[OFFICIAL] Charle's Fun Mafia - "Game On" Day 4

[Devante]

I'm not so sure on your points on Extreme Loose but open to keep an eye on it more. I had Extreme as likely town trying to help but given he's one of the most experienced players here I wouldn't put it past careful deception as scum so I'll stay on the fence for now. Would have been ok with kingm for a lynch too going right back to the issues that arose from DDS and then his takeover. However right now I am most suspect of Sonic three reasons, one I don't think Sonic and Rag would both have town protective roles given what occurred last night, two Rags offering to have himself lllynched so town hassonic for the target the next day if he flips town had crickets from sonic and a lot of circumventing the back and forth going on, and finally we now have a claim from Rag so unless someone counter claims doc then simply I say

VOTE SONIC

FP Sonic/hjelp

[Loose Canon]

Actually since rag has claimed town doc, sonic you must take your vote off rag asap unless you are going to counterclaim exactly that role.

Other town voting rag should unvoted for safety if nothing else NOW

Actually anything else brings town to verge of losing game town has a very good chance of winning, however clouded that prospect seems right now, to you personally

Fpd by sonic

That is bollocks sonic

Apologies sonic just read the 100 times over bit.

Getting very frustrated that's all - you know I love you playing these games.

Fpd by Devante

Apologies sonic

[SoN!c]

I'm not so sure on your points on Extreme Loose but open to keep an eye on it more. I had Extreme as likely town trying to help but given he's one of the most experienced players here I wouldn't put it past careful deception as scum so I'll stay on the fence for now. Would have been ok with kingm for a lynch too going right back to the issues that arose from DDS and then his takeover. However right now I am most suspect of Sonic three reasons, one I don't think Sonic and Rag would both have town protective roles given what occurred last night, two Rags offering to have himself lllynched so town hassonic for the target the next day if he flips town had crickets from sonic and a lot of circumventing the back and forth going on, and finally we now have a claim from Rag so unless someone counter claims doc then simply I say

VOTE SONIC

FP Sonic/hjelp

Spoiler

[color=#FF0000]Vote wonic[/color]

?

Np wonic will be there

[hjelp]

So is your reasoning when you are the SK. Both kong and darin first votes where on loose canon.. Look im not making myself popular i know but shit needs a dirty harry and that is what i do best.

Regarding Dirty Harry claim.
Do you claim Vigilante Town?

[Extreme Ways]

So is your reasoning when you are the SK. Both kong and darin first votes where on loose canon.. Look im not making myself popular i know but shit needs a dirty harry and that is what i do best.

Regarding Dirty Harry claim.
Do you claim Vigilante Town?

I want to know this as well

[SoN!c]

So is your reasoning when you are the SK. Both kong and darin first votes where on loose canon.. Look im not making myself popular i know but shit needs a dirty harry and that is what i do best.

Regarding Dirty Harry claim.
Do you claim Vigilante Town?

All veteran players including Rag will know what i mean by that. And that is no vigilante if answering your question right

[hjelp]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

[SoN!c]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

[Extreme Ways]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

vote sonic
fwiw I also dont know what you mean

[Devante]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

This makes no sense Sonic. I dont the bread crumbing. You're essentially claiming a power role yet leaving the rest of us that don't get the reference in the dark, unless your fishing for info. If youur claim is valid then I'll unvote you and move elsewhere but this is just making things more confusing

fp ew

[hjelp]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

Unvote Kingm
Vote SoN!c

[hjelp]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

vote sonic
fwiw I also dont know what you mean

I think you have to unvote first if to vote on SoN!c

[Devante]

Charle can we get a vote count please

Let's see where we're at here before jumping to L-1 so Sonic has a chance to clarify what he's saying

[halrob64]

hjelp,
Is my being the town cop still in question? Its time to move on and look for the real villains.

[halrob64]

Devante,
you seem to be an intermittent poster so why don't you get up to speed on what Sonic has been saying, I thought it was quite clear?
Why not come clean about your role

[hjelp]

hjelp,
Is my being the town cop still in question? Its time to move on and look for the real villains.

You are not on my list. I have you as town at the moment.

Also
I'm off to bed.

[Loose Canon]

Before you guys have gone fully down the either of sonic or rag route which I say again has been perpetuated by sonic and rag but driven and egged on by extreme, consider this.

In other games there have been cop reports of guilty on day 2, where the cop is bonafide and the townie is innocent.
These have occurred if mafia at the outset had the powers such as bus driver to take a player to the wrong place, and make the correct educated guess from day1 chat as to who a town cop is most likely to be.
In such cases the townie innocent will almost certainly be mislynched D2 and then suspicions fall back on the cop.

Extreme s genius this game has been to simulate deception and a false guilty must be one of sonic or rag, based on the tools and roles mafia as a whole had to hand.

EXTREME KNEW TOO MUCH.

You'd have almost certainly lynched extreme if there had been a cop report of guilty on extreme - correct?

Well believe me the QUANTITATIVE evidence of guilt on EXTREME here is STRONGER than a guilty cop report.

HE KNEW TOO MUCH

[Loose Canon]

Can't sleep this is playing on my mind.

Jail keeper - one power role down.
Perm 2 of 4 sonic rag Halrob extreme (extreme isn't but I'll include him)
are 2 other power roles bringing town to 3 in total.
Leaves other 2 as mafia out of the four.

Do you think those 2 mafiosi are sonic AND rag - really???
So if one of sonic or rag is town, the other mafia is extreme or Halrob.
And if you can't contemplate it might be Halrob at this point, then it must be extreme.

FFS lynch extreme

[Loose Canon]

Fellow Vanilla townies take note.

It may seem all you have at the start of the game is a number in a vote.

Each of us actually has a lot more than that. We also have the implicit power to think neutrally and prod and question and air theories until we come up with hopefully the truth.

Please follow me in this game - the truth shall set you free - from crime

[chanakam2020]

Fellow Vanilla townies take note.

It may seem all you have at the start of the game is a number in a vote.

Each of us actually has a lot more than that. We also have the implicit power to think neutrally and prod and question and air theories until we come up with hopefully the truth.

Please follow me in this game - the truth shall set you free - from crime

What is the stratergy you suggesting.
Elaborate.

[Loose Canon]

1 Lynch extreme now - he is guilty.

2 One of Halrob sonic and rag is guilty too.
Make best assessment of that after night 2 results.
I actually think the most likely second guilty is Halrob but I don't know that.
I also see - maybe it's just me - accelerated development in Halrob s play in this game. Such acceleration would I think naturally occur best playing mafia with a mafia extreme.


3. Try to keep both claimed town protectives alive as best we can for now. I think they may be both bona fide town protectives and so will slow down the dual threats of mafia and sk

4. You and me Chana, try to subtly evaluate who is more likely of the others to also be vanilla town.
I think you have nodded to me and I have to you.
We can be subtle about this.
Could narrow down the search for third mafia and sk considerably.

[Loose Canon]

Let's call it SEVI Chana.
Search for extra vanilla intelligence.

[chanakam2020]

1 Lynch extreme now - he is guilty.

2 One of Halrob sonic and rag is guilty too.
Make best assessment of that after night 2 results.
I actually think the most likely second guilty is Halrob but I don't know that.
I also see - maybe it's just me - accelerated development in Halrob s play in this game. Such acceleration would I think naturally occur best playing mafia with a mafia extreme.


3. Try to keep both claimed town protectives alive as best we can for now. I think they may be both bona fide town protectives and so will slow down the dual threats of mafia and sk

4. You and me Chana, try to subtly evaluate who is more likely of the others to also be vanilla town.
I think you have nodded to me and I have to you.
We can be subtle about this.
Could narrow down the search for third mafia and sk considerably.

Sound a good plan to me.
But I have to read the thing again and think about possible plot twisters before voting.
Give me some time to think.

[hjelp]

Good Morning

Town couldn't agree about SoN!c either.

Unvote SoN!ic

Anyhow - there is no need for Town to vote on SoN!c since kill-target (EW tracking). Let's leave SoN!c to Mafia or SK.

[Loose Canon]

I'm not a veteran player so what is your answer to me?

Vote me or think.

Unvote Kingm
Vote SoN!c

Sonic could mean one of two things.

Either think it's either me or rags who is mafia, and I know it's not me.
So think - it must be rags.
And I see Halrob has jumped on the either.

Or think, think properly, loose isn't getting any traction, I think he should be so I'm playing with this rags thing to get more reactions to evaluate more mafia and the sk, but actually if you think you will see what I'm trying to do, particularly after I suggested we needed to search for sk.
Or is a much deeper sonic.
It's the one I hope we have.