Nostalgia Mafia ~ Commander wins!

[edocsil]

Humh. That wasn't a good idea.

[Mr. Squirrel]

The boring residents ran around the town frantically. This was, by far, the most interesting day that Boringsville had ever seen. However, one person was running faster and being far less boring than all the other residents. The other members of the town grabbed the poor bloke, tied him to the back of a car, and sent that car off a cliff. Needless to say, he died.

Nagerous (VT) has died!

Night 1 begins!
You have until sunday night to send your actions.

[Mr. Squirrel]

The city's residents woke up the next morning peacefully. The night had been perfectly boring, just how they liked it. Many of the residents wanted to return to their normal lives, now that boringness had returned to Boringsville, but a small group of 6 people decided to continue searching for the spork killer.

Day 2 Begins!
Deadline is 6 days away (saturday night)

[Commander9]

Good, no one died - perfect. That means we do have a doctor around... Do we have a cop to share any results?

[edocsil]

Good, no one died - perfect. That means we do have a doctor around... Do we have a cop to share any results?

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

[VioIet]

If i have to take the heat for hammering, so be it.

Seriously, someone had to do it.

If not, we'd still be on Day 1, arguing in circles.

Going to continue on with my hunch from yesterday.

Vote Fir

[Streaker]

So essentially we have two possibilities here

Nag for being so pushy for a lynch towards edocsil
edocsil for being so defensive

Considering we have just over 24 hours, I'm going to go with unvote? vote nagerous

This post is what bothers me about cena. We were heading towards a lynch, after which cena gives this speech about how it's gonna be either nag or edoc. Then cena vote's nag, effectively getting him lynched. I can see a divert of attention here, and I will

Vote cena

Also, great work doc

[Commander9]

I'd have to say that we've got to be really careful here, guys - if we mislynch today, it's a possible game over for the town. While I can definitely see where you're coming from with Cena, Streaker, Vio was the one who hammered nag.

[Commander9]

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

Actually, I thought a bit about this - since it's LyLo, wouldn't a good scum go for the easiest lynch (like here for vio) and try to quickly hammer the person without letting the town discuss?

I'm going to do something a bit different here - this coupled with what happened yesterday, I'm going to Vote Edoc.

[edocsil]

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

Actually, I thought a bit about this - since it's LyLo, wouldn't a good scum go for the easiest lynch (like here for vio) and try to quickly hammer the person without letting the town discuss?

I'm going to do something a bit different here - this coupled with what happened yesterday, I'm going to Vote Edoc.

God I had hoped that I wasn't going to have to defend myself today. With this whole c9 setup there is not much I can do to prove my innocence. The only thing that can really definitively prove my innocence is a cop investigation on me or a doc protect on me. Cop is obvious. Doc on the other hand may not be, but you should be able to see that if I was protected last night I cannot be scum. With this I am not asking for the doc to stand up and say who he is, unless that is if I am about to be hung. I am just saying make a strong case on someone else if you want to have a decent shot at winning.

[Commander9]

God I had hoped that I wasn't going to have to defend myself today. With this whole c9 setup there is not much I can do to prove my innocence. The only thing that can really definitively prove my innocence is a cop investigation on me or a doc protect on me. Cop is obvious. Doc on the other hand may not be, but you should be able to see that if I was protected last night I cannot be scum. With this I am not asking for the doc to stand up and say who he is, unless that is if I am about to be hung. I am just saying make a strong case on someone else if you want to have a decent shot at winning.

That is IF you were targeted, but yes, if you were targeted, you can't be scum - that is correct. The only reason why I brought that up is that I just thought it's rather suspicious that you went straight on vio and you said that you didn't care to let her speak. I still find that hammer incredibly scummy, but it just felt like you were going for the obvious and easiest lynch.

[edocsil]

Good, no one died - perfect. That means we do have a doctor around... Do we have a cop to share any results?

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

Where in here do I say anything about not giving here fair chance to reply? FoS Commander

[Streaker]

I have a hunch about edoc, and I think he is speaking the truth. The focus, imo, should be aimed at either cena or Vio.
Cena for redirecting a case towards nag, who turned out to be a VT, or Vio for hammering. If it's a choice between these 2, Cena stands out because Vio can hide behind the pressure of a deadline.

If anything, now is the time to investigate other possible leads. When deadline approaches, and nothing better is found, we can still go for edoc. I don't see the point in discussing him any further, when we have limited time and other suspicious players around.

[Commander9]

Where in here do I say anything about not giving here fair chance to reply? FoS Commander

Bolded and sized exactly for you

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

I have a hunch about edoc, and I think he is speaking the truth. The focus, imo, should be aimed at either cena or Vio.
Cena for redirecting a case towards nag, who turned out to be a VT, or Vio for hammering. If it's a choice between these 2, Cena stands out because Vio can hide behind the pressure of a deadline.

If anything, now is the time to investigate other possible leads. When deadline approaches, and nothing better is found, we can still go for edoc. I don't see the point in discussing him any further, when we have limited time and other suspicious players around.

There's truth here - and I am okay with trying those as well. I'll mainly do this for one reason - if edoc isn't scum, I'm pretty sure the doc targeted either him or me (perhaps a very small chance on streaker), so there's a good chance he's not lying. I'll still keep an eye on you ( UNVOTE ), but better not mess up your story.

In a way we've reach an impasse here (cul de sac, if you will) - we know that a doctor can clear someone, but if the doctor ousts himself and we don't get a scum, we're done for.

[edocsil]

Where in here do I say anything about not giving here fair chance to reply? FoS Commander

Bolded and sized exactly for you

Thank god for a doc. Gives us so much more time.

Barring a cop coming in with a guilty investigation I will go with VOTE VIO. I care not at all for how she hammered yesterday.

I think there may be a language barrier. That means that I didn't like how she hammered nag yesterday, not that I want to do the same to her.

[Commander9]

I think there may be a language barrier. That means that I didn't like how she hammered nag yesterday, not that I want to do the same to her.

If that's what you meant, apologies - give me some time and I'll learn all these intricacies of this language And I got just a bit different translation, but the ending meaning was the same.

[Streaker]

I'm glad you two made up

Now let's get back to business. In light of my previous post, I will

Vote cena

[VioIet]

I don't think there is any good reason for the doctor to out himself.

Also the doctor is not a watcher/tracker. It seems as though some of these posts are implying that he is. Lets say the doctor saved Bob, and the mafia had targeted Bob. Knowing that still doesn't do us any good- except that we know Bob is most likely not mafia. Whoever the doctor is knows that- and I'm sure will proceed Bob in a subtle way, if he is ever to come under scrutiny.

Doctor still doesn't have a clue who is mafia anymore than we do. So I think the doctor outing himself won't help us one bit. The cop is probably also staying quiet for similar reasons. I think the cop investigated someone who turned up innocent- and will also subtly defend them. Only reason they would probably come out is if they found mafia. They haven't, so they aren't.

[Commander9]

I don't think there is any good reason for the doctor to out himself.

Also the doctor is not a watcher/tracker. It seems as though some of these posts are implying that he is. Lets say the doctor saved Bob, and the mafia had targeted Bob. Knowing that still doesn't do us any good- except that we know Bob is most likely not mafia. Whoever the doctor is knows that- and I'm sure will proceed Bob in a subtle way, if he is ever to come under scrutiny.

Doctor still doesn't have a clue who is mafia anymore than we do. So I think the doctor outing himself won't help us one bit. The cop is probably also staying quiet for similar reasons. I think the cop investigated someone who turned up innocent- and will also subtly defend them. Only reason they would probably come out is if they found mafia. They haven't, so they aren't.

No one said that doctor should out himself?

Also, cena, Fir - got something to say?

[edocsil]

I'm glad you two made up

Now let's get back to business. In light of my previous post, I will

Vote cena

Yea, but cena is really the only reason I am alive. If he was scum (this does assume we are not both the scum) he would have just joined the party at my house. Would have remained totally incognito.

[Commander9]

Yea, but cena is really the only reason I am alive. If he was scum (this does assume we are not both the scum) he would have just joined the party at my house. Would have remained totally incognito.

But wouldn't it be smart from a mafia to defend one of the townies like that? I'm not saying that he's scum, but I'm not saying that he's safe either.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote Count
vio (1) - edoc
fircoal (1) - vio
cena (1) - streaker

6 alive, 4 to lynch
deadline saturday

[edocsil]

Yea, but cena is really the only reason I am alive. If he was scum (this does assume we are not both the scum) he would have just joined the party at my house. Would have remained totally incognito.

But wouldn't it be smart from a mafia to defend one of the townies like that? I'm not saying that he's scum, but I'm not saying that he's safe either.

Was going to call WIFOM, but I think you are right here. If you "know" enough information there will always be something that you know or assume to be true, will actually in turn be false.

[Commander9]

Was going to call WIFOM, but I think you are right here. If you "know" enough information there will always be something that you know or assume to be true, will actually in turn be false.

Isn't this the game, though? Mafia is based on WIFOM and the doctor managed to save the kill on WIFOM. The key here is to have a good balance - and I don't think my suggestion is too far fetched either.

[VioIet]

The case on cena is good, but I still believe that Fir is more suspicious than cena.

Also fir was not on Naggy's wagon, which I think is telling.

And I do believe someone wanted to Doc to come out and say who he protected last night. I was saying it would probably be best for the doctor to say nothing.