Nostalgia Mafia ~ Commander wins!

[edocsil]

EDIT:
Edoc, I'm pretty sure we all already know that there is no cop and I honestly don't think you could manipulate scumming into assuming that role.

Well now I certainly won't.

[Commander9]

EDIT:
Edoc, I'm pretty sure we all already know that there is no cop and I honestly don't think you could manipulate scumming into assuming that role.

Well now I certainly won't.

Well, vio, you and Safari had already claimed VT's, so it wouldn't make any sense for them to claim that. So, at least from my point of view, this was mostly directed at me. I've also already hinted at who I am, so this was sort of desperate.

[edocsil]

Alright, vote saf. We know it is going to happen today so why wait?. Your move commander, are we right or are we wrong?

[Commander9]

Alright, vote saf. We know it is going to happen today so why wait?. Your move commander, are we right or are we wrong?

Should I hammer? I wouldn't mind discussing this a bit more, but I guess this is inevitable. I just really hope you won't turn out to have been manipulating us all along.

[edocsil]

Alright, vote saf. We know it is going to happen today so why wait?. Your move commander, are we right or are we wrong?

Should I hammer? I wouldn't mind discussing this a bit more, but I guess this is inevitable. I just really hope you won't turn out to have been manipulating us all along.

yes *crosses fingers* it is him or vio, and the case is stronger against him.

[Commander9]

Vote Safari.

Well, I guess we will know the outcome soon enough.

[Mr. Squirrel]

The town members really wanted to go back to their boring lives. They were desperate and quickly strung up the first person they thought was scummy.

safariguy - VT has been lynched!

Night 4 begins!
this should end pretty quickly...

[edocsil]

Shoot. So was it Vio then? Btw Mr. S I probably would have just endgamed both the townies at this point.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Shoot. So was it Vio then? Btw Mr. S I probably would have just endgamed both the townies at this point.

Yea, I couldve but whatever.

Vio - VT has been killed!

Edocsil - VT has been endgamed!

COmmander - Mafia goon has won!!!!!!!!!!

[Commander9]

Good game, all. It was most enjoyable and I hope I can continue my learning curve upwards.

(my first ever win as mafia - 1/3 now).

EDIT: Shouldn't fir have won as well?

[safariguy5]

Damn, I guess me siding with the chu got me killed. Nice one Commander.

[edocsil]

Good game, all. It was most enjoyable and I hope I can continue my learning curve upwards.

(my first ever win as mafia - 1/3 now).

EDIT: Shouldn't fir have won as well?

No. he must live to win. Why waffle when you could have just quick lynched safari? I do not understand. And facepalm Saf, why did you defend Fir so hard. You must have known what would have happened if he flipped Scum.

[safariguy5]

Good game, all. It was most enjoyable and I hope I can continue my learning curve upwards.

(my first ever win as mafia - 1/3 now).

EDIT: Shouldn't fir have won as well?

No. he must live to win. Why waffle when you could have just quick lynched safari? I do not understand. And facepalm Saf, why did you defend Fir so hard. You must have known what would have happened if he flipped Scum.

I didn't defend Fir that hard. I was just convinced that Vio was the better target. And correct me if I'm wrong, allegedly wasn't cena defending you the main reason you thought him to be town. I seriously was bothered by vio's psuedojoke claim and thought she was the better lynch target. And therefore you guys jumping on Fir for pushing for her lynch was not justified to me. Commander must have loved the distraction though.

[safariguy5]

Good game, all. It was most enjoyable and I hope I can continue my learning curve upwards.

(my first ever win as mafia - 1/3 now).

EDIT: Shouldn't fir have won as well?

No. he must live to win. Why waffle when you could have just quick lynched safari? I do not understand. And facepalm Saf, why did you defend Fir so hard. You must have known what would have happened if he flipped Scum.

Wait really? Scum have to live to win but town don't have to? I always say the faction won in my games whether or not they all lived (impossible for town, very difficult for scum).

[Commander9]

No. he must live to win. Why waffle when you could have just quick lynched safari? I do not understand. And facepalm Saf, why did you defend Fir so hard. You must have known what would have happened if he flipped Scum.

Well, there was an outside possibility that Streaker wasn't the doc and if there would have been no kill, it would've looked bad. Second of all, I really enjoyed the game and I was planning to hammer, but then Fir went... crazy. Oh well...

[nagerous]

He went crazy, because you didn't hammer. If you hammered Vio at that moment, the game would've been won for the mafia. He was asking you to hammer so you guys could win! Why were you wasting so much time, there was no point you were sitting about on the fence at that moment - the game was won! (Your NK that night for the win was secured as streaker was obv the doc)

[Fircoal]

Good game, all. It was most enjoyable and I hope I can continue my learning curve upwards.

(my first ever win as mafia - 1/3 now).

EDIT: Shouldn't fir have won as well?

No. he must live to win. Why waffle when you could have just quick lynched safari? I do not understand. And facepalm Saf, why did you defend Fir so hard. You must have known what would have happened if he flipped Scum.

Wait really? Scum have to live to win but town don't have to? I always say the faction won in my games whether or not they all lived (impossible for town, very difficult for scum).

No scum don't have to live to win. Otherwise it would hard for scum to get anything done. To further it my pm:

You are Scum! Your mafia buddy is Commander9. You may talk to each other at night. The mafia may make one kill every night. You win when your numbers equal the town numbers.

Read bolded. The mafia numbers equal the town numbers. Thusly I have won. There's nothing in there about staying alive. ;3

[Commander9]

He went crazy, because you didn't hammer. If you hammered Vio at that moment, the game would've been won for the mafia. He was asking you to hammer so you guys could win! Why were you wasting so much time, there was no point you were sitting about on the fence at that moment - the game was won! (Your NK that night for the win was secured as streaker was obv the doc)

I was only around 90% sure at that time and I didn't want to throw it away.

[Fircoal]

He went crazy, because you didn't hammer. If you hammered Vio at that moment, the game would've been won for the mafia. He was asking you to hammer so you guys could win! Why were you wasting so much time, there was no point you were sitting about on the fence at that moment - the game was won! (Your NK that night for the win was secured as streaker was obv the doc)

What Naggy said.

Just a question to the rest of town, but why do you think I was trying to coax Commander to hammer? Do you really think that I am ballsy enough to put myself on the line to try to get a townie to end the game? The only reason I did that was the game was supposed to be over after Commander got my hint and hammered. It wouldn't have mattered! I'm not silly enough to try to do that to someone whom has no motive to do so. After he didn't know it my emotions started to kick in big time.

[nagerous]

He went crazy, because you didn't hammer. If you hammered Vio at that moment, the game would've been won for the mafia. He was asking you to hammer so you guys could win! Why were you wasting so much time, there was no point you were sitting about on the fence at that moment - the game was won! (Your NK that night for the win was secured as streaker was obv the doc)

I was only around 90% sure at that time and I didn't want to throw it away.

It wouldn't have been thrown away, safari could still have got easily lynched the next phase if by chance streaker wasn't the doctor. Also, I don't think streaker would have been the top choice for the doctor protection anyway, he was also on the Vio wagon. You basically threw your scum buddy under the bus, wasn't the right call and should've just hammered.

[Commander9]

It wouldn't have been thrown away, safari could still have got easily lynched the next phase if by chance streaker wasn't the doctor. Also, I don't think streaker would have been the top choice for the doctor protection anyway, he was also on the Vio wagon. You basically threw your scum buddy under the bus, wasn't the right call and should've just hammered.

Yet again, with all due respect, I disagree. First of all, Fir should technically win with me, so it doesn't matter. Secondly, say that Streaker wasn't doc and he also was targeted for doc protection. We'd have had 3/2 LyLo with me hammering a townie after Fir advocating for lynch. Both of us would have looked really scummy (like Fir/Safari looked now) and we'd probably have been lynched both. While the chances were low, they were there.

Just because a person has a different way of playing doesn't mean that your way is right and the other person is wrong.

[Fircoal]

It wouldn't have been thrown away, safari could still have got easily lynched the next phase if by chance streaker wasn't the doctor. Also, I don't think streaker would have been the top choice for the doctor protection anyway, he was also on the Vio wagon. You basically threw your scum buddy under the bus, wasn't the right call and should've just hammered.

Yet again, with all due respect, I disagree. First of all, Fir should technically win with me, so it doesn't matter. Secondly, say that Streaker wasn't doc and he also was targeted for doc protection. We'd have had 3/2 LyLo with me hammering a townie after Fir advocating for lynch. Both of us would have looked really scummy (like Fir/Safari looked now) and we'd probably have been lynched both. While the chances were low, they were there.

Just because a person has a different way of playing doesn't mean that your way is right and the other person is wrong.

I do have to agree that if we were wrong we'd be fffed, however I was sure that a) I was right and b) Edoc was the cop and found Safari as town, so that even if we were wrong it wouldn't matter anyway. However b turned out to be false. Thusly I was trying to get it done.

[Commander9]

I do have to agree that if we were wrong we'd be fffed, however I was sure that a) I was right and b) Edoc was the cop and found Safari as town, so that even if we were wrong it wouldn't matter anyway. However b turned out to be false. Thusly I was trying to get it done.

I'm not blaming you and I can understand your impatience and anxiety. I wanted to be sure and I wanted to wait just 1 more day, but... Oh well, we still won

[Streaker]

Should I hammer? I wouldn't mind discussing this a bit more, but I guess this is inevitable. I just really hope you won't turn out to have been manipulating us all along.

You sun of a scum

I think commander actually played this really well. He had close to 0 suspicion on him, and he played all of town like he had strings attached. If you reread it, it's quite funny
Like the quote above, there are a few other nice ones from the puppetmaster.
He made a mistake not hammering instantly and winning the game, but he DID win. Hell, if you can afford to throw your only scummate under a bus and still win

MrSquirrell, thank you for hosting. I really enjoyed it, and believe I have learned a few things. Also i'd like to ask you, or anyone else, to host another one of these.
They are very interesting games after all. Quick, and fun.

[Mr. Squirrel]

MrSquirrell, thank you for hosting. I really enjoyed it, and believe I have learned a few things. Also i'd like to ask you, or anyone else, to host another one of these.
They are very interesting games after all. Quick, and fun.

It was fun to do. My next game probably won't be another C9 game, but it will be smaller with some vanillas. I've had a great idea for a game in my head for a while so eventually I will host that.

Also, yes technically fircoal won despite his backstabbing teammate.