I have decided I like Max to go over despite what Rag says. He's right, we can't take any defense or push on him as info because there's no posts of his to attack or defend. Chance that a townie defends town!Max because he's low hanging fruit is as high as a scummie thinking it might get him good boy points. Chance that someone defends scum!Max is also very justifiable because anyone can hide behind the "well there was exactly a random chance that he was scum given that he didnt give us anything".
That being said, I also dont want to get into an endgame where we have to rely on Max to vote correctly or do something. Imagine worst case scenario: overnight both scums kill townies, and we lynched a townie in Max. Is this really worse than being in the same scenario with a townie in Max? We will have this same debate again on whether Max is allowed to live another day.
Town gets a couple lynches this game, I didnt check the previous games but after 2 nights theres likely 4 nightkills UNLESS one scum party gets wiped out n1. Imo a Max lynch satisfies the "always lynch" crowd despite it being a meh lynch as well as a "no lynch" crowd because they also dont want to ask themselves the same questions tomorrow.
SoN!c wrote:Werewolf...Strike Wolf...? Werewolf...Strike Wolf...?? Werewolf...Strike Wolf.. Dang, That sounds waaay too loony tuned to make that stuff up! That's gotta be it!!
unvote
Vote Strike
PS: Strike, if you are not a wolf but the spare Mason, just reveal yourself as spare Mason when you are in danger of being lynched. Nothing to worry then
Son!c votes me...
PepeAtila wrote:
Loose Canon wrote:
PepeAtila wrote:I will wait a little because I have no idea what is the best thing to do, but if most people think we should vote lynch I will do it.
Come on Pepe put forward an argument with reasoning - any argument.
Perhaps you are asking too much... 'an argument with reasoning'' ? sorry it is the charles bad joke effect...
Serious now: I have no clue, but looking for a reason it can be a good option put some fear on strike because of his name and try to get some information from him (L-2) vote Strike
Pepe follows.
SoN!c wrote:OMG wolf pair DDS-Strike admitted it in a way but you didn't see that? sO did DDS in a way And because of that you think im a scum pair with Max??
Roses are red. Violets are blue. Son!cs theories are crazy but we're all crazy too.
I'm not telling that you should change your name, but I guess you and DDS can be a pair (in this game) ... I am not telling who is the wolf and who is "little red riding hood" ... However since I don't see it clear and people are changing ... unvote vote Max
Pepe follows.
SoN!c wrote:At least you guys could have waited a bit on Strike to hear him say he is the spare mason before unvoting
Son!c criticizes people for unvoting me...
PepeAtila wrote:
DirtyDishSoap wrote:Unvote
Its a joke wagon, come on!
I know it was a joke wagon, but why to unvote so fast?
Pepe criticizes DDS for unvoting me.
PepeAtila wrote:well I will see what strike wolf will do ... I guess he is going to unvote, vote DDS
Pepe posts something related to predicting/wifoming my actions...
SoN!c wrote:
Ragian wrote:
SoN!c wrote:With you aboard we now have 3 votes for pushing the deadline, Charle said that it would need a majority so that's 6.. And it's already friday, weekend coming up..
What is your case on Devante exactly? You seem pretty sure about it.
I'm not sure. It's D1. In a nutshell, if you can't be arsed to reread my posts, it's his third vote that was supposed to come off as a joke vote, but the timing was weird and it didn't feel jokey to me + his skimming + his absence apart from telling you about the rules.
Yes i got all of that. Was just wondering if i missed something.. Tell me: if this was an actual case on Strike (for exactly same reasons) don't you think Strike would call this "going down the rabbit hole"? But tempted to follow i'll give you that - the vote on Max is sitting idle anyways and deadline got extended.. I think DDS will hop onboard the Dev train too. He has Dev in his scummy list. That would make it 3 votes fast. And then Strike must follow ofcourse. Not following would read as "look, im no Wuff Wuff pair - im not following DDS!! Everybody sees that? im not following DDS!!" getting Dev on L-2.
English lesson for Pepe: "a rabbit hole" is a metaphor for entering into a situation that is particularly strange and transports the entrant into a wonderfully surreal and fanatical state of mind.
Son!c later posts something trying to predict/wifom my actions. Honestly, I can't say it's not a Pepe thing since I haven't played that much with Pepe and it's been at least a few months but the whole "I predict x will do this" is a Son!c move and he's made similar posts through the game.
Then there's Pepe's list of DDS, me and Max as the three he's most suspicious of which matches Son!c's main three that he'd been pointing to at the time.
So I believe Son!c and Pepe are aligned and know it. So 33.3% Masons +whatever chance you'd give that this is just coincidence vs. 66.7% anti-town-whatever chance you'd give that this is just coincidence.
Vote Son!c
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Lmao! This is exactly what overzealous calling out of an OMGUS vote looks like.. Double OMGUS on me and Pepe. Your unvote on DDS could be seen coming from a mile away.
Then you post this sentence that doesn't make any sense at all:
"So I believe Son!c and Pepe are aligned and know it."
You believe me and Pepe are aligned and we know it?
Lol! This is ridiculous if you think on it for 1 second. A "aligned scumpair that know they are aligned"?? With day-chat? They better huh
Since your OMGUS vote on me that is what your saying here..but It's like you don't even believe this yourself. A little slip up thinking / fishing for the masons at the moment you typed it?
SoN!c wrote:Lmao! This is exactly what overzealous calling out of an OMGUS vote looks like.. Double OMGUS on me and Pepe. Your unvote on DDS could be seen coming from a mile away.
Sure it can be read as OMGus but I don't care about appearances when noting an actual pattern here.
Cool, you and pepe predicted that I would unvote my joke vote. You guys must be super geniuses. /s Implying scum pair from it is disingenuous when I never implied my vote was serious to begin with.
Son!c wrote:Then you post this sentence that doesn't make any sense at all:
"So I believe Son!c and Pepe are aligned and know it."
You believe me and Pepe are aligned and we know it?
Lol! This is ridiculous if you think on it for 1 second. A "aligned scumpair that know they are aligned"?? With day-chat? They better huh
Since your OMGUS vote on me that is what your saying here..but It's like you don't even believe this yourself. A little slip up thinking / fishing for the masons at the moment you typed it?
Yes. I believe you are aligned and know it which is evidence against you being vanilla town who would be aligned but not know it. It doesn't rule out Masons but there are 2 wolves and 2 mafia vs 2 masons who know they are masons so the odds are better for scum. That's the very point I was making that you glossed over there, Son!c. As for "fishing for masons", the possibility that you were masons was the only reason I hesitated to point out how closely Pepe was specifically following you early in the day. If I was scum then I could very easily hold onto all of this and just kill one of you tonight. You flip Mason then Pepe dies the next night.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
SoN!c wrote: If I was scum then I could very easily hold onto all of this and just kill one of you tonight. You flip Mason then Pepe dies the next night.
Think about that. If he was scum he kills me and i flip Mason.. "You flip Mason",.
So your exposing the pair you believe to be the Masons then as "the true townie you are"?
All this doesn't make any sense as town Strike. It feels like you know your already exposed as scum and you know you won't get far anyways.
Unvote
Vote strike wolf
Pretty confident you are gonna flip scum now. No chance left you are a Mason after hearing all this.
Also i wanna add: if you think me and Pepe are scum would we be in sync so much D1 already making it so obvious?? No, its town noticing and town following.. Thats all it is and you very well know that. No town Strike would say this = you are scum.
I wouldn't expect you to follow Pepe sure. You know enough not to connect yourself like that but Pepe isn't as experienced. He could definitely make that mistake and it's mostly been you doing something and him mimicking.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:I wouldn't expect you to follow Pepe sure. You know enough not to connect yourself like that but Pepe isn't as experienced. He could definitely make that mistake and it's mostly been you doing something and him mimicking.
Day-chat. I would tell him what to do. Yes in spanish. Having spanish blood myself and having google translate cabron.
Day chat doesn't guarantee cooperation. Messages can go unread until too late, theyre can be miscommunications even between two native speakers and there can be disagreement. I should know a lot of suggestions made in the last games day chat either went ignored or in the case of the last day, Fusi and Rag outright did the exact opposite of what I suggested.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Look you wanna scummy me as last resort thats great. Great exchange 1 town for 1 scum. That is also the risk you take when digging.. So easy exchange: town lynches you and if you flip town then town can do with me whatever they want. What do you say? Im sure as i was sure in last game on the last 3 scummies: you, rag and Fusi.
You know you are gonna flip scum Strike. Yes or no?
-I really like the DDS/Strike ticket. It's like they feel cornered #HOLYFUCKTHEYMADEUS!!!
-Rags and Loose. They already know I'm town, but they're playing good cop/ bad cop with me; Loose being hellbent on having me lynch, Rags trying to "rescue" me by saying no valuable info would be gathered from that.
So, yeah, my lynch list right now is DDS, Strike, Rags and Loose(in no particular order).
-I really like the DDS/Strike ticket. It's like they feel cornered #HOLYFUCKTHEYMADEUS!!!
-Rags and Loose. They already know I'm town, but they're playing good cop/ bad cop with me; Loose being hellbent on having me lynch, Rags trying to "rescue" me by saying no valuable info would be gathered from that. So, yeah, my lynch list right now is DDS, Strike, Rags and Loose(in no particular order).
Then vote Strike. Strike was here all discussion long. He must have read the "checkmate post" by now when it was going to this climax. But didnt answered.. he must know its checkmate by now but a cornered wolf will jump once more until put down..
So does the wolfdog takes the deal? Yes or no? 1 for 1 should be a no brainer if he is town..
Ps: i think loose and rags are town Max. Also your probably not helping when this is coming from you but its fun anyway. Strike will probably post we are a scumpair now
So im asking town to give another 5 town votes on strike here being pretty sure. Max can wait till tomorrow and Strike initiated all of it himself in case anybody is wondering..100 % sure strike is scum - reread yourself! jajajaaa brothers!
It feels like a lot of absolute statements are being made here that I really don't feel like any town player at this stage should be able to make with conviction. I would agree on Pepe seeming very easily swayed/eager to please, but I don't think that requires a sonic/pepe pair just because he's been the one pepe has generally followed so far? Not hard for a scum player to just try to echo a (potential) town player in hopes of blending in/getting them on their side, fusi was doing that a lot last game.
I will also say that DDS and strike have also been largely similarly aligned, but I honestly haven't really had any huge issues with any one thing they've said or issues with their reasoning thus far. It is potentially worth noting though that while DDS seems to have diverged a bit here from strike, calling it "a bit of a reach", he still does effectively end up supporting the same overarching point/theory anyway. Not making a ton out of that right now, especially given I just pretty much agreed with DDS as well, but wanted to make a note of that.
strikewolf wrote: If I was scum then I could very easily hold onto all of this and just kill one of you tonight. You flip Mason then Pepe dies the next night.
I got the quote wrong last time but these are Strike his own words.
Look he is saying that if i i flip Mason he (as scum) kills Pepe the night after..
2 scummy things here; first he thinks i'll flip Mason..but the other thing is even way more suspicious. Scum Strike knows he will have to hit the other scum team tonight. Scum hitting a Mason N1 is just not the good strategy. The spare Mason will get active..
strikewolf wrote: If I was scum then I could very easily hold onto all of this and just kill one of you tonight. You flip Mason then Pepe dies the next night.
I got the quote wrong last time but these are Strike his own words.
Look he is saying that if i i flip Mason he (as scum) kills Pepe the night after..
2 scummy things here; first he thinks i'll flip Mason..but the other thing is even way more suspicious. Scum Strike knows he will have to hit the other scum team tonight. Scum hitting a Mason N1 is just not the good strategy. The spare Mason will get active..
Strike knows this. So this is a lie.
I was posting a hypothetical scenario where if I was scum I wouldn't make this case but rather kill you at night and then Pepe if you flipped Mason. You should know it, I put it right in the post that youre quoting. And yes, I would kill the second Mason in the scenario where I am scum. Two masons would be a threat. Scum wants as much division in the game as possible. Unaligned town can provide that. The other scum team while risky to keep in the game certainly can help provide that. Two masons who can verify each other to the remaining town does the opposite of that. It's admittedly a bit awkwardly worded as I initially wrote something along the lines of if you had flipped scum or Mason I'd kill pepe the following night but realized that killing Pepe in the second scenario is a bit more circumstantial and I'd be more likely pushing for his lynch during the day and then hopefully not have to consider whether he's the best kill target that night or not.
As far as letting myself be lynched in exchange for Son!c being lynched. I've been pretty open on the record saying that I dont think town should just sit back and let themselves be lynched. Son!c should know this. I said it as recently as the Matrix game which I know he's read. So for him to know it and paint me declining as proof that I'm scum if I don't accept is disingenuous. Furthermore to accept this deal, I would have to feel pretty confident that A. You are scum and B. The rest of town would actually follow through and lynch you the next day. I dont feel 100% confident about either of those.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
'an argument with reasoning'' ? 
