joshzam wrote:It's hard to apply any calculation you may have found to our game because we don't know how many Town and how many Scum there are here. Also, calculations just don't usually hold up in Mafia, as it's more of a game of intuition, vibe, and trust. I've never seen a convincing argument to always or never lynch on day 1.
I do find it interesting that there are 23 inmates and 24 in the game. Some sort of special "warden" or "God" role maybe? Could it be third-party? Any thoughts?
There are certainly third-party, some has special win objectives that's stated in the post.
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
I Usually wound't like to lynch in day 1. But I was about to say the same thing, he gave himself away.
The picture shows Château d'If, so maybe it's Edmond Dantès or Abbé Faria.
Text says it's been a museum for 30 years, so maybe a tourist who got left behind, or a museum curator.
As for me, *Not a breadcrumb. Shawshank is my favorite prison movie
Scum doesn't equal Mafia. Scum comes in many forms. But since you were quick to point me out, that shit looks guilty. I vote for YOU then. I vote by hanging
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
I like to kick ass and chew bubble gum and right now I'm out of bubble gum......
As Ragian is deflecting votes off of Dunk90 either they could be in the Cosa nostra together or Rag is Dunks bitch in here.
I say vote Rag and if he's scum then maybe we flush Dunk out too.
If on the other hand they are just cuddling up to each other would be kinda fun to split the lovers apart.
Dunk90 wrote:Scum doesn't equal Mafia. Scum comes in many forms. But since you were quick to point me out, that shit looks guilty. I vote for YOU then. I vote by hanging
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
Is that supposed to be an official vote? It's not in bold red.
I was asking to be guided. I'm new to this game. I saw a bold sentence. GO FORTH AND KILL THE SCUM. I didn't know that meant mafia at that time. I admit, it does looks suspicious. But I assure you, I'm not a mafia member. I wouldn't be that stupid if I was. But I am definitely scum. I got 15 years for arson. If I'm not considered scum, I don't know who is. Just so you know, I'm innocent of those charges. I was in Portland at the time, torching police cars. Oops
i-andrei wrote:
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
Kind of agree with this. Would like to hear what he has to say tough.
I like to kick ass and chew bubble gum and right now I'm out of bubble gum......
Dunk90 wrote:Scum doesn't equal Mafia. Scum comes in many forms. But since you were quick to point me out, that shit looks guilty. I vote for YOU then. I vote by hanging
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
Is that supposed to be an official vote? It's not in bold red.
Dunk90 wrote:I was asking to be guided. I'm new to this game. I saw a bold sentence. GO FORTH AND KILL THE SCUM. I didn't know that meant mafia at that time. I admit, it does looks suspicious. But I assure you, I'm not a mafia member. I wouldn't be that stupid if I was. But I am definitely scum. I got 15 years for arson. If I'm not considered scum, I don't know who is. Just so you know, I'm innocent of those charges. I was in Portland at the time, torching police cars. Oops
i-andrei wrote:
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
Kind of agree with this. Would like to hear what he has to say tough.
"Scum" and "Mafia" are interchangeable terms for the faction that is opposed to "Town". There may also be Cults, or 3rd party players as well.
Saying "But I am definitely scum." could just be a mistake by an inexperienced player, or it could be a Freudian slip, or it could be an attempt to deflect from an earlier mistake. In any case, it doesn't look good.
Dunk90 wrote:I was asking to be guided. I'm new to this game. I saw a bold sentence. GO FORTH AND KILL THE SCUM. I didn't know that meant mafia at that time. I admit, it does looks suspicious. But I assure you, I'm not a mafia member. I wouldn't be that stupid if I was. But I am definitely scum. I got 15 years for arson. If I'm not considered scum, I don't know who is. Just so you know, I'm innocent of those charges. I was in Portland at the time, torching police cars. Oops
i-andrei wrote:
*Pixar* wrote:The only sorta clue I have to go off of is Dunk90 saying "(I don't mind being scum btw)" after roles were released on April 8th. He posted that in signups on April 9th...
In that case I got Vote Dunk90
Kind of agree with this. Would like to hear what he has to say tough.
"Scum" and "Mafia" are interchangeable terms for the faction that is opposed to "Town". There may also be Cults, or 3rd party players as well.
Saying "But I am definitely scum." could just be a mistake by an inexperienced player, or it could be a Freudian slip, or it could be an attempt to deflect from an earlier mistake. In any case, it doesn't look good.
FOS (Finger Of Suspicion) on Dunk
Thanks for explaining that, I didn't realize scum and mafia were equal from the previous comment. I'm going to go for a smoke. I know more but I'm f*cking confused in general at this point. If this shit gets any more weird, I don't even know how to keep up.
TheJMac wrote:I know more but I'm f*cking confused in general at this point. If this shit gets any more weird, I don't even know how to keep up.
The first day is generally chaos. There is little or no concrete evidence to go by, so people tend to pick apart every statement to look for a reason to vote for one person over another.
Be careful what you post. The Preview button is your friend.