheat.
The courts are also not above the law. The situation in Israel right now is that the Supreme Court can strike down laws, not because they objectively violate the constitution, but because they personally don't think they're reasonable.
- Since the tenure of Aharon Barak as its chief justice, Israel’s highest court has arrogated to itself broad powers to overturn legislation and intervene in various aspects of public life, based only on its evaluation of the “reasonableness” of any particular measure. To David M. Weinberg, the concept of “reasonableness” has become an “authoritarian” tool that “allows high-court justices to apply elastically their own sensibilities; to re-engineer Israeli society—in their enlightened image, of course.”
https://mosaicmagazine.com/picks/israel ... nableness/
If the U.S. Supreme Court invalidates a law it's because that law violates the U.S. constitution or a principle of English Common Law. If the Canadian Supreme Court invalidates a law it's because the law violates the Canadian constitution or a principle of English Common Law. In these cases the court must strike down laws it likes if they violate a legal principle, and uphold laws it hates if they don't.
If the Israeli Supreme Court invalidates a law it's because the court thinks the law is unreasonable based on its own emotions and worldview and no objective criteria. That's the opposite of rule of law. ROL requires neutral objectivity, not emotional subjectivity. "Reasonableness" is a political, not a judicial, question.