[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

[AladdinSane]

Interesting list. Promise to look to this list after the night...

I have one better:

Self called circle of trust, or scummy compadres:

• WingCmdr
• Storr
• IB
• benga
• ptlowe

No one in the "circle of trust" is denying it, though I debate Benga's inclusion. So why state it? How about you scumhunt rather than post pointless comments. You havent responded to Storr yet.

Wot I don't get about dis cerkul-jerk of trust - and I have asked Storr about dis awready and he failed to anser - is teh basis on witch you lot trust eech other. Sounds more like a fackshun in sekret communicashun to me, maybe even Mafia.

[AladdinSane]

Addendumb:

It seems orfully erly (N2) to claim to have a solid basis for trusting sumwun.

[rizky_biznezz]

Sorry guys I have a visitor staying I haven't been able to read everything or make a post.. I received an apple too anyone have any suggestions on which way to go

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Addendumb:

It seems orfully erly (N2) to claim to have a solid basis for trusting sumwun.

For my part, I have played with those three a fair bit.

PTLowe claimed cop early without prompting in a genuine way, niave but genuine.
Storr is the subject of a copcheck, until the investigation is shown to be false I must assume it to be correct.
IB's day 1 play makes most sense as town.

Thus I am not in a rush to lynch any of these. As you can see the term trust is overrated, I do not trust any of them completely. I only know one persons alignment.

If I play solo i become insane and paranoid, I trust their opinion and that theyll keep me on the right track.

Note that although I strongly believe Mtam and Rage to be town I do not use them as a sounding board in the same way.

@Rizky - I will probably go for option 1 as its more fun!

[Ragian]

Surely, he would flip cult, then..?

I get only these results:
town, antitown, no result

don't know what else could it be then cult...

HS was also 3rd party that can win only with town eliminated?

Not talking about your results, but what he flipped when lynched.

Anyway, we know that we can believe Benga's result.

FP'ed

3rd party are not protown. They are 3rd party. I haven't seen any "protown" results on non-town players ever (barring a naive/insane cop, but that's not the issue here).

Okay, thanks. Chork dat one up to inexperiense. So, it is never teh case that a 3P's wincon coincides wit Town's wincon? I was unner the impreshun that cood happen, but okay if I was mistaken about that, I accept it.

FP'ed Storr

when I said flipped I thought if he joined cult over night and IB investigated him over night so he was still town...

but not sure if cult is a possiblity, just a thought

You lost me. Maybe I don't understand your post. Could you help out an old man?

Falko - how about you add yourself to that list seeing as you havent made any statements here.

Beat me to it
Also apple here.

[ptlowe]

Who else has recieved an apple from the orchard?

I did. What we gonna do?

[ptlowe]

"

I dont get you Wing.First you want to hunt scum now you are second guessing me on stupid shit? I seem to be the whiping boy this game. Neat distraction.

You start the game by holding a random player up for lynch and you expect md not to question it? It doesnt make sense.

Scum Rollcall, thoughts please (from all)

Aladdin
DJPatrick
Player
CatchersMitt
Falko
/ slash
Deg
White Rose

(in rough order)

I agree on Aladdin, DJ, falko, twr, deg

I'd add mets to the list

The others I'll have to review

[degaston]

I got an apple. Feeling kind of hungry,

@DJPatrick:

And don't forget, night talk IS allowed.

[Iron Butterfly]

several of us have received an Apple from the Orchard, freshly harvested.

We have two choices, eat it or pass. and we are aloud to discuss this gift.

Two things. Mitch mentioned the orchard as well as well as several other things. He can not be everything. I think he is here to help Town now. He has known about Mailman, me getting gifted and the Orchard by name. I think the mod gives him info he has to share while acting crazy. Thats the way I see it with him.

Second Apples have never been healthy eating in mythology. Adam and Eve and Snow White come to mind. We have 48 hours to decide so perhaps one of us can test? Hah my gut screams NOOooooo but I wanna see what happens.

[Ragian]

We could do different things. See what happens.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Where did Mitch mention the orchard? That would make a difference.

I'd suggest that IB does eat it whilst PTlowe does not due to their respective expendability.

The rest of us? Am not sure.

[AladdinSane]

Two things. Mitch mentioned the orchard as well as well as several other things. He can not be everything. I think he is here to help Town now. He has known about Mailman, me getting gifted and the Orchard by name. I think the mod gives him info he has to share while acting crazy. Thats the way I see it with him.

Second Apples have never been healthy eating in mythology. Adam and Eve and Snow White come to mind. We have 48 hours to decide so perhaps one of us can test? Hah my gut screams NOOooooo but I wanna see what happens.[/quotemailma]

IB, I tink you mite have awreddy eeten yer appul an it made you ferget stuff LOL:

It was a restless night. While most players tried to get some sleep, it was hard finding any because loud voices were heard during the entire night.
That was not all that happened. The villagers could feel the effect of the -4 votes fade away, and something new settle in it's place. They couldn't quite define what it was just yet, but they would find out soon enough anyway. A mailman was also spotted coming into the town. Where was he going?
Near the town, the Apple Orchard seemed almost ready for the harvest.

Frum teh intro to D2...

[degaston]

Mine was from a nice old lady. What could be the harm in taking a bite?

A mailman was also spotted coming into the town. Where was he going?
Near the town, the Apple Orchard seemed almost ready for the harvest.

Then:

Well it looks like I.B. might have got his message from the mailman, I wonder how many new messages went out ? and who the mailman is? The orchard is right for a fruit vendor and I wonder what that will cost ? This day is already being a nice cheerful and informative day .

I think Mitch was just riffing on the D2 message, and when he mentioned IB, he was talking about the information he had about HotShot from D1, and knew nothing about the package that was delivered on N1. His apple orchard reference is nothing specific.

[CatchersMitt14]

I receved an apple too. At the miment I'm inclined to eat it out of curiostiy. My murr thoughtful side thinks we should pobibky split up who aetes it who doesn't.

[degaston]

FP'ed by Aladdin, who needs to learn to use preview.

[AladdinSane]

Two things. Mitch mentioned the orchard as well as well as several other things. He can not be everything. I think he is here to help Town now. He has known about Mailman, me getting gifted and the Orchard by name. I think the mod gives him info he has to share while acting crazy. Thats the way I see it with him.

Second Apples have never been healthy eating in mythology. Adam and Eve and Snow White come to mind. We have 48 hours to decide so perhaps one of us can test? Hah my gut screams NOOooooo but I wanna see what happens.

IB, I tink you mite have awreddy eeten yer appul an it made you ferget stuff LOL:

It was a restless night. While most players tried to get some sleep, it was hard finding any because loud voices were heard during the entire night. That was not all that happened. The villagers could feel the effect of the -4 votes fade away, and something new settle in it's place. They couldn't quite define what it was just yet, but they would find out soon enough anyway. A mailman was also spotted coming into the town. Where was he going?
Near the town, the Apple Orchard seemed almost ready for the harvest.

Frum teh intro to D2...

[AladdinSane]

FP'ed by Aladdin, who needs to learn to use preview.

Teh sad ting is dat I used preview dis time, and I still funked it up.

[degaston]

I agree that we should not all do the same thing, I'm wondering if it is better to claim who is going to eat, or keep it a secret?

[degaston]

I realize that if we keep it a secret, it might be difficult to ensure that we don't all do the same thing.

[Ragian]

Well, I ate mine.

[CatchersMitt14]

So fare these are the people wgo claimed to receve an apple. We have 48 hours to mayke our decision. Is it possible the effects could be shown quickely and before the deadline? For exampke, I send in my choice now and we possibley get a response before the majority have to make a deciskion?

Wing
Falkomango
rizky
Ragian
ptlowe
degaston
Iron Butterfly
CatchersMitt14

[AladdinSane]

Well it looks like I.B. might have got his message from the mailman, I wonder how many new messages went out ? and who the mailman is? The orchard is right for a fruit vendor and I wonder what that will cost ? This day is already being a nice cheerful and informative day .

Hear is the post frum Mitch dat is corsing so mutch confusion. I tink it is just Mitch's vershun of a deduckshun. He is putting menshun of the mailman in the D2 intro together wit IB's misterius info about HS on D1, and putting too and too together to get five - i.e. concluding dat dis mailman delivered IB's info about HS.

I dont tink dis indicates prior knowledge by Mitch of IB's gift, and so does not corroborate IB's story about teh 8-borl.

[AladdinSane]

So fare these are the people wgo claimed to receve an apple. We have 48 hours to mayke our decision. Is it possible the effects could be shown quickely and before the deadline? For exampke, I send in my choice now and we possibley get a response before the majority have to make a deciskion?

Wing
Falkomango
rizky
Ragian
ptlowe
degaston
Iron Butterfly
CatchersMitt14

Wot makes you tink the results will be uniform?

[StorrZerg]

Add me to the list.
I has apple

[CatchersMitt14]

So fare these are the people wgo claimed to receve an apple. We have 48 hours to mayke our decision. Is it possible the effects could be shown quickely and before the deadline? For exampke, I send in my choice now and we possibley get a response before the majority have to make a deciskion?

Wing
Falkomango
rizky
Ragian
ptlowe
degaston
Iron Butterfly
CatchersMitt14

Wot makes you tink the results will be uniform?

Not a danm ting. Itz quite possible in my mind that rezults could be completely radium. But in my opinion we should at least atempt to determine the rezults. These apples seem reminiscent of the 8-ball currrently.