Interesting Mafia! GAME OVER ~ MAFIA WINS ~

[dazza2008]

Yeah. I don't get why everyone worries so much about getting someone to L-1. If there is a hammer out of the blue it would most certainly be scum who did it so whats the worry?

[BGtheBrain]

****

[dazza2008]

Yeah. I don't get why everyone worries so much about getting someone to L-1. If there is a hammer out of the blue it would most certainly be scum who did it so whats the worry?

Could be hated townie, or there could be a doublevoter.

L-1 can easily lead to an "Accidental lynch"

Good points.

[soundman]

Yeah. I don't get why everyone worries so much about getting someone to L-1. If there is a hammer out of the blue it would most certainly be scum who did it so whats the worry?

Actually in Gangster griftron, who was town, hammered another townie because he got impatient. So not all hammers are done by scum. It cost us valuable information as the townie ended up being the tracker.

[spiesr]

If there is a hammer out of the blue it would most certainly be scum who did it so whats the worry?

Not exactly, if someone prematurely hammers it means that are being stupid, not necessarily that they are scum. They could be scum stupidly trying to kill of a townies, they could simply not be paying attention and not know they are hammer, they could simply be stupid and just want to hurry things along. There are several possibilities, not all of them actually mean that the person who hammered is scum. (Smart scum would think twice being prematurely hammering unless they are at LYLO.)

[dazza2008]

Yeah. I don't get why everyone worries so much about getting someone to L-1. If there is a hammer out of the blue it would most certainly be scum who did it so whats the worry?

Actually in Gangster griftron, who was town, hammered another townie because he got impatient. So not all hammers are done by scum. It cost us valuable information as the townie ended up being the tracker.

Oh yeah I remember that. Its nearly always scum or just poor play though.

[MoB Deadly]

Day 1 - Vote Count 8

(1) AndyDufresne - Gilligan
BGtheBrain -
dazza2008 -
edocsil -
(1) Gilligan - Victor Sullivan,
Iron Butterfly -
Leehar -
(4, L-3) shieldgenerator7 - spiesr, dazza2008, BGtheBrain, soundman
soundman -
spiesr -
(1) thehippo8 - Iron Butterfly
(1) Victor Sullivan - edocsil
zimmah -

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to Lynch or No Lynch.

[AndyDufresne]

Who is next for a prod by MOB Deadly? It looks like edocsil maybe. He's made 3 posts during the 'game stage' (after confirmations), but they were all on December 1st I think, the start of the event.

That's mine line, off with your HEAD! VOTE SULLY

Iduno, that's going out on a bit of a limb there..

Unvote Andy Vote Hippo

For thinking we would miss that he is a double voter.

What?

--Andy

[zimmah]

I think Gilligan's 'that was close' was referring to the fact that ShieldGenerator was 1 vote away from a lynch.


--Andy

yes, but sg7 posted after him, so why was he assumed "it WAS close (as in SG7 is save) if sg7 didn't even show up to save himself in the first place?

i assume he's somehow masoned with sg7 (either 3rd party mason, town mason, or same mafia group) and sg7 talked with him before he posted in the topic or something.

[zimmah]

Who is next for a prod by MOB Deadly? It looks like edocsil maybe. He's made 3 posts during the 'game stage' (after confirmations), but they were all on December 1st I think, the start of the event.

That's mine line, off with your HEAD! VOTE SULLY

Iduno, that's going out on a bit of a limb there..

Unvote Andy Vote Hippo

For thinking we would miss that he is a double voter.

What?

--Andy

i'll vote sg7 again since he never actually claimed or said anything construtive. he's basicly still scummarining.

[AndyDufresne]

I think Gilligan's 'that was close' was referring to the fact that ShieldGenerator was 1 vote away from a lynch.


--Andy

yes, but sg7 posted after him, so why was he assumed "it WAS close (as in SG7 is save) if sg7 didn't even show up to save himself in the first place?

i assume he's somehow masoned with sg7 (either 3rd party mason, town mason, or same mafia group) and sg7 talked with him before he posted in the topic or something.

I thought the 'was,' was in reference to the fact that you and hippo 'unvoted', thus moving Shieldgenerator away from lynch some, and since he posted after your and hippo's unvote, hence the past tense.


--Andy

[BGtheBrain]

****

[spiesr]

I assume he's somehow masoned with sg7 (either 3rd party mason, town mason, or same mafia group) and sg7 talked with him before he posted in the topic or something.

I don't know how Mob does things, but normally mafia, and masons or anyone else you can talk, are only supposed to communicate during the night phase...

[MoB Deadly]

Day 1 - Vote Count 9

(1) AndyDufresne - Gilligan
BGtheBrain -
dazza2008 -
edocsil -
(1) Gilligan - Victor Sullivan,
Iron Butterfly -
Leehar -
(5, L-2) shieldgenerator7 - spiesr, dazza2008, BGtheBrain, soundman, zimmah
soundman -
spiesr -
(1) thehippo8 - Iron Butterfly
(1) Victor Sullivan - edocsil
zimmah -

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to Lynch or No Lynch.

Who is next for a prod by MOB Deadly? It looks like edocsil maybe. He's made 3 posts during the 'game stage' (after confirmations), but they were all on December 1st I think, the start of the event.

Prodding edoc.

[edocsil]

Gah, I got prodded. Anyhow her and reading. I don't joke vote much during finals season. Anyhow, I ate a banana today and it made me sick. It is Andys fault. Unvote Vote Andy

[Gilligan]

I assume he's somehow masoned with sg7 (either 3rd party mason, town mason, or same mafia group) and sg7 talked with him before he posted in the topic or something.

I don't know how Mob does things, but normally mafia, and masons or anyone else you can talk, are only supposed to communicate during the night phase...

I think this is a rule for all games. Myself and shield have had no contact in the past, I don't know how long...

yes, but sg7 posted after him, so why was he assumed "it WAS close (as in SG7 is save) if sg7 didn't even show up to save himself in the first place?

I said that after votes were taken off of shield.

[Victor Sullivan]

I'll give shield a day. He needs to get in here.

-Sully

[AndyDufresne]

Gah, I got prodded. Anyhow her and reading. I don't joke vote much during finals season. Anyhow, I ate a banana today and it made me sick. It is Andys fault. Unvote Vote Andy

Ha, welcome back to this game. :D


--Andy

[thehippo8]

Day has come and gone ... unvote vote sg7

[MoB Deadly]

Day 1 - Vote Count 10

(2) AndyDufresne - Gilligan, edocsil
BGtheBrain -
dazza2008 -
edocsil -
(1) Gilligan - Victor Sullivan,
Iron Butterfly -
Leehar -
(6, L-1) shieldgenerator7 - spiesr, dazza2008, BGtheBrain, soundman, zimmah, thehippo8
soundman -
spiesr -
(1) thehippo8 - Iron Butterfly
Victor Sullivan -
zimmah -

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to Lynch or No Lynch.

[Victor Sullivan]

Hm, it's a day later, but it's not hammer-time. Sorry, MC... What? We can't just hammer him without a claim!

-Sully

[soundman]

Hm, it's a day later, but it's not hammer-time. Sorry, MC... What? We can't just hammer him without a claim!

-Sully

I agree. We need a claim or a replacement. Unvote So no one hammers him cause they were impatient.

[thehippo8]

I'll give shield a day. He needs to get in here.

-Sully

Please define ... "day"

Click image to enlarge.

[BGtheBrain]

****

[MoB Deadly]

As a mod I still don't know what to do in this situation. He is inactive in other mafia games as well (Christmas Mafia). However he responded to my prod with a check-in. Do I make the executive decision here and decide he should be replaced? Or is that unfair to SG7 because he has intentions of coming back? Other mods please advise.

fast posted by BG